Riviera recall organizers pledge lawsuit to fight signatures’ rejection


Highlights

A group trying to oust three Riviera Beach council members says it will fight the rejection of their petitions

Organizers petitioning to recall three city council members say they’ll sue to undo the county election supervisor’s rejection of the nearly 9,000 signatures they collected, saying the rejection was based on incorrect information about when they started the effort.

John Whittles, the group’s attorney, said at a City Hall press conference Wednesday that the suit will be filed by Friday to ask a judge “to make a reasonable interpretation” of the law to dismiss as “scrivener’s errors” the ineligible dates cited in rejecting the petitions.

The Greater Riviera Beach Community Group/Recall Committee filed papers with the city Oct. 19 to start collecting signatures to oust council members Terence Davis, Lynne Hubbard and Dawn Pardo, for firing popular City Manager Jonathan Evans without specifying why. Under state law, petitioners have 30 days to collect the number of signatures required to spark a recall election. The petitioners submitted their approximately 8,600 signatures to the city clerk Nov. 14, seemingly within that 30-day requirement.

But City Attorney Andrew DeGraffenreidt, in a letter to Supervisor of Elections Susan Bucher, pointed to a handful of signatures dated prior to Oct. 19 — including one as far back as January 19, and another dated 2016. And since state law says the 30-day clock starts with the first signature, that meant virtually all the others collected in October and November could not be certified, he said.

Bucher agreed, effectively disqualifying the recall effort and sparing the council members from having to defend their terms in a recall election.

But Whittles and Amon Yisrael, an organizer of the recall effort, said the too-early signatures obviously were incorrectly dated, to a time even before the petition forms had been printed for signing. What’s more Evans had not even started work in January, let alone been fired, so that was months before any recall effort was contemplated, Yisrael said, calling the city attorney’s effort to discredit the recall “hilarious.”

Whittles said he didn’t even draw up the petition blanks until “5 a.m. on Saturday the 14th” of October. Since the petitions referred to Evans’ Sept. 20, 2017 firing, they couldn’t possibly have been signed the previous January, he added.

Thousands of citizens signed the petitions on a timely basis, calling for a recall election to be scheduled, he said. “I’m going to ask the court to give that voice some volume,” he said.

“Thankfully the facts are on our side.”

Mayor’s car repossessed during council meeting

Evans was on the job six months when the three voted without discussion to fire him for alleged “misfeasance.”

Evans had been brought in to replace the previous manager, who the council also fired. He has since been replaced with an interim manager, while the commission searches for a permanent replacement.

The city government has remained in disarray, with several high-level positions unfilled and with the former deputy finance director managing the helm on an interim basis. A few months before the council fired Evans, the assistant city manager who’d been passed up for the manager job resigned. The human resources director gave notice in October. The internal auditor resigned. The city has no assistant human resources director, purchasing director, IT director or fully licensed building services director.

Councilman scolds resident as ‘man with rag around his head’

The police chief, recently the subject of a 67-3 vote of no confidence by the county Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association, is scheduled to retire near the end of the year. The public works director has been on leave for months, pending an internal investigation, while receiving full pay.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Things to do: Jazz on J Street at Lake Worth Book Cellar
Things to do: Jazz on J Street at Lake Worth Book Cellar

Things to do in Lake Worth: 1. Jazz on J Street: A professional JAM Session hosted by Blanche Williams is Tuesday at The Book Cellar, 801 Lake Avenue. Show runs from 7-10 p.m. with a $5 cash cover. Free public parking available on Lake Avenue, J Street and all around. 2. Divas on Stage: Performances by Lupita Hollywood, Melissa St John, Dayzee Deluxx...
Judge: Edna Hibel museum must leave FAU’s Jupiter campus
Judge: Edna Hibel museum must leave FAU’s Jupiter campus

Works of art by Edna Hibel, and any other personal property from the foundation in the late Singer Island artist’s name, must be removed from Florida Atlantic University’s John D. MacArthur campus by Sept. 24, a judge has ruled. This marks the end of a battle to keep the Hibel Museum of Art at 5353 Parkside Drive in Jupiter through the...
Look for a big block party every month in downtown Lake Worth
Look for a big block party every month in downtown Lake Worth

Evening on the Avenue is gone in Lake Worth . Now, get ready for Block Party on the Avenue, a new monthly event starting Oct. 5 on Lake Avenue from 6 to 10 p.m. “We want to bring something new this year and try to help the merchants who are still open on the Avenue to bring business downtown,” said Vice Mayor...
Wellington game shooting: Too close for one family in more than one way
Wellington game shooting: Too close for one family in more than one way

It all started with a cryptic text from their daughter. “I’m safe,” Hope Lerman had written to her parents, defense attorney Gregg Lerman and his wife, Debra. “I’m with Coach Pagley.” It was Friday night, and the Lermans had expected their daughter home late from one of the most highly anticipated football games...
UPDATE: Fuel tanker rolls over, injures 2 and shuts down I-95 lanes in Lake Worth
UPDATE: Fuel tanker rolls over, injures 2 and shuts down I-95 lanes in Lake Worth

7:30 P.M. UPDATE: According to Palm Beach County Fire Rescue, the rollover crash involved a fuel tanker. Two people were injured and transported to a hospital by helicopter. All lanes were reported to be open. 7:05 P.M. UPDATE: According to Palm Beach County Fire Rescue, the rollover crash involved a fuel tanker. Two people were injured and...
More Stories