LATEST: Suit says Boynton-area girl, 13, who died in crash called Lyft


The ride-sharing company Lyft took a 13-year-old girl in the middle of the night to a 17-year-old boy’s home, where she got in his pickup and died when it slammed into two trees west of Lantana early on July 9, a lawsuit filed this week contends.

Josie Saint Fleur still doesn’t know what her daughter, high-honors student Karenine Saint Louis, was doing out at 5:30 a.m. with Jimmy Aguirre, a boy the mother didn’t know. Saint Fleur, a nurse, has told The Palm Beach Post she was working an overnight shift and thought Karenine was home asleep. Lawyers said a grandmother was asleep in the home.

The lawsuit names as defendants Aguirre and his mother, as well as Lyft, and two Lyft drivers, one of whom is believed to have taken Saint Louis from her home west of Boynton Beach to Aguirre’s home in Greenacres. Lawyers said they were able to narrow down drivers to two names and eventually expect to learn which of the two picked up Karenine.

The lawsuit, filed Monday in Palm Beach Circuit Court, doesn’t specify damages.

Lyft spokeswoman Alexandra LaManna, contacted late Tuesday, had not yet seen the suit.

State records show Aguirre does not have a regular driver license, but only a Class E learner’s permit, which requires someone who’s at least 21 be in the front seat when he drives. The report on the crash says the two were the only ones in the 2002 Ford F-150 pickup when Aguirre lost control on a wet road west of Lantana.

No charges have been filed for now as the investigation continues, the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office said Tuesday. The Post has been unable to make contact either with Jimmy Aguirre or his family.

The suit said the Lyft driver “had a duty to request ID for confirmation of her (St. Louis’) age and to refuse transport after the driver would have learned that was under 18, and in fact 5 years younger than 18.” It says the driver had a duty to get the parent’s consent and to call Lyft’s “Critical Response Line” for guidance.

“They took a vulnerable child out of the home,” attorney Scott M. Fischer told The Post on Tuesday, “and drove her 9 miles into the hands of a 17-year-old male, which proceeded to cause her death, which we don’t believe would have happened had Lyft acted responsibly.” He said lawyers believe Karenine left her house at about 1 a.m.

According to Lyft’s web page, children 17 and under are forbidden to ride alone.

Relatives and friends of Karenine created an online page July 13 to raise money for her funeral. By Tuesday afternoon, it had raised about half of the $5,000 goal.

“Karenine’s mother and family are in desperate need for your prayers, support and donations as she tries to piece together the circumstances of her daughter’s passing of her soul,” the page said. It said funeral details were incomplete.

The 1,700-student Somerset Canyons charter school in suburban Boynton Beach, the charter school Karenine attended, will plant a tree to honor her when students return for the fall, an assistant principal said this past week. Karenine was about to start her third year there and was to be in the eighth grade. She was in advanced classes in the school’s medical program and wanted to be a psychiatrist.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

NEW: Boca councilwoman asks mayor to publicly apologize for ethics violations
NEW: Boca councilwoman asks mayor to publicly apologize for ethics violations

BOCA RATON — A Boca Raton councilwoman asked her colleague Mayor Susan Haynie to publicly apologize for violating ethics law when she voted on projects that benefited an outside client of her family’s business, developer James Batmasian. Councilwoman Monica Mayotte, who joined the five-person board in March, called...
NEW: Person of interest ID’d in Palm Beach Gardens dog theft
NEW: Person of interest ID’d in Palm Beach Gardens dog theft

A 48-year-old Palm Beach Gardens woman has been identified as a person of interest in the theft of a dog Saturday from a pet store. Police said they are seeking to speak to Heather Ryan regarding the theft of an 11-year-old Maltese mix named “Teddy” from the Petco store on Legacy Avenue.  She may be in Broward County as her...
Man once cleared in West Palm Chick-fil-A murder is going to prison
Man once cleared in West Palm Chick-fil-A murder is going to prison

Nearly two decades after the execution of an 18-year-old Forest Hill High School student at a West Palm Beach Chick-fil-A, the former co-worker once convicted, then exonerated of his murder, is now headed to prison on a heroin trafficking charge. Jesse Lee Miller, 36, of West Palm Beach, turned himself in Friday. He will go to prison as part of...
Cramped DMV on PGA Boulevard in Gardens to be replaced
Cramped DMV on PGA Boulevard in Gardens to be replaced

The days of sweltering in the heat or getting drenched in the rain while waiting for a new driver’s license soon will be over. Palm Beach County Tax Collector Anne Gannon on Monday announced plans to demolish the cramped DMV office across from The Gardens Mall on PGA Boulevard to make way for a bigger, better North County Service Center. Construction...
A year after re-starting political career, McAuliffe shakes up judicial races
A year after re-starting political career, McAuliffe shakes up judicial races

Nearly a year after former Palm Beach County State Attorney Michael McAuliffe announced he would try to jump-start his abandoned political career by running for circuit judge, he is roiling election waters again. McAuliffe, who stepped down from his powerful position as the county’s top prosecutor in 2012 to work for an energy company headed...
More Stories