Gardens residents tell Council to leave term limits alone


Residents wore stickers with expired parking meters, stating “Don’t touch my term limits. Leave it alone!!”

A review committee and the Council said one more term would give allow them to do a better job.

With a court ruling on their side, Palm Beach Gardens residents have overwhelmingly supported strict term limits, but the city council is asking for a reprieve.

As it stands, city council members can serve no more than two, uninterrupted three-year terms because of a measure that 80 percent of voters approved in 2014. A council member forced from office by term limits may never run again, based on a court’s interpretation.

RELATED: After judge’s order, Carl Woods will be sworn in as Gardens councilman

Now, a group appointed by the council has suggested changing the rules to allow officials to serve three, three-year terms. The group also recommended allowing council members to run again after they’ve sat out a term.

The council directed the city attorney to draft measures to put on the ballot in March.

All five city council members took the seats of officials who had to leave office because of the retroactive term limits. If voters approve the proposed changes in March, council members could get one more three-year term than they’re allowed under the current rules.

RELATED: Palm Beach Gardens voters limit city council terms

Resident Fred Scheibl, a co-founder of the PBG Watch blog, said the council members shouldn’t be trying to get themselves a better deal.

“You were all elected under these rules, and you should abide by them,” he said.

Supporters of the Palm Beach Gardens Needs Term Limits committee wore stickers with a picture of an expired parking meter printed with the words “two term limit” and “Don’t touch my term limits. Leave it alone!!”

Sid Dinerstein, a BallenIsles resident who has fought for term limits, was among the most outspoken critics.

“We stand 16,000 strong. More residents voted for our term limits than voted for any of you,” he said. “Nobody could be as stupid and gullible as you think we are.”

Brian Seymour, an attorney who chaired the volunteer committee reviewing the charter, said the recommendations weren’t specific to any person.

“This is not about you. This is not about any previous council, and I don’t know who will be sitting up there in the future,” he said.

The committee never considered removing term limits, only tweaking them to give newly elected officials more time to learn the job, he said.

Term limits were at play in last year’s election between now-former councilman David Levy and Carl Woods. An appeals court ruled term limits made Levy ineligible for office after the city declared him the winner and swore him in.

Whether Levy had the majority of the votes cast was disputed, and a Palm Beach County Circuit judge ruled that a runoff was required. That was before the appeals court ruled Levy ineligible, and the circuit judge ruled Woods the winner by default.

Mayor Maria Marino said the city council wasn’t involved in forming the committee’s recommendations, and that the issues are for voters to decide.

Councilman Matthew Lane said he’d rather have two, four-year terms, the most common term in the country and state, mirroring how the United States picks the president. That would provide more stable leadership and save the city money by requiring fewer elections.

Seymour said the committee discussed four-year terms but ultimately decided it would be better to have two elections — opportunities to remove people from office — instead of just one.

As for allowing people to return to office after a break in service, an outside consultant hired to advise the committee said forcing people to sit out a term usually results in fewer people choosing to run again.

If voters agree with the recommendations, the city will also decide election winners by plurality instead of requiring one candidate to earn the majority of the votes cast.

That would allow straw candidates to dilute the “opposition vote,” Dinerstein said.

Run-off elections cost thousands of dollars, and the result doesn’t often change, according to the committee. An extremely small percentage of eligible voters choose the council person, the committee reported.

Palm Beach Gardens Attorney Max Lohman will rewrite the recommendations into legal-sufficient wording that city council will OK and put to voters for final approval in March. Residents criticized officials for the timing because no council seats are up for grabs in that election.

Lohman said Supervisor of Elections Susan Bucher won’t allow municipal questions on the ballot in November and doesn’t like to take them in August because it adds too many pages.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

NEW: No bond for man accused of stealing car with baby in backseat
NEW: No bond for man accused of stealing car with baby in backseat

A man accused of stealing a car with a baby in its backseat early Tuesday will remain in the Palm Beach County Jail until his next court hearing. Judge Ted Booras on Thursday denied bond on the kidnapping charge Marquise Sharkear Hudson is facing, even though Hudson declined to appear at his hearing. Hudson is accused of stealing a 2013 Kia Forte from...
NEW: Woman arrested in 2017 fatal shooting of man
NEW: Woman arrested in 2017 fatal shooting of man

A 28-year-old woman was arrested Thursday in the 2017 fatal shooting of a 26-year-old man in suburban West Palm Beach, according to the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office.  Ruby Martinez, 28, faces charges of manslaughter with a firearm and tampering with physical evidence in the death of Jamal Francis in March 2017. Martinez was arrested...
Cerabino: How Donald could Trump weekend’s ‘March for Our Lives’
Cerabino: How Donald could Trump weekend’s ‘March for Our Lives’

It’s great to be back in Florida. Up north, it was a little stormy … … but the weather here is beautiful as usual, and we’re looking forward to a very productive weekend. As you all know, I have been the only elected leader in America who isn’t afraid to stand up to the folks at the National Rifle Association...
NEW: Popular ‘escape room’ coming to Boynton Beach
NEW: Popular ‘escape room’ coming to Boynton Beach

By way of an entrepreneurial Boynton Beach resident, an international escape room franchise is opening the first business of its kind in the city. Michael Watts, a realtor and instructional coach for a Boynton charter school, will open Novus Escape Room with his business partner, Aldo Trevino...
Islands near at hand in the Lake Worth Lagoon
Islands near at hand in the Lake Worth Lagoon

It may look like a big clump of sand but evolution takes time. In this case, that sand, shipped from a dredging site a few miles north, will form five islands off the El Cid neighborhood. They’ll be seeded with sea grass, red mangrove saplings and smooth cordgrass, providing habitat for fish and sea birds. There’ll also be a handful of...
More Stories