Editorial: Florida Legislature assault on home rule must end

Florida’s counties and municipalities are under siege. But it’s not just from crises such as rising sea levels, a spreading opioid epidemic or lack of affordable housing.

The state’s Republican-controlled Legislature, which has been chipping away at Florida’s bedrock “home rule” statute for years, appears ready to take to a sledgehammer to it in the 2018 legislative session and supplant local elected officials’ authority on local issues with that of state lawmakers.

That would be bad for local residents and taxpayers.

As Thomas Jefferson once wrote: “The government closest to the people serves the people best.”

Florida voters came to that conclusion nearly 50 years ago, when they amended the state Constitution in 1968 to give home rule authority to counties and municipalities. Prior to that, most local decisions were made in Tallahassee, resulting in more than a 1,000 local bills being passed during the 60-day session. It was unwieldy, unnecessary and untenable.

Home rule allowed for the idea that local governments, and their elected officials, were better positioned to deal with local matters for their communities.

To be sure, local governance is far from perfect. The Post has chronicled numerous missteps by local government officials over the decades. But to suggest that state lawmakers in Tallahassee are better at governing than their brethren in every municipality and county in the state is not only ludicrous, but hypocritical. After all, this same GOP Legislature vehemently argues for states’ rights against the federal government.

Yes, there are many issues best addressed by our Legislature to maintain continuity throughout the state — such as water and land conservation, transportation infrastructure and health care. But on many issues — zoning ordinances, emergency services, building codes, solid waste disposal and business licensing, for example — local officials are better equipped to respond quickly to local residents.

Moreover, Tampa is not Tallahassee. Monticello is not Miami. And Jupiter is not Jacksonville.

Unfortunately, GOP lawmakers, especially in the House, increasingly don’t see it that way. Last session, several so-called “preemption bills” were introduced with the aim of giving Tallahassee more local control — especially of permitting. The most egregious of which was House Bill 17, which sought to “preempt the regulation of businesses, professions and occupations to the state.”

The bill, which would have given local residents no say in whether a “gentlemen’s club” was appropriate for their community, failed; but not before advancing further than anyone expected.

What didn’t fail was a bill that preempts local government control of public rights of way when it comes to the placement of small wireless equipment. To appease wireless providers, the new law disregards the fact that local governments treat their rights of way differently and keeps one city from charging more than another for a permit.

RELATED: Editorial: Homestead-exemption boost spells trouble for cities, county

And in the ultimate big-foot move, state lawmakers placed a constitutional amendment on next year’s general election ballot that would increase the non-school homestead exemption by $25,000. An analysis shows that if 60 percent of voters approve, it could reduce property-tax revenue to the cities, counties and special districts by $644 million a year. It could cost Palm Beach County about $25 million, the county’s fire-rescue services $9 million and cities an extra $17 million a year.

And with the backing of House Speaker Richard Corcoran, R-Land O’Lakes, a version of HB 17 is expected to make a comeback in the upcoming session. Bolstered by its successful draconian assault on the state’s public school system with the passage of HB 7069 last session, the Corcoran-led House is poised to preempt even the most basic local permitting with a one-size-fits-all approach.

“I care more about the people of this state than I care about the governments of this state,” Corcoran said during the last session.

Well, so do we. Though not infallible, the governments closest to the people tend to be the most responsive to their needs.

From tree-cutting to the height of signs, local residents and taxpayers risk losing that local responsiveness unless they make their voices heard in Tallahassee.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Fraternity video exposes crumbling decency in society

PAWLEYS ISLAND, S.C. — Courage isn’t required to condemn the Syracuse University chapter of the Theta Tau fraternity for simulating a sexual assault on a disabled student. Video of this ape-ish display, now in wide circulation, should horrify anyone with an ounce of decency. That is, assuming people still recall what decency is. After the...
Commentary: Raising legal age limits won’t solve gun violence
Commentary: Raising legal age limits won’t solve gun violence

A national debate over gun violence has erupted in the wake of the tragic shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland. Unlike past mass shootings, grieving and evidence-gathering have been superseded by fervent demands for gun control, with a particular emphasis placed on increasing age limits required to buy certain weapons. Under...
Commentary: Let pre-18 teens register to vote
Commentary: Let pre-18 teens register to vote

Along with turning up the heat in the national debate over gun laws, the horrific attack at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Florida on Feb. 14 has introduced the nation to a new generation of articulate, passionate teenagers. Days after watching classmates get gunned down in their school, the Parkland massacre’s young survivors confronted...
POINT OF VIEW: A chance to get pension reform right

There is a crisis looming that has the potential to dramatically affect both the retirement benefits of millions of retirees as well as multiple states and communities. I am referencing the Multi-Employer Pension Plan crisis. What is a MEPP? They are pension plans collectively bargained (i.e., union pension plans) maintained by more than one employer...
Palm Beach Post editorial cartoon Wednesday, April 25
Palm Beach Post editorial cartoon Wednesday, April 25

More Stories