POINT OF VIEW: NYT expresses ‘regret’ over white nationalist profile

The New York Times over the weekend published a nicely turned satire — “Choose Your Own Public Apology” — lampooning the men who’ve attempted to make amends for their histories of sexual harassment. In the same time frame, the newspaper’s leadership was figuring out how best to phrase its own regret over a profile of 29-year-old Ohio white nationalist Tony Hovater, whom reporter Richard Fausset depicted as a run-of-the-mill guy with some extreme viewpoints.

“We regret the degree to which the piece offended so many readers,” New York Times national editor Marc Lacey wrote in a carefully drafted response to the social-media backlash against the Hovater profile.

“We recognize that people can disagree on how best to tell a disagreeable story. What we think is indisputable, though, is the need to shed more light, not less, on the most extreme corners of American life and the people who inhabit them. That’s what the story, however imperfectly, tried to do.”

There was a lot of backlash, with some high points duly credited by Lacey’s post.

“We described Mr. Hovater as a bigot, a Nazi sympathizer who posted images on Facebook of a Nazi-like America full of happy white people and swastikas everywhere,” Lacey writes. “We understand that some readers wanted more pushback, and we hear that loud and clear.”

Twitter is a superb ex post facto editor, and its dwellers have suggested some excellent ways in which the Times could have added weight to its piece. Angus Johnston, for instance, posted an interesting thread mining a podcast that was mentioned only briefly in the Fausset profile. And BuzzFeed’s Charlie Warzel noted that the story failed to account for the radicalizing influence of the internet.

No editor — whether at The New York Times or elsewhere — can possibly foresee all the legitimate gripes that’ll surface on social media about a pending story. And the story did get plenty of attention, as Lacey indicates: “Our reporter and his editors agonized over the tone and content of the article,” he wrote. Such agony wasn’t reflected in the piece.


Editor’s note: Erik Wemple is media critic at The Washington Post.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: The blindness of social wealth

Bob Hall was a rancher. In 1936, in the midst of the Depression, he was suffering from a cancer that was eating the flesh on the side of his face. His ranch had dwindled to nearly nothing, and weeks after bankers took the last of his livestock, Hall died, leaving his family deeply in debt. His sons pleaded with anybody they could find to make a loan...
Opinion: Nikki Haley’s SOS to the nation

WASHINGTON — “With all due respect, I don’t get confused.” These eight words from Nikki Haley, the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, will go down as among the most powerful indictments of the rancid governing culture President Trump has fostered. They may also shed light on one of the great mysteries of the moment: Why...
Opinion: Trump — prisoner of the War Party?

“Ten days ago, President Trump was saying ‘the United States should withdraw from Syria.’ We convinced him it was necessary to stay.” Thus boasted French President Emmanuel Macron Saturday, adding, “We convinced him it was necessary to stay for the long term.” Is the U.S. indeed in the Syrian civil war “for...
Opinion: The real next war in Syria: Iran vs. Israel

SYRIA-ISRAEL BORDER, Golan Heights — Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: Syria is going to explode. I know, you have heard that one before, but this time I mean really explode. Because the U.S., British and French attack on Syria to punish its regime for its vile use of chemical weapons — and Russia’s vow to respond &mdash...
Opinion: Choosing animals over people

BAYANGA, Central African Republic — The cutest primates on earth may be Inguka and Inganda, gorilla toddler twins who playfully tumble over each other here in the vast Dzanga Sangha rain forest, one of the best places to see gorillas, antelopes and elephants play. The only risk: They are so heedless and unafraid of people that they may tumble...
More Stories