Up, down or out: As spring training nears, a look at baseball’s window treatment

It’s such an inviting word: window. Just look at those first three letters. Everyone wants to win, right? As spring training opens this week, in Florida and Arizona, there’s powerful symbolism in opening a window to a new season, drinking in the blue sky and dreaming of the best.

Executives are more realistic. Under the last collective bargaining agreement, and the new one reached last fall, Major League Baseball is designed for teams to win and lose in cycles. Only the savviest organizations find a way to contend every year. Most understand that they have a distinct window to win — and that once it closes, it’s time to nail boards over the glass and remodel.

Free agency looms after 2018 for so many star players — Bryce Harper, Manny Machado, Josh Donaldson, Zach Britton, Andrew Miller, Andrew McCutchen, Matt Harvey and possibly Clayton Kershaw and David Price. More than ever, perhaps, teams feel urgency to win or risk a long wait for another legitimate shot.

With that in mind, let’s take a spin around the majors to see which teams’ windows are open, opening, closing or closed.

Los Angeles Angels: OPEN

Maybe they’re kidding themselves, but the Angels haven’t acted like a team in retreat. With Albert Pujols still slugging and Mike Trout still sublime, they have quietly improved the lineup with Danny Espinosa, Cameron Maybin and Luis Valbuena, players whose defense should prop up a shaky pitching staff. It’s a long shot, but with Trout in his prime and few top prospects coming, the Angels are going for it.

Houston Astros: OPEN

The Astros are 46 games over .500 the last two seasons ... when not playing the Texas Rangers. They’re 10-28 against Texas, a string of futility that has probably kept them from winning the American League West. They’ll have another good chance this season, with an impressive blend of youth and veterans. One more solid starter and they might win the first World Series in franchise history.

Oakland Athletics: CLOSED

It’s startling how little the A’s have gotten from their farm system, especially for a team that relies on low-cost talent. As they wait to develop their own stars, they’ll continue to patch with castoffs and make the best deals they can. They badly need Sonny Gray to regain his All-Star status, if only to rebuild his trade value.

Toronto Blue Jays: CLOSING

The Blue Jays lost their top run producer, Edwin Encarnacion, to the Cleveland Indians — the team that just beat them in the American League Championship Series. It was the second ALCS loss in a row for Toronto, and another of their sluggers, Jose Bautista, will be 37 by the World Series. With Josh Donaldson, their star third baseman, under control for just two more years, the Blue Jays are running out of chances with this core.

Atlanta Braves: OPENING

Twenty-three years after his Cleveland team opened a new ballpark ready to contend, John Hart is doing something similar in Atlanta. Hart, president of baseball operations, doesn’t have as much high-impact young talent now as he did then. But the Braves’ veterans should keep the team mildly competitive as they race the Phillies to see who can rise quickest from the depths of the National League East.

Milwaukee Brewers: CLOSED

The Brewers fell two games shy of the World Series in 2011, then tried to stay relevant by spending big for mid-level free agent pitching. It was a noble effort, but they’re back on their best path, collecting as many prospects as possible. It seems to be working: Last month, ESPN’s Keith Law ranked Milwaukee sixth in the majors in farm system talent.

St. Louis Cardinals: OPEN

In St. Louis, the window never closes. In the first 17 seasons of the 2000s, the Cardinals have had 16 winning seasons, 12 playoff appearances, four pennants and two World Series titles. They poached Dexter Fowler from the champion Cubs, and if Alex Reyes emerges as a star, they may have the pitching to challenge in the National League Central.

Chicago Cubs: OPEN

The Cubs, newly crowned as World Series champions, do have a few potential free agents: Jake Arrieta, John Lackey, the new closer Wade Davis. But they’re so flush with cash and prospects, and their front office makes such sound decisions, that they should easily fill any hole. With so many players in their primes, another pennant or two seems almost inevitable before this group breaks up.

Arizona Diamondbacks: OPEN

Their window was open last season, but Arizona still found a way to crash through plate glass. After overpaying in dollars for Zack Greinke and players for Shelby Miller, they stumbled to 93 losses and fired their general manager and manager. But as the team tries desperately to win with Paul Goldschmidt, who is under its control through 2019, the window is still open.

Los Angeles Dodgers: OPEN

The record for consecutive division titles without reaching a World Series is six, by the Braves from 2000-05, so there’s precedent for the Dodgers’ current streak of four. At least they have the talent and money to keep trying. After bringing back Kenley Jansen, Justin Turner and Rich Hill and trading for Logan Forsythe, the Dodgers should someday give Clayton Kershaw the World Series spotlight he deserves. But the wait seems interminable.

San Francisco Giants: OPEN

With three championships and just one losing season in the last eight years, the Giants have earned this distinction; they’re a perennial contender until proven otherwise. But there’s reason for mild concern, since Johnny Cueto can opt for free agency this fall and Buster Posey, who turns 30 next month, just caught a career-high 123 games. Signing a solid backup catcher, the veteran Nick Hundley, was a subtle and wise move.

Cleveland Indians: OPEN

After losing to the Cubs in Game 7 of the World Series, Cleveland has the sport’s longest title drought, at 69 years. The good thing is that no team understands windows as do the Indians, who know they won’t get many chances like this. With sturdier pitching and Encarnacion in the middle of the lineup — joined, they hope, by a healthy Michael Brantley — the Indians are doing all they can for that elusive final victory.

Seattle Mariners: OPEN

Imagine a city with four soaring skyscrapers — and the rest of downtown constantly under construction. That’s the Mariners, who have Robinson Cano, Nelson Cruz, Kyle Seager, Felix Hernandez and a supporting cast in a feverish state of flux. Has Jerry Dipoto, their creative and freewheeling general manager, built something to last? We know he’ll keep trying.

Miami Marlins: CLOSING

With the Marlins, plans often change without notice. Their 13-year playoff drought is the longest in the National League and the front office could turn impatient if the team slumps past the All-Star Game, which will be played in Miami. For now the Marlins plan to win, adding depth to the pitching staff — Edinson Volquez, Dan Straily, Junichi Tazawa, Brad Ziegler — in hopes of replacing the irreplaceable: Jose Fernandez, who died in a boating accident last September.

New York Mets: OPEN

The Mets still seem rather tentative, retaining Yoenis Cespedes but mostly just hoping to win with the same group of mismatched position players and star-crossed pitchers that captured a wild card last year. If the starters stay healthy, the Mets have a good chance to reclaim the National League East. The hard part comes when those pitchers start to get too expensive. That hasn’t happened yet, so enjoy this while it lasts.

Washington Nationals: CLOSING

Because of significant salary deferrals, the Nationals will be paying their aces for many, many years — Max Scherzer through 2028 and Stephen Strasburg through 2030. Will they have a ring to show for it, or at least a playoff series victory? Time may be running out. Bryce Harper and Daniel Murphy, who anchor the middle of the lineup, are eligible for free agency after 2018.

Baltimore Orioles: CLOSING

The Orioles have the most victories in the American League over the last five seasons, yet have not won a game beyond the division series. Their best player (Manny Machado), their leader (Adam Jones) and the game’s best closer (Zach Britton) can all hit free agency after 2018 — and they still haven’t found an ace for the rotation.

San Diego Padres: CLOSED

The Padres might be as bland and uninspired as their navy-and-white uniforms. OK, that’s hyperbole — nothing could be that boring. Now the only team in town, the Padres have a sickly roster but are doing what general manager A.J. Preller does best: aggressively cultivating young talent. Someday it might pay off, but that day won’t come in 2017.

Pittsburgh Pirates: OPEN

It’s open, but only by the Pirates’ standards. Their creativity has been admirable, building a contender without ever guaranteeing a player more than McCutchen’s $51.5 million. But while they have years of control on their core position players, the Pirates have been unable — or unwilling — to find long-term dependability in their rotation. Without big strides by their homegrown starters, they seem destined to keep falling just short.

Philadelphia Phillies: OPENING

The Phillies were great for five years, then bad for five years. So if their window isn’t opening yet, it really should be. They just committed more than $60 million to six veterans — Joaquin Benoit, Clay Buchholz, Howie Kendrick, Pat Neshek, Michael Saunders and the returning Jeremy Hellickson — so they’d like to be respectable. But since all are unsigned past this season, they’re also prime trade bait as the Phillies continue to seek long-term assets.

Texas Rangers: CLOSING

For the sixth time in seven seasons, the Rangers played beyond Game 162. They went home empty yet again, swept in the division series when Toronto flattened their aces, Cole Hamels and Yu Darvish. Both are back, but Darvish is facing free agency and Adrian Beltre, the team’s heartbeat, will soon be 38. They could win this year, but maybe not much longer.

Tampa Bay Rays: OPENING

From 2008-13, Tampa Bay averaged almost 92 victories per season. They’ve had three losing records since, but the fun thing about the Rays is that they never fully retreat. While they did trade two veterans (Drew Smyly and Logan Forsythe), they have a dynamic young rotation and hit for enough power to scare you. They just might threaten for the playoffs again.

Boston Red Sox: OPEN

No team has as many young, high-impact position players as the Red Sox, with Mookie Betts, Xander Bogarts, Jackie Bradley Jr. and Andrew Benintendi. Their rotation has two Cy Young Award winners (David Price and Rick Porcello) and three 2016 All-Stars (Chris Sale, Steven Wright, Drew Pomeranz). So, yes, even without David Ortiz, this team is poised to win now, and for years to come.

Cincinnati Reds: CLOSED

The Reds need to find out what they have in the young infielders Jose Peraza and Dilson Herrera. Joey Votto is elite, but he’s signed for seven more years at an average of $22.5 million per season. The Reds might contend by the end of his deal, but this team will take a long time to fix.

Colorado Rockies: OPENING

After their sixth losing season in a row, the Rockies showed what they think of themselves by splurging for Ian Desmond, giving him $70 million for five years to shift to first base. They spent another $26 million on bullpen help in Greg Holland and Mike Dunn, supporting a young but talented rotation. There’s not much pitching depth, but if the Rockies stay healthy, their offense will lift them to contention.

Kansas City Royals: CLOSING

The Royals have always known when to strike and when to hold back. Their discipline to cultivate a certain style of play — and their patience to grow the right players to implement it — led to a title in 2015, boosted by bold deadline deals. They’re clinging to contention now, trading veterans (Wade Davis, Jarrod Dyson) but getting major leaguers, not prospects, in return. The death of Yordano Ventura in a car crash last month was devastating, but this is a resilient group that wants to win again before Lorenzo Cain, Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas test free agency next winter.

Detroit Tigers: CLOSING

It’s still amazing that the Tigers could not win a championship from 2011-14, when their roster was loaded with superstars. They’re not as strong anymore, but instead of breaking up their veterans, they basically sat out the winter and decided to give it another try. Few of their players will be much better than we’ve already seen, but with more elite performances from Miguel Cabrera and Justin Verlander, there’s always a chance.

Minnesota Twins: CLOSED

If you’re reading this despite last year’s regrettable prediction of a wild-card spot, thanks for the second chance. The Twins’ winning record in 2015 was a mirage, and the team sank to 103 losses, the most since moving to Minnesota in 1961. Their raw young hitters have promise, but until the Twins improve on their American League-worst earned run average (5.08), it’s hard to have much hope.

Chicago White Sox: CLOSED

After pushing forward futilely for years, the White Sox showed a sudden skill for the teardown. By trading Chris Sale to Boston and Adam Eaton to Washington at the winter meetings, they scored a deep haul of talented prospects who should start contributing this season. Still, this is a roster in major transition, with several more moves to come.

New York Yankees: OPENING

If the Yankees were serious about winning this season, they would have bolstered their thin rotation. Instead they welcomed back closer Aroldis Chapman, gave designated hitter Matt Holliday a one-year deal, and left it at that. They’re still gathering as much young talent as possible before those starry free agents hit the market after next season. The plan is working — their prospect collection really is impressive — but it’s all just a waiting game now.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

LSU quarterback competition remains unresolved after spring game
LSU quarterback competition remains unresolved after spring game

BATON ROUGE, La. — The LSU football team exits this spring in the same manner in which it entered — without a starting quarterback. That was the plan all along, but the spring game on Saturday only hammered home a point that’s been repeated by coach Ed Orgeron all spring — this competition isn’t going to be...
Georgia’s G-Day: Freshman QB Justin Fields outperforms Jake Fromm
Georgia’s G-Day: Freshman QB Justin Fields outperforms Jake Fromm

ATHENS — Jake Fromm was down after the G-Day Game on Saturday. Not down like “woe is me” and “everything was terrible.” More like he was saying all the right things but deep down was kind of bummed. Fromm’s Red Team lost to the Black team 21-13, and that was his chief gripe. But he also didn’t play...
Texas quarterbakcs battle in pit and then have their moments in scrimmage
Texas quarterbakcs battle in pit and then have their moments in scrimmage

Shane Buechele and Sam Ehlinger butted heads before the Orange-White game  in the “Circle Drill.” After that, the Texas quarterbacks’ battle for playing time on the field later Saturday night was almost inconsequential. The great quarterback battle for Texas appeared to come no closer to finding resolution Saturday...
LSU gymnastics finishes fourth place at NCAA championships
LSU gymnastics finishes fourth place at NCAA championships

For the third year in a row, the LSU gymnastics team finishes second to one. In the final meet of decorated senior all-arounder Myia Hambrick’s career, the LSU gymnastics team finished in third place behind UCLA, Oklahoma and Florida in the NCAA Super Six championships. This is the third time in three seasons that Oklahoma ...
Former Alabama QB: ‘Probably none’ of active Tennessee players would start for Tide
Former Alabama QB: ‘Probably none’ of active Tennessee players would start for Tide

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. — Tennessee football is so far down that former Alabama quarterback Greg McElroy said “probably none” of the Vols who played in the Orange and White Game on Saturday would start for the Crimson Tide. “Frankly there’s not really a guy on this team right now that is in the upper echelon, that...
More Stories