Should term-limited Gardens council members be allowed to run again?


Highlights

Voters will be asked if term-limited council members can run again after sitting out 3 years.

It’s one of several changes voters will decide March 13.

After a series of contentious meetings filled with hours of debate, Palm Beach Gardens council members have agreed to ask voters to extend their time in office and change how they are elected.

RELATED: Term limits debate gets testy in Palm Beach Gardens

The City Council approved four questions Thursday that will be put to voters on March 13, when no Gardens council races appear on the ballot. Three of the four questions about altering the City Charter, akin to its constitution, change elections or term limits that voters approved in November 2014.

RELATED: What was decided at contentious Gardens council meeting on term limits

Officials voted 4-1, with Councilman Matt Lane dissenting, to ask voters if:

  • City Council members, including themselves, should be allowed to serve three consecutive, three-year terms instead of two, as dictated by voters in 2014.
  • Council members who leave office because of term limits would be able to run again after sitting out three years. Currently, past council members can never run again but current council members could sit out just one year.
  • The highest vote-getter in council elections should be named the winner, even if the candidate doesn’t get more than 50 percent of the vote. That would eliminate runoff elections, but critics have said it could also make it easier for candidates to get elected.
  • The city manager should no longer be required to live in the city, nor should the City Council be required to review his performance each year. The proposal on eliminating outdated language also would eliminate a required review of the charter every five years.

Council members said the terms of the city manager’s employment should be negotiated as part of his contract instead of stipulated in the charter.

The lone “no” vote, Lane, has said the four questions are “deceptive” and that voters won’t really know what they’re voting on. He preferred limiting the council to two, four-year terms, but the rest of the council preferred three consecutive, three-year terms recommended by the Charter Review Committee they appointed.

Councilman Carl Woods said he feels he can do a better job in three, three-year terms, a point argued by other council members. Woods said he wants to be there to see the completion of spending from a penny sales tax to build parks and renovate City Hall, police headquarters and the fire station.

“The reason for the term limits agenda was to remove the last council, not us,” he said. “We want term limits that are in the charter that are well-defined and that are enforceable and that do not separate one group from another.”

Currently, council members who were in office when term limits were enacted face a lifetime ban on serving again, but the current council and their successors can run again after sitting out for a year, under an appeals court ruling last year. Some of those members had served for decades.

The distinction could leave the city open to lawsuit, City Attorney Max Lohman has said.

If voters say “yes” to changing when council members can run again, it will resolve the problem, he said. It would also allow people who have held office for decades to run again.

Residents have been critical of putting the questions to voters in March, when there’s no city races to draw voters to the polls. Supervisor of Elections Susan Bucher won’t allow municipal questions on the ballot in November and doesn’t like to take them in August because it adds too many pages, Lohman has said.

Former Mayor Linda Monroe said she suggested term limits when she was on the council many years ago, but “no one wanted to talk about it at that time” and was pleased when they came up again three years ago.

Monroe, who served 18 years, ultimately voted against the proposal, though, because she prefers council people be allowed to serve three terms instead of two. She said she doesn’t agree with the third term being allowed for current council members, though, if voters approve the question.

“I’m kind of sad to say that, but when you’re elected with two, three-year terms, I think you should live with it,” Monroe said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

North Carolina deputies find nearly $91 million of liquid meth on truck
North Carolina deputies find nearly $91 million of liquid meth on truck

Deputies in North Carolina on Saturday seized a tractor-trailer containing $90.8 million worth of liquid methamphetamine in the driver's side fuel tank, WTVD reported. Raul Topete Arreola, 49, and Aquileo Perez Pineda, 48, were charged with three counts of trafficking methamphetamine, according to the Harnett County Sheriff’s Office. Deputies...
WATCH: Veterans arrive home to cheers and hugs after trip to Washington D.C.
WATCH: Veterans arrive home to cheers and hugs after trip to Washington D.C.

The noise filled the entrance to Concourse A and B long before the men in red hats arrived. About 300 people had already come, some wearing cowboy boots, some holding USA signs, some sporting freshly pressed military uniforms and pushing walkers with American flags pinned to the sides. “We came to honor our boys,” said Frank Bonfiglio,...
25 people in New York City hospitalized for synthetic marijuana overdoses
25 people in New York City hospitalized for synthetic marijuana overdoses

Twenty-five people in New York City were hospitalized Saturday night after apparently having a negative reaction to synthetic marijuana, WABC reported. Lt. Paul Ng of the New York Police Department said that the drug, known as K2, was taken by people in the Bedford-Stuyvesant section of Brooklyn. They were taken to the hospital after reports of...
UPDATE: Man charged in Boynton drive-by that injures teen gets $20,000 bond
UPDATE: Man charged in Boynton drive-by that injures teen gets $20,000 bond

An 18-year-old boy who allegedly shot and injured a teen in Boynton Beach Wednesday night was given a $20,000 bond by a Palm Beach County Court judge Saturday morning. Cleevens Altiner was arrested Friday and faces charges of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon without intent to kill and aggravated battery with a firearm. The judge ordered a $10...
Police: Massachusetts man arrested for allegedly hitting dog with baseball bat
Police: Massachusetts man arrested for allegedly hitting dog with baseball bat

A Massachusetts man was arrested Friday for allegedly abusing a dog with a baseball bat. Gregory Ostiguy, 50, of New Bedford, was arrested by Dartmouth Police and charged with animal cruelty. Police responded to a report of animal abuse at around 6:50 p.m. on Friday. After an investigation, police determined that Ostiguy did in fact...
More Stories