Clause that could force teachers unions to disband back in Senate bill

  • Lloyd Dunkelberger
  • News Service of Florida
3:08 p.m Wednesday, Feb. 28, 2018 Politics
Teachers and staff with Broward Schools Superintendent Robert Runcie as they return to Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School on February 23, 2018 in Parkland, Florida. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

The Florida Senate Appropriations Committee on Tuesday approved a far-reaching education bill that would let bullied students transfer to private schools and could force teachers unions to disband if they don’t meet new membership standards.

The proposals are part of a House bill (HB 7055) that is a priority of Speaker Richard Corcoran, R-Land O’ Lakes. In part, it contains a new state-funded voucher program that would let bullied public-school students transfer to private schools or other public schools.

»RELATED: The latest in Florida political news

The state would pay for the private school vouchers with contributions that Florida motorists would be able to make when they buy or register vehicles. In return for the donations, the motorists would get a credit against the sales tax they pay in vehicle transactions.

But the most contentious part of the debate Tuesday was over an amendment, sponsored by Sen. Dennis Baxley, R-Ocala, that would result in teachers unions losing state certification if their membership falls below 50 percent of the employees they represent in the collective-bargaining process.

A similar provision was stripped out of the bill last week in the Senate Education Committee. But Baxley’s amendment was approved Tuesday in the Appropriations Committee in a largely party-line vote, with Democrats calling it a “union busting” measure.

Sen. Bobby Powell, D-West Palm Beach, said the measure would hurt teachers and the public education system.

“We say that we are for our teachers,” Powell said. “Then we try to get rid of a unit that fights for the rights of those individuals. I don’t think we’re moving in the right direction.”

Baxley said the measure was aimed at revising the way teachers pick organizations to represent them in the collective-bargaining process, where unions negotiate with local school boards over issues like pay and working conditions. Under Florida’s “right to work” policy, teachers do not have be members of unions, although the unions represent them in the negotiating process.

“This is looking at, how do we choose that representation? And it’s simply saying, what’s wrong with having a majority of that work group if that’s what they want?” Baxley said. “If you represent the majority of that workforce, then you’re the right people, with strong credibility, to be negotiating on their behalf.”

Rich Templin, representing the Florida AFL-CIO, warned that allowing local teachers unions to lose their certification would lead to “chaos” because it would invalidate existing employment contracts.

“Teachers will not know their work conditions. School boards will not know how to interact with their teachers,” he said.

Melissa Faust, representing Americans for Prosperity, spoke in support of the measure, noting it would require unions to report on how many dues-paying members they have and how many overall employees they are representing in the negotiations.

“We just believe that this amendment language comes down to creating additional empowerment for teachers and accountability for unions,” Faust said.

The legislation contains a number of other changes for the public-school system, including strengthening state oversight and requirements for publicly funded private-school scholarship programs, including the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship Program.

It also would create a separate category in the school funding formula for mental health funds and require students entering high school in the fall of 2018 to take a financial literacy course before they graduate.

The bill next moves to the Senate floor.