Police say woman stole 1969 Preakness Cup from Delray storage unit


The 1969 Preakness Cup trophy, the prize of a major thoroughbred horse race won by a stallion that nearly landed a Triple Crown, was among the items an alleged looter grabbed from a storage unit in Delray Beach, police said.

Alicia Elaine Murphy, 59, of Boca Raton, faces several charges of burglary and grand theft. Investigators say she cut the locks on at least 12 storage units at CubeSmart, on Military Trail north of Atlantic Avenue, and pinched electronics, household items, musical instruments and taxidermy.

And one storage unit had more than $300,000 worth of goods, including family heirlooms and memorabilia from the 1969 Preakness Stakes. Majestic Prince, a thoroughbred colt, won the race that year, two weeks after winning the Kentucky Derby.

Murphy sent the Preakness Cup, and other mementos including gilded horseshoes, to an auction house in New York that specializes in sports collectibles, police say.

The auction company had given Murphy a $15,000 advance on the cup before detectives arrested her Wednesday.

Police value Murphy’s total haul at between $350,000 and $400,000, the report says.

Murphy told detectives that she rented a storage unit at CubeSmart for 24-hour access, and routinely broke into other units using bolt cutters. She rented a large vehicle and hired laborers at Home Depot to help load trucks with stolen merchandise, the police report says.

Murphy broke into the lockers at night when workers weren’t present, police say.

Murphy has been convicted of several felonies since the early 1990s, including cocaine possession, fraud, grand theft and forgery, state records show. Most recently, Murphy served eight months in state prison in 2005 on charges of grand theft and fraud.

The lucrative horse race memorabilia belonged to Francine McMahon, a Delray Beach resident whose father, Canadian industrialist Frank McMahon, owned Majestic Prince, according to news reports. Frank McMahon helped develop lucrative gas and crude-oil pipelines in Canada.

Majestic Prince nearly won a U.S. Triple Crown, a rare feat in thoroughbred racing earned when a horse wins three prestigious races in a six-week span — Kentucky Derby, Preakness and Belmont Stakes. Only twelve horses have won the Triple Crown, the last in 2015 by American Pharoah.

Majestic Prince was the first horse to enter the Belmont Stakes undefeated in 1969. But he had injured a ligament in his right front leg before the race, according to news reports. McMahon had wanted to rest “The Prince” as media called the champion thoroughbred, but changed his mind.

Majestic Prince finished second by 5 1/2 lengths to Arts and Letters in the Belmont and never raced again.

Staff Researcher Melanie Mena contributed to this report.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Ex-Santaluces student gets 35 years in fatal shooting of 16-year-old classmate
Ex-Santaluces student gets 35 years in fatal shooting of 16-year-old classmate

Frank Quarles on Friday was sentenced to 35 years in prison for fatally shooting a 16-year-old fellow student at Santaluces High School in February 2012 in a dispute over a bicycle. Quarles, who was 15 when he shot Michael Coogle-Robertson in a park in the Seminole Manor neighborhood near Lantana, will not be eligible for release until he serves 35...
One-armed Gardens golfer, 7, to be on Steve Harvey’s ‘Little Big Shots’
One-armed Gardens golfer, 7, to be on Steve Harvey’s ‘Little Big Shots’

Tommy Morrissey, a 7-year-old golf prodigy born with one arm, is no stranger to the spotlight. RELATED: Honda Classic 2017: Inspirational Gardens boy missing arm outhits pros He appeared on “The Ellen Show” when he was 3 years old. He traveled to Indonesia at age 4 to inspire other children with physical differences. He challenged PGA pros...
West Palm officer makes history as city’s first woman SWAT member
West Palm officer makes history as city’s first woman SWAT member

Before West Palm Beach police even hired her, Sarah Burgoon knew she’d be the department’s first woman SWAT member.  The undaunted 35-year-old officer didn’t think it’d be easy. She didn’t want it to be.  This month, Burgoon ran, shot and sweated her way past her male colleagues and into West Palm Beach...
A reprieve? Immigration officials cancel meeting with Palm Beach restaurant manager
A reprieve? Immigration officials cancel meeting with Palm Beach restaurant manager

Francisco Javier Gonzalez’s meeting with Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials was canceled Friday, and the Palm Beach restaurant manager will likely be granted an extended stay into the summer, according to his lawyer. Gonzalez, the manager of Pizza Al Fresco in Palm Beach, had a meeting scheduled at an ICE office in Miramar on...
Swedish musician Avicii dies at 28
Swedish musician Avicii dies at 28

Swedish DJ Avicii was found dead Friday in Oman, his publicist confirmed. He was 28.
More Stories