POINT OF VIEW Grand jury’s sober home report lacks balance


The Palm Beach Post’s Dec. 13 story, “Sober home report cites patient abuse,” accepted without question the grand jury’s “Report on the Proliferation of Fraud and Abuse in Florida’s Addiction Treatment Industry.”

I believe grand juries can and do perform important functions, but they need to be “fair and balanced”.

The report correctly concludes the obvious: there are some sub-standard sober homes, and some greedy substance use disorder treatment providers. Notably absent in the report were comparators like slumlords in poor neighborhoods and greedy medical providers in other health professions.

The report also correctly notes the “growing national health crisis involving opioid addiction,” but then uses words like “drastic,” “exploitation,” “medical tourism” and “lucrative opportunity for bad actors” to describe expanded capacity for substance use disorder treatment. Nowhere, however, does the grand jury talk about the need for more treatment, or how in Palm Beach County less than 15 percent of the population with substance use disorders received treatment in the previous year.

Palm Beach County, and Florida as a whole need to expand substance use disorder treatment opportunities, not demonize the health providers. While some regulation is certainly necessary, the grand jury essentially recommends over-regulation, which will drive up the cost of treatment and reduce its availability to those who need it most.

Additionally, the grand jury claims to have heard testimony from “private and municipal attorneys who extensively litigated treatment and recovery housing issues over the past decade.” I don’t know a single private lawyer in Palm Beach County who has extensively litigated treatment and recovery housing issues on behalf of people in recovery over the past decade who was called to the grand jury.

Had I been called, for example, I would have talked about the history of zoning discrimination against people with disabilities which makes it hard and expensive for them to get fair housing and treatment. I would have talked about “Not in My Backyard,” where people and politicians say we need sober homes and treatment centers but not in their city. If not there, where?

Also, I would have talked about the failure of neighbors, politicians, people in recovery and providers to sit down face-to-face and discuss their fears and needs. It does not appear that any of this was presented to, or considered by the grand jury.

JAMES K. GREEN, WEST PALM BEACH

Editor’s note: James K. Green is a West Palm Beach attorney who litigated in federal court for people in recovery who were seeking fair housing and treatment providers seeking zoning approval to open treatment facilities.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Fraternity video exposes crumbling decency in society

PAWLEYS ISLAND, S.C. — Courage isn’t required to condemn the Syracuse University chapter of the Theta Tau fraternity for simulating a sexual assault on a disabled student. Video of this ape-ish display, now in wide circulation, should horrify anyone with an ounce of decency. That is, assuming people still recall what decency is. After the...
Commentary: Raising legal age limits won’t solve gun violence
Commentary: Raising legal age limits won’t solve gun violence

A national debate over gun violence has erupted in the wake of the tragic shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland. Unlike past mass shootings, grieving and evidence-gathering have been superseded by fervent demands for gun control, with a particular emphasis placed on increasing age limits required to buy certain weapons. Under...
Commentary: Let pre-18 teens register to vote
Commentary: Let pre-18 teens register to vote

Along with turning up the heat in the national debate over gun laws, the horrific attack at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Florida on Feb. 14 has introduced the nation to a new generation of articulate, passionate teenagers. Days after watching classmates get gunned down in their school, the Parkland massacre’s young survivors confronted...
POINT OF VIEW: A chance to get pension reform right

There is a crisis looming that has the potential to dramatically affect both the retirement benefits of millions of retirees as well as multiple states and communities. I am referencing the Multi-Employer Pension Plan crisis. What is a MEPP? They are pension plans collectively bargained (i.e., union pension plans) maintained by more than one employer...
Palm Beach Post editorial cartoon Wednesday, April 25
Palm Beach Post editorial cartoon Wednesday, April 25

CARTOON VIEW SIGNE WILKINSON
More Stories