Editorial: Fighting, fingerpointing no way to fix toxic algae issue

Another rainy summer season. Another massive toxic algae bloom on Lake Okeechobee. Another round of nutrient-rich water discharges threatening Florida’s coasts and fanning outrage.

And, most frustrating, another triage approach to fixing a festering decades-old wound.

On Monday, Gov. Rick Scott issued an emergency order to help mitigate the impact of toxic algae outbreaks on both coasts. Scott was clearly reading the political tea leaves of an election year while touring the Caloosahatchee River Monday morning, then imposing the order for Glades, Hendry, Lee, Martin, Okeechobee, Palm Beach and St. Lucie counties “to help combat algal blooms caused by Lake Okeechobee water discharges from the Army Corps of Engineers.”

RELATED: Scott issues emergency order over blue-green algae

As reported by the Post’s Kimberly Miller, it was Scott’s second such order regarding the cynobacteria — blue green algae — in two weeks.

The governor, in a tight race to unseat longtime Florida Sen. Bill Nelson, had already ordered the state Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) and South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) to install more water quality monitors to try to stop the spread of a nasty wave of thick green goo. Monday’s order went appreciably further, enlisting a variety of other agencies to address the toxic waters — requiring the Department of Health and Visit Florida, for example, to step up outreach and communications with the public and local businesses.

Water managers were also allowed to waive various restrictions and regulations to store water in additional areas south of the lake. DEP and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) were ordered to spend more staff time on water testing. And DEP will set up a grant program to help local governments pay for clean-up services.

The state’s flurry followed a late Sunday decision by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to temporarily suspend water releases from Lake O into the Caloosahatchee and St. Lucie estuaries so a full assessment of system conditions could be undertaken. That welcome announcement came just as the Corps was expected to resume flows into the estuaries after a nine-day hiatus to provide some relief.

RELATED: White House approves massive reservoir to hold Lake O overflow

But, as Miller reported, with the lake at 14.44 feet above sea level, the pause in discharges is temporary. Because the Army Corps doesn’t like to push the lake level beyond 15.5 feet, Jacksonville District Commander Col. Jason Kirk said it “will likely have to resume releases later in the week to reduce the flood risk that a rising lake presents.”

In other words, we’re right back where we started. Residents yelling. Businesses cussing. And politicians threatening the Army Corps — which, if the past week has taught us anything, is merely a political puppet in this play. Witness U.S. Rep. Brian Mast’s recent demands on the House floor, and Sen. Marco Rubio’s Sunday letter to President Donald Trump, both targeting the Corps.

To hear Scott tell it, the federal government is completely to blame for dragging its feet on funding repairs to the Herbert Hoover Dike, which surrounds the lake and approving the the Everglades Agricultural Area (EAA) reservoir. That’s rich, coming from a governor whose eight-year track record on the environment has made him the butt of jokes on late-night TV.

The glacial pace of federal appropriations is frustrating, to be sure. (The Army Corps said last Thursday that $514.2 million is heading toward repairs of the dike, now expected to be done in 2022.) But that shouldn’t have stopped Scott and the Florida Legislature from doing their own jobs.

RELATED: Editorial: Now is a good time to stop fighting, solve water issue

This is the third time in five years that high lake levels have led to toxic discharges into the estuaries and very vocal, upset residents and business owners. But rather than leadership needed to bring the disparate coastal, Glades, agricultural and environmental interests together, we continue to get more fingerpointing.

RELATED: Editorial: Long-term plan to fix algae blooms needs Big Sugar backing

Scott and the Republican-controlled Florida Legislature finally did allocate $100 million toward repairs to the dike the past two years, and last year found $60 million for a 10,500-acre above-ground reservoir and a 6,500-acre stormwater treatment area planned for western Palm Beach County. But those projects are all years down the road.

What about more immediate relief from the seemingly annual algae blooms and Lake O discharges? This should have been a priority. But here we are: Coastal residents can’t swim or fish. Their businesses can’t stay open. Their counterparts in the Glades worry about their lives and livelihoods being washed away.

Sign up for The Palm Beach Post FREE weekly Opinion newsletter: Text Opinion to 444999

As former Martin County Commissioner Maggy Hurchalla said in a recent op-ed:

“This is about finding a solution to the problem. It’s about finding a solution that works and finding it in time. It’s not a time for dividing up the residents of South Florida and getting them to fight with each other. Florida Bay and the Everglades are at stake. Miami’s drinking water supply is at stake. The coastal estuaries will not survive if we don’t find a way to move forward together.”

Ultimately, only Florida’s governor can bring these interests together. Voters should remember that come November.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Trump isn’t first president to cozy up to Putin

WASHINGTON — The definition of insanity is doing the same thing again and again and expecting to get a different result, which is one of the many reasons President Trump’s news conference with Russian President Vladimir Putin seemed so insane. Trump is trying to do something that both of his immediate predecessors tried to do: turn over...
Opinion: ‘Sort of a double negative’

It is an unfathomable proposition that the day would ever come when America could rightly question the loyalties of its own president, but that is precisely where we have arrived. Donald Trump’s “Surrender Summit” with President Vladimir Putin of Russia was such a disloyal, traitorous display that it boggles the mind. Russia attacked...
POINT OF VIEW: My trade deficit with grocery stores, the local laundry

Inspired by President Donald Trump’s insistence that all U.S. trading partners buy as much from us as we do from them, I have been trying to apply the concept to my personal affairs. I’ve got a problem with my local grocery chains, Aldi and Publix. I buy lots of groceries from them, but they don’t buy any of the lectures or writing...
Editorial cartoon
Editorial cartoon

Letters: Trump did a great job in summit with Putin

Trump did a great job in summit with Putin Watched the televised Trump-Putin Summit and followup of politically dividing remarks on all media. I thought President Trump did an outstanding job. Best historical quote: “I would rather take a political risk in pursuit of peace than to risk peace in pursuit of politics.” Trump doesn’t...
More Stories