Commentary: Why Wakanda matters

In a scene close to the riveting climax of “Black Panther” — the Hollywood superhero blockbuster that smashed numerous box office records over its first weekend — the titular character’s tech-wizard sister refers to a CIA officer as a “colonizer.” For many, that’s a loaded word, immediately bringing to mind a legacy of abuse and exploitation and a tense history that separates nations and divides communities to this day.

“Between colonizer and colonized,” wrote Aimé Césaire, the great 20th-century Francophone poet and Afro-Caribbean political theorist, “there is room only for forced labor, intimidation, pressure, the police, taxation, theft, rape, compulsory crops, contempt, mistrust, arrogance, self-complacency, swinishness, brainless elites, degraded masses.”

But in the world of “Black Panther,” the invocation of “colonizer” drew laughs in the packed Washington theater where I sat. It was a lighthearted punchline, a word so harmless in the context of the film that it simply became a term of endearment for a token white guy.

For that, and for so much more, “Black Panther” marks a fascinating cultural moment. It’s further (although unnecessary) proof that a Hollywood movie dominated by minorities is no barrier to huge commercial success in the United States or elsewhere. And it also delivers a genuinely powerful statement: It’s unapologetic Afrofuturist fantasy, centered on the cat-cowled monarch of a peerless African nation, manages to be both overtly and subtly political in ways that few films of the genre ever are, uplifting the “colonized,” while pushing the “colonizer” away.

Advancement Project tweeted: “We are here for #WakandaTheVote, an effort by 3 Black women to register voters at #BlackPanther screenings everywhere. Black joy, positive film representation & empowerment are a great combination …”

The film’s story is based on the iconic Marvel superhero created more than a half-century ago by two Jewish New Yorkers who crafted their comic-book legends amid the turbulent civil rights struggle in the United States. Around the same time, the radical leftist Black Panther Party emerged in Oakland, Calif. — which also happens to be where the movie’s first scene takes place.

But the essential location here is Wakanda, the fictional nation where T’Challa — our hero who dons the invulnerable suit that makes him the Black Panther — is king. Wakanda, like many places in Africa, is home to a great wealth of natural resources. But unlike most places in Africa, it was able to avoid European colonization. Shielded by the powers of vibranium, the element mined beneath its surface that enabled the country to develop the world’s most advanced technology, Wakanda resisted invaders while its rulers constructed a beautiful space-age kingdom.

Without colonialism’s influence

“Wakanda represents this unbroken chain of achievement of black excellence that never got interrupted by colonialism,” Evan Narcisse, a pop culture critic who co-writes “The Rise of the Black Panther” miniseries, told The Washington Post’s David Betancourt.

Wakanda, deliberately, is hard to place on the map. Ahead of making the film, director Ryan Coogler explored the highlands of the tiny nation of Lesotho, nestled in mountains within the landmass of South Africa. An indistinct satellite image in the movie (and a clearer drawing in the new series of books written by acclaimed African American author Ta-Nehisi Coates) places Wakanda farther north, along the shores of Lake Victoria. The country is rendered as a Pan-African pastiche; viewers of “Black Panther” can point to Ghanaian fabrics and Zulu headdresses, Ethiopian tribal body markings and a prominent Bantu tongue.

Laura Seay tweeted “A student asked about the role of women in Dahomey’s army in seminar today and I’m like YES, let’s talk about the Dahomey Ahosi & #BlackPanther”

There is a logic to conjuring such geographic imprecision on a continent whose political borders were drawn largely by Europeans. “Wakanda was not colonized, so they had a chance to build a society that was free of European influence, whether British or French,” mused Kenyan journalist Larry Madowo, in conversation with my colleague Karen Attiah, after both had watched the movie. “We call ourselves Francophone Africa vs. Anglophone Africa. We categorize ourselves based on who our oppressor was. I always find that a strange thing. Our identity is so deeply tied to our oppression.”

And, as an idealized homeland, Wakanda also represents the powerful promise of black liberation dreamed by generations of African Americans. “We have for centuries sought to either find or create a promised land where we would be untroubled by the criminal horrors of our American existence,” Carvell Wallace wrote in the New York Times magazine. “From Paul Cuffee’s attempts in 1811 to repatriate blacks to Sierra Leone and Marcus Garvey’s back-to-Africa Black Star shipping line to the Afrocentric movements of the ’60s and ’70s, black people have populated the Africa of our imagination with our most yearning attempts at self-realization.”

‘Afrofantasy’ vs reality

In the film, though, the promised land is under threat, torn between two visions of how to wield its vast power. T’Challa, our hero, is moved to maintain Wakanda’s largely peaceful seclusion from the rest of the world. The nemesis who emerges, a Wakandian emigre with the not-so-subtle name of Eric Killmonger, wants Wakanda to lead an armed global revolution against the oppressors in the West. As some academics have observed, Killmonger is rather directly channeling the spirit of mid-20th-century anti-colonial thinker Frantz Fanon, who saw in armed struggle a pathway to utopia.

“T’Challa’s advocacy of internal development and neutrality in international affairs resembles ideas initially advanced by the African American clergyman Alexander Crummell in the 19th century and refined by Ghana’s Kwame Nkrumah in the 20th,” noted Jonathan Gray of the City University of New York, “while Killmonger’s desire for a militaristic engagement with the world on African terms seems an interesting blend of Edward Blyden’s messianic Ethiopianism, Fanon’s embrace of armed conflict and … Garvey’s belief that Africa was a sleeping giant with the unrealized capacity to dominate the world.”

This may seem a bit much for a big-budget blockbuster, but “Black Panther” wears its themes as lightly as T’Challa’s potent necklace. The result is a sprawling, transporting 3-D spectacle that ultimately returns viewers to the festering troubles of the real world — the United States.

In the end, “Black Panther” delivers a pointed message of inclusion, a call to build “bridges” — not “walls” — to move beyond a past of violence and injustice. But, in Wakanda, there’s just one global superpower, resplendent and mighty, that needs no reference but itself.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: A parable of self-destruction

EASTER ISLAND — This remote speck in the South Pacific is famous for its colossal stone statues, nearly 1,000 of them towering over the landscape like guardians. Who built them? How did they get there? And who fitted some of them with giant red stone hats weighing up to 12 tons each? When I was a kid, a huge nonfiction best seller by Erich von...
Opinion: Women promise to storm the swamp

How many times have we heard that this is the year of the woman? Let’s just say, several. Each decade for the past century or so seems to have presented a fresh feature to justify yet another proclamation of historic import. From suffrage (1920) to the pill (1960) and to legalized abortion (1973) to Gloria Steinem and Ms. Magazine (1972) to &ldquo...
Editorial: Despite new law, Florida needs bigger commitment on opioids
Editorial: Despite new law, Florida needs bigger commitment on opioids

With plenty of pomp, Gov. Rick Scott came to Boca Raton on Monday to ceremoniously sign a high-profile bill designed to prevent Floridians from getting hooked on opioids. If only this new law were anywhere near as powerful as the addictions it hopes to combat. Although the governor last year declared a public health emergency, the reality is that he...
POINT OF VIEW: Beware of bullies on a plane
POINT OF VIEW: Beware of bullies on a plane

There have always been bullies and there always will be. And it’s not just a problem our children have to face. Sure, bullies get older, but they may never change their behavior and as adults remain just as prone to exploiting weakness when they see it. Recently, a United Airlines flight attendant compelled a mother, traveling alone with two...
Letters: Jupiter, developer insult our intelligence

Jupiter, developer insult our intelligence Thousands of residences have been built in Jupiter over the past two decades, and not once can I remember the subject of “cheaper” new construction being addressed. I refrain from the overused terminology of “affordable” housing since all homes built are affordable to someone &mdash...
More Stories