POINT OF VIEW: Florida insurers should stay out of doctors’ exam rooms

As the debate around health reform continues to rumble on Capitol Hill, there’s a common-sense fix that Florida lawmakers can make right now to ensure better care for Floridians.

Insurance companies are changing patient prescriptions without doctor consent, all in an effort to save money. This is happening while patients are locked into their health policy for the year — with nowhere to turn for help.

During open enrollment, Floridians and their families may choose a health insurance plan solely because it covers a particular drug, only to find that the formulary can change at any time.

Sometimes these changes are prompted by the inflation of drug prices. But those changes are happening after pharmacy benefit managers and insurers have negotiated price protections contracts that shield them from these unexpected price increases. If the drug price goes up, an additional rebate is paid to make up the difference.

In some cases, patients are prescribed a medicine similar to their original medication, but “similar” doesn’t mean it will have the same effect.

Patients living with cancer, lupus, HIV/AIDS, and other chronic conditions know all too well that they may respond differently to one drug over another.

As a health care provider, I know firsthand the degree of thought and careful precision that goes into making crucial treatment decisions for Florida’s patients. When patients are locked into their health policy, they can be forced to adjust their treatments based on the whims of their insurer.

The health and financial consequences can be dire when patients are switched like this. In some cases, these switches lead to damaging side effects, force more appointments with care providers, and create unnecessary check-ins for the patient — all of which further increase care costs.

These formulary switches are often medically arbitrary, based on what makes the most financial sense for the insurer, without regard for the patient’s well-being.

For example, a patient with rheumatoid arthritis can experience flare-ups without a proper treatment plan, which can manifest in terrible joint pain, swelling, and very serious systemic consequences impacting a patient’s heart and lungs. There is evidence that patients with rheumatoid arthritis have a high risk of heart attack.

The consequences of a rheumatoid flare-up can range from being unable to work, to experiencing a constant state of pain, to having much more serious effects. The risk of these switches is substantial.

Tragically, these consequences are often entirely avoidable because the patient experiencing them was already stable on a treatment regimen.

This is an incredibly frustrating experience for doctors: people outside of our offices are making decisions that affect our patients. These people are not medically qualified.

It’s time to say enough is enough. Insurers should not try to practice medicine without a license. They need to deliver on the benefits they marketed and sold to Florida’s consumers during open enrollment.

Patients are locked into their policy for the year. The benefits they rely on should be too. It’s time to end bait-and-switch practices in the Sunshine State.


Editor’s note: Dr. Shawn Baca is immediate past president of the Palm Beach Medical Society and a member of the Rheumatology Associates of South Florida.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Challenging Trump’s Christian apologists

WASHINGTON — Maybe it takes a royal wedding to offer lessons in what a good sermon sounds like. Maybe it takes one of the world’s most elitist institutions to provide a view of Christianity rooted not in conservative cultural warfare but in an egalitarian love that will “let justice roll down like a mighty stream.” And the Most...
Opinion: What moral heroes are made of

Recently, I’ve been lucky enough to be around a lot of people who I would regard as moral heroes. They spend their lives fighting poverty, caring for the young or the sick, or single-mindedly dedicated to some cause. I’ve been wondering what traits such people tend to have in common. The first is that they didn’t overthink their decision...
POINT OF VIEW: Confront bullying in schools, not just access to guns

As a 47-year veteran teacher, it is immensely disheartening to see that schools are no longer safe havens for children. Particularly disturbing is the relative lack of action to address this problem. I will leave it to others to debate the merits of gun control and campus policing. Sign up for The Palm Beach Post weekly Opinion newsletter: Text Opinion...
Letters: New resident lauds ease of dealing with Tax Collector’s Office

New resident lauds Tax Collector’s Office As a new Florida resident, I was somewhat apprehensive about getting my auto tags, driver’s permit and business license from a political entity with 39 incorporated jurisdictions and numerous “unincorporated” areas, all under the umbrella (I assume) of Palm Beach County. Sign up for...
Editorial cartoon
Editorial cartoon

More Stories