Jury awards $2.5 million in damages in 2009 polo horse deaths


Seven years after 21 polo ponies collapsed and died before a match in Wellington, a Palm Beach County jury has awarded $2.5 million in damages to a wealthy Venezuelan and three polo players who owned the prized horses and an insurance company that partially covered the losses.

The question now is: Will anyone ever recover any money?

In clearing Wellington veterinarian Dr. James Belden of any wrongdoing, the jury last week put the majority of the blame on Franck’s Pharmacy, finding that it improperly mixed a nutritional supplement that had been ordered for the horses, turning it toxic.

The Ocala pharmacy went out of business in 2012, raising quesitons about how it could be forced to pay any damages to Victor Vargas, a Venezuelan banker, entreprenuer and polo enthusiast who owned 12 of the horses, or three polo players, who owned the other nine.

“There’s an issue of collectibility,” said attorney Daniel Bachi, who represented Belden in the two-week trial. “Whether they’ll ever be able to collect is uncertain.”

The jury ordered Franck’s, once one of the biggest compounding pharmacies in the nation, to pay $1.75 million to Vargas, Diamond State Insurance Co. and polo players Juan Martin Nero, Guillermo Caset and Nicolas Espain. The three athletes were playing on the wealthy businessman’s famed Lechuza Caracas team at the International Polo Club Palm Beach when the horses died in April 2009.

Two pharmacists who worked at Franck’s - Anthony Campbell and Nefertiti Abdullah - were ordered to pay $375,000 each in damages. However, Bachi said, Abdullah wasn’t a party to the lawsuit so he can’t be forced to cough up any money. That means Campbell is the only one of the hook.

Neither Campbell’s attorney or those representing Vargas, the polo players or the insurer returned phone calls for comment. They were seeking $4 million to replace the horses.

Belden said he has no idea why he was dragged into the litigation. Days after the horses collapsed, pharmacy officials admitted they had put too much selenium in the supplement it prepared for the horses. Considered an essential nutrient, it is also fatal in large doses.

“The lab admitted it from the get-go,” Belden said. “There was never any question what caused it.”

During the trial, evidence showed that the lab put 100 times more selenium in what was supposed to have been a generic version of Biodyl for the horses. Instead of adding one-tenth of 1 percent of selenium into the mixture that was to help the ponies recover between matches, it put in 10 percent.

While glad to put the lawsuit behind him, Belden said sitting through the trial brought back horrific memories.

Shortly before a quarterfinal match of the U.S. Open Polo Championships, some of the horses became sick. As they were walking toward the polo field, some fell in a grassy field. Others collapsed in their stables. While trainers and veterarians scrambled to treat them, within hours they were dead.

“It was sad to relive that day,” Belden said.



Next Up in Local

Two sentenced for sex trafficking of 14-year-old
Two sentenced for sex trafficking of 14-year-old

For plying a 14-year-old runaway with crack cocaine, having sex with her and turning her into a prostitute, two West Palm Beach men will spend roughly two decades in prison, a federal judge ordered on Thursday. Calling his conduct “reprehensible,” U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks sentenced 63-year-old Charles Edward Smith to 19 1/2...
NEW: Two killed in single-car crash in West Palm Beach
NEW: Two killed in single-car crash in West Palm Beach

Two people were killed in a traffic crash Thursday morning when their vehicle spun out of control and crashed into a wall along North Jog Road, West Palm Beach police said.  Police identified the crash victims as driver Oshane Edwards and passenger Kamron Greenidge, both 22.  According to police, the crash happened at about 1:30 a.m. along...
LATEST: Girl hurt when PBSO deputy allegedly ran stop sign now headed to rehab
LATEST: Girl hurt when PBSO deputy allegedly ran stop sign now headed to rehab

A college student is out of the hospital and on her way to rehab, 66 days after she was severely hurt in a crash after an off-duty Palm Beach County Sheriff's deputy allegedly ran a stop sign. Farrah Fox left Delray Medical Center on Thursday morning, heading for a long-term rehabilitation facility in Mount Dora, northwest of Orlando...
Ex-board member of Palm Beach charity admits stealing $2M from pension
Ex-board member of Palm Beach charity admits stealing $2M from pension

A former board member of a revered Palm Beach charity admitted Thursday that he stole at least $2 million from its pension fund in a carefully orchestrated scheme that spanned 25 years. Sitting in a wheelchair before U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks, 69-year-old William Minor pleaded guilty to a charge of mail fraud in connection with the massive...
More Stories