Meacham: Political polarization more rule than exception in US history


America may seem polarized, but Pulitzer Prize-winning presidential historian Jon Meacham said the current state of affairs is “actually more the rule than the exception” in U.S. history and can be remedied by returning to the principles of the nation’s founding.

Meacham spoke at a Forum Club of the Palm Beaches lunch on Tuesday and afterward signed copies of his recently released book The Soul of America: The Battle For Our Better Angels.

“It’s not a great moment if you are measuring overall social happiness in the United States,” Meacham told the crowd of more than 600 at the Kravis Center. “If you voted for the incumbent president, you believe that the country was inexorably headed down a path toward destruction and ruin. If you did not vote for him, you now think it is headed down a path toward destruction and ruin.”

Meacham called political “tribalism” the great problem of the age and said it goes against the ideals of the American revolution.

“The American Revolution, which continues to unfold even to this hour, was the greatest embodiment in western history that reason could take an equal stand against passion in the arena of public life,” Meacham said.

“If we don’t listen to each other, if we only watch one particular cable network or another, if we only filter out news sources that we tend to agree with, then we’re doing a disservice to the fundamental promise of the country. We’re not living into what the revolution was about.”

Paraphrasing Harry Truman, Meacham said Americans get the government they deserve.

“Politicians are far more often mirrors of who we are than they are molders. It’s the nature of popular politics,” Meacham said.

“If you don’t like what we’re getting, get in the arena and speak up. If you do, get in the arena and speak up. But don’t shout at each other because that’s not going to be true to that promise of the American Revolution. The American Revolution is about reason, not passion,” Meacham said.

Meacham described himself to the Forum Club as “not a partisan” and said he has voted for Republicans and Democrats in the past. He has been a critic of President Donald Trump and told The Palm Beach Post last week he wrote his latest book in response to Trump’s “singular failure of presidential leadership” after last summer’s deadly white nationalist demonstrations in Charlottesville, Va.

During a question-and-answer period after his remarks, Meacham was asked what Trump is getting right.

“Look, the economy is doing quite well,” Meacham said. “The markets love the deregulation … Unemployment levels are at historic lows.”

Meacham added: “While I don’t think the moment is unique, this experiment in presidential leadership is. We just don’t know how this will turn out. He has decided to kick over most conventions, if not all, in an attempt to see how it works. And it could work out.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

It’s hot outside! Indoor things to do in Palm Beach County and South Florida
It’s hot outside! Indoor things to do in Palm Beach County and South Florida

Summers in Florida are as bipolar as a Sour Patch Kids gummy. You know, first they’re sour, then they’re sweet. Except in Florida, there’s a touch of bitter too, with rain and heat competing to make our day miserable.  Luckily, we have some of the best beaches in the country, crystal clear natural springs and plenty...
LATEST: Person stabbed early Friday in Lake Worth
LATEST: Person stabbed early Friday in Lake Worth

A person was stabbed early Friday in Lake Worth, one of three violent incidents reported in the city’s Dixie Highway corridor that night, according to the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office. Deputies responded at about 1:15 a.m. to 1000 South Dixie Highway, near 10th Avenue South, for reports of a stabbing.  The victim was ...
LATEST: Person robbed at knifepoint in Lake Worth
LATEST: Person robbed at knifepoint in Lake Worth

Two men robbed a person at knifepoint late Thursday in Lake Worth, Palm Beach County sheriff’s authorities said.  The victim waved down a deputy shortly before 11 p.m. at Sixth Avenue South and Dixie Highway to report the robbery.  The victim said the men ordered him to empty his pockets. One man took his pocket knife and held it to...
BREAKING: Man shot in Lake Worth; sheriff seeks suspects
BREAKING: Man shot in Lake Worth; sheriff seeks suspects

A man was shot early Friday in Lake Worth, Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office authorities said.  At 6:15 a.m., deputies responded to the 600 block of North H Street just west of Dixie Highway for a reported shooting.  They found a man with non-life threatening injuries. The suspects fled the area in a vehicle, authorities...
NEW: Woman, 69, cries foul as PBSO seizes pounds of marijuana from Lake Worth-area home
NEW: Woman, 69, cries foul as PBSO seizes pounds of marijuana from Lake Worth-area home

Kathleen Szabo has been a court reporter and a chef. She's raised and sold exotic cats and wild animals. But it's her marijuana that recently got her into trouble. The Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office raided her home west of Lake Worth last month and arrested her for possession of 1,500 grams — 3.3 pounds — of marijuana and...
More Stories