Residents want answers: Why are Brightline’s ‘quiet zones’ not so quiet?


Turns out the recently enacted quiet zones designed to muzzle the blaring sounds of those oncoming 80 mph Brightline trains in Palm Beach County are really more like ‘sometimes’ quiet zones.

Residents from West Palm to Delray Beach and Boca Raton were looking forward to the peace and quiet, but the locomotion commotion hasn’t ceased on the Florida East Coast Railway tracks.

Train horns will still sound during emergencies and construction, said Ali Soule, spokeswoman for Brightline.

That was the case Monday in West Palm Beach and two weeks ago in Delray Beach where workers are doing signal maintenance along the tracks.

WEST PALM READERS: Sign up for The Post’s weekly West Palm Beach newsletter here

West Palm officials received so many phone calls asking why the horns were still deafening along the tracks between 15th Street and Forest Hill Boulevard, the city issued a statement clarifying the situation and emphasizing it was not aware of the construction in that area.

“FEC has indicated that, as a result of their maintenance of tracks and switches, train engineers may blow their horn if workers are near the tracks,” spokesperson Kathleen Walter said in a statement. “This construction may last for up to 90 days.

CLICK HERE for The Post’s full coverage of Brightline

“As the City does not have oversight over the railway, the schedule for construction and maintenance activities along this corridor is controlled exclusively by the railroad. Still, the City felt strongly that this information was important to share with our community, as neither the City nor our residents had been made aware of the construction activities.”

Routine construction along the FEC tracks is frequent so the noise is still as piercing.

West Palm is the first of seven cities in Palm Beach County to establish the quiet zone along Brightline’s route. Two weeks ago, Delray residents were also griping about the blasts.

“I heard (the horns) three times in the morning and I left the house at 9:30 a.m.,” said Patty Ennis-Stone, who lives near the tracks at Lindell Boulevard and Dixie Highway. “It’s annoying as all hell.”

Some of the early confusion regarding the continued use of train horns seems to have been born out of unrealistic expectations of what quiet zones really mean.

“Just because there’s a quiet zone doesn’t mean you’ll never hear a train horn again,” Soule said. “If there’s an emergency situation, or if it is outlined in the federal law, a locomotive engineer is required to blow the horn.”

In Boca Raton, officials have also seen confusion on social media regarding the noise near the Broward-Palm Beach boarder, but haven’t received the volume of phone complaints like West Palm Beach.

RELATED: Delray quiet zones in effect, so why are residents still hearing train horns?

“It’s a ‘quiet zone’ because it’s a heck of a lot more quiet than it was with 20 trains going by a day, but we just do a lot of education with people to let them know that doesn’t mean you’re not going to hear a horn,” said Chrissy Gibson, a spokeswoman for Boca Raton.

With hundreds of miles of track running from Miami to West Palm Beach, there are bound to be projects to upgrade signals or maintain tracks and switches, officials say. The work isn’t a 24-hour process and train engineers only have to blow the horn when workers are present in the corridor.

“For us, it’s important because it’s a quality of life issue, so I think it’s important that our citizens are well aware of what’s transpiring along this corridor,” said Scott Kelly, assistant city administrator for West Palm Beach.

Gibson said the full elimination of horns would not happen and that was made clear during news conferences about the quiet zones.

Some members of the community still see benefit in the sounding of train horns.

Mike Pikney, a supervisor at The Salvation Army Northwest Community Center located near railroad tracks in West Palm Beach, said he has noticed how quiet the trains have become but worries they may be too quiet.

“I think it’s almost too quiet, because we have kids and we constantly have to tell them to be careful around the tracks because you just don’t hear the train coming,” said Mike Pikney, a supervisor at The Salvation Army Northwest Community Center in West Palm Beach, located near railroad tracks. “A lot of kids today wear headphones and stuff like that, so the well-being of the children of the community is more my concern.”

All Aboard Florida, which operates Brightline, is owned by an affiliate of Fortress Investment Group LLC, a global investment management firm. Fortress Investment Group LLC is contracted to manage and advise New Media Investments Inc., which owns GateHouse Media, the parent company of The Palm Beach Post.

Follow Palm Beach Post reporter Ryan DiPentima on twitter at @Ryan_DiPentima



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Alabama boy, 13, found naked and chained in home
Alabama boy, 13, found naked and chained in home

A woman, her husband and her mother were arrested on child abuse charges Thursday after a 13-year-old boy was found naked and chained in a central Alabama home, AL.com reported. >> Read more trending news  Nicole Martin, 32, Joshua Daniel Martin, 26, and Vickie Seale Higginbottom, 58, were charged with torture and willful abuse of a...
Going bananas: Texas agents find $18M worth of cocaine in pallets of fruit
Going bananas: Texas agents find $18M worth of cocaine in pallets of fruit

Pallets of bananas that went unclaimed at port near Houston yielded a bunch of cocaine worth nearly $18 million, KHOU reported. >> Read more trending news  A business in Freeport, Texas, offered two pallets of the fruit to the Texas Department of Criminal Justice because they had not been claimed at the Ports of America, the television...
Sororities at George Mason University reject woman with Down syndrome
Sororities at George Mason University reject woman with Down syndrome

An Indiana woman with Down syndrome was not accepted to any sororities at George Mason University because of her disability, her sister claimed. >> Read more trending news  AnnCatherine Heigl, a sophomore from Zionsville, was the first person from Indiana to be accepted to the university’s LIFE program -- a full-time program for people...
Man accused of walking too close to Old Faithful arrested in Cheyenne
Man accused of walking too close to Old Faithful arrested in Cheyenne

A Colorado man accused of walking too close to the Old Faithful geyser in Yellowstone National Park last week faces more charges after he led police on a chase in Cheyenne, Wyoming, the Billings Gazette reported. >> Read more trending news  Gabriel Villalva, 27, of Greeley, Colorado, was arrested in Wyoming’s capital city Wednesday...
Man who killed Colts linebacker, Uber driver in crash gets 16 years in prison
Man who killed Colts linebacker, Uber driver in crash gets 16 years in prison

The man accused of killing Indianapolis Colts linebacker Edwin Jackson and an Uber driver during a crash in February was sentenced to 16 years in prison, WXIN reported.  >> Read more trending news  Manuel Orrego-Savala -- a 37-year-old Guatemalan man who was living illegally in Indiana, according to police -- was charged with four...
More Stories