Ethics panel begins probe of Boca Raton mayor’s potential conflict


The county ethics body that gave Boca Raton Mayor Susan Haynie the go-ahead in 2013 to vote on projects involving developer James Batmasian apparently has launched an investigation after a Palm Beach Post story detailed financial ties between Haynie and Batmasian.

Commission on Ethics Executive Director Mark Bannon says he is prevented by county rules from confirming whether such a probe is taking place. But one of his investigators this past week requested from the city a trove of emails exchanged between Boca Raton’s top officials that reference Haynie and Batmasian.

After The Post’s story, the Boca council made a formal request to the ethics commission for a review. But it’s likely the commission initiated the investigation on its own.

Haynie, a longtime Boca Raton political figure and Republican candidate for Palm Beach County Commission, and her husband founded a property management firm that for years has been collecting thousands in paychecks from a company controlled by Batmasian and his wife. All the while, she has voted on at least a dozen projects that benefit Batmasian, the largest commercial property owner in the city, without disclosing the business link, The Post found.

Without identifying herself or Batmasian, Haynie sought an ethics advisory opinion in 2013 to see if she could vote. After several revisions over months, the commission found that she could vote under narrow circumstances.

The opinion applies to only when Batmasian is neither the developer nor the applicant coming before the Boca Raton City Council. However, in the 12 votes she took, he or his company was the developer or applicant, The Post found.

The ethics investigator, Abigail Irizarry, made a public request Nov. 22 for city emails exchanged in 2013 that include keywords such as “Batmasian,” “Commission on Ethics,” and “property management company,” among others.

A week earlier, the council instructed City Manager Leif Ahnell to send a letter to the ethics commission asking the commission to review the 2013 opinion and “either affirm the issued advisory opinion or re-address the advisory opinion in an appropriate fashion.”

But the ethics commission doesn’t issue opinions on past opinions, Bannon said. Ethics commission staff discussed the letter this past week, but Bannon could not comment on what steps they might be taking, again citing county rules.

Instead, Haynie or the city can request a new opinion with a new set of facts to guide future votes.

Under those circumstances, the ethics commission’s request for emails is not a review of a past opinion, as Boca Raton requested, but a step in probing Haynie’s actions.

A related complaint from a Haynie political foe also is the subject of a Florida Commission on Ethics review.

The city council was expected to discuss the issue tonight.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Wellington game shooting: Too close for one family in more than one way
Wellington game shooting: Too close for one family in more than one way

It all started with a cryptic text from their daughter. “I’m safe,” Hope Lerman had written to her parents, defense attorney Gregg Lerman and his wife, Debra. “I’m with Coach Pagley.” It was Friday night, and the Lermans had expected their daughter home late from one of the most highly anticipated football games...
UPDATE: Fuel tanker rolls over, injures 2 and shuts down I-95 lanes in Lake Worth
UPDATE: Fuel tanker rolls over, injures 2 and shuts down I-95 lanes in Lake Worth

7:30 P.M. UPDATE: According to Palm Beach County Fire Rescue, the rollover crash involved a fuel tanker. Two people were injured and transported to a hospital by helicopter. All lanes were reported to be open. 7:05 P.M. UPDATE: According to Palm Beach County Fire Rescue, the rollover crash involved a fuel tanker. Two people were injured and...
Shooting at football game in Wellington not a ‘school’ shooting
Shooting at football game in Wellington not a ‘school’ shooting

Detectives are still piecing together what really happened amid the pandemonium after a shooting at the Palm Beach Central-Dwyer high school football game Friday night. But they, school officials, parents and students alike by Saturday had all reached the same conclusion about the incident: it was not a “school” shooting.  One or both...
Wellington game shooting: Pre-K teacher huddles with teens in lockdown
Wellington game shooting: Pre-K teacher huddles with teens in lockdown

WELLINGTON – The moment pre-K teacher Britt Downey was ushered into a room by the front offices of Palm Beach Central High School late Friday, hours of code-red lockdown drills kicked in. Downey, who teaches students with autism at Loxahatchee Groves Elementary School, wound up under a desk in a room along with six teenage girls after shots were...
Florida man, 88, allegedly set raccoon on fire for eating his mangoes
Florida man, 88, allegedly set raccoon on fire for eating his mangoes

An 88-year-old man was arrested Friday for allegedly setting a raccoon on fire for eating mangoes in his yard in Palm Bay, WKMG-TV reports.  Ezra James told authorities he was afraid the raccoon would bite him and give him rabies, said WKMG.  A neighbor called 911 as the raccoon burned alive. "I throw some gasoline on him and I...
More Stories