Opinion: Student journalists continue to cover school’s tragedy


The first journalists on the scene at the school shooting in Parkland, Fla., were there for every terrifying shot.

After all, Marjory Stoneman Douglas High is their school.

As a former student stormed the halls, firing an AR-15, the newspaper teacher’s classroom became a refuge, sheltering 163 students and six adults during the mass shooting that killed 14 students and three faculty members.

In the following days, the high school journalists began writing with a perspective that no other reporter in America could equal. One, David Hogg, filmed interviews with students as they hid, waiting for police rescue.

Seniors Nikhita Nookala and Christy Ma posted to the school’s online paper, EagleEye.news, describing how helicopters from the news organizations drowned out the speeches at the vigil. They noted that some students were angered by insensitive media questions and coverage that exaggerated or distorted facts. And, they offered this searing description at the candlelight vigil: “Some chanted ‘Arm the schools,’ while the audience retaliated with ‘No more guns.’ Students caught in between could do nothing but cry and hold on to friends and family.”

Let’s hope no busybody administrator or politician tries to hush these student journalists as they continue asking pointed questions about lapses in school safety and delving into political issues that some adults have the gall to claim are none of the teenagers’ business.

Already, moronic conspiracy theorists have promoted the false claim that the most vocal Stoneman Douglas students aren’t survivors of the mass shooting but rather plants by leftist funders.

These rants are from people who fear the Parkland students because they’re powerful advocates for their own safety and that of others.

It’s past time to fully restore full protections to such students’ free speech, rights that were stripped away nearly 30 years ago through a St. Louis case decided by the U.S. Supreme Court, Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier. It involved a principal who kept stories about divorce and teen pregnancy from the student newspaper — yes, banal subjects compared to mass school shootings.

The high court sided with the principal in 1988.

And for several decades, attacks on high school and college press freedoms became real, sustained and daunting. Often, crackdowns are motivated by the supposition that student journalists are not properly promoting the school’s image.

After the Parkland shooting, it’s a good bet that more high school journalists will take a hard look at safety in their districts and hold legislators accountable who have failed to pass adequate gun laws.

Florida is not among the 13 states, six in the past three years, that have passed laws to strengthen student’s free speech protections in school-sponsored publications.

The “New Voices” effort of the Student Press Law Center is trying to move legislation along in other states, including Missouri, where it passed the House Feb. 19.

And consider that in many communities, and not necessarily just small towns, cutbacks in professional press ranks mean that the only independent eyes and ears of observation is the local student press.

One of the many lessons sure to come from Parkland is the galvanizing power of student voices. A nation that truly cares about its youth would have done everything in its power to keep them safe at school. We’ve failed to do so. It’s time to value students’ right to speak out and up for themselves.

Writes for Tribune Syndicated Content.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: A time to mourn

PAWLEYS ISLAND, S.C. — Ecclesiastes tells us that there’s a time to mourn and a time to dance, but lately I can hardly find time to mourn — and I’m dancing as fast as I can. These thoughts came tumbling down last week after the heart-wrenching news that Aretha Franklin had died. I spent the day re-listening to all my favorite...
Opinion: Musk, Trump and the second Gilded Age

I’ve long admired Elon Musk as a technological visionary. But I worry about his sense of responsibility to the public. Earlier this month, Musk announced on Twitter that he intended to turn Telsa, the electric-car maker he founded, into a private company. He said the funding was “secured” — a claim that sent Telsa stock skyrocketing...
Opinion: If Mother Nature gets a vote in 2020

What if this time is different? There is an assumption that the 2020 presidential election will be business as usual: Donald Trump will run on the economy, social issues and immigration, and the Democratic candidate will run on income inequality, Democratic socialism and Trump’s character — the 2020 version of right-left U.S. politics....
POINT OF VIEW: “Stand Your Ground”: A good law for bad situations

On July 19, Michael Drejka shot and killed Markeis McGlockton in a Clearwater parking lot. Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri declined to charge Drejka, citing the state’s “stand your ground” law. Outrage ensued. It was just an argument over a parking spot, some say, hinting that the whole thing is Drejka’s fault in the first...
Readers weigh in on attacks upon freedom of the press

Repudiating the notion that the U.S. media are “the enemy of the people,” The Palm Beach Post on Thursday joined with more than 350 other newspapers to assert, each in its own way, the critical importance of a free and independent press. Our editorial, “In defense of democracy’s defenders,” elicited strong responses, pro...
More Stories