In reversal, PBC schools chief says to exclude charters in tax push

Facing pushback from school board members and the teachers union, Palm Beach County Schools Superintendent Donald Fennoy has dropped his proposal to give charter schools a share of a $150 million-a-year property tax increase if voters approve it.

The turnabout comes after board members declined last month to approve Fennoy’s last-minute recommendation that charter schools receive a slice of a tax hike proposed to raise money for higher teacher salaries, school security and extra teaching positions.

Fennoy’s recommendation in June, which came after legal threats from a Lantana charter school, was backed by an opinion from an education-law attorney who concluded that the school board faced legal risks if it excluded the county’s 48 charters.

RELATED: PBC public schools may share $150 million tax hike with charters

But the suggestion faced stiff resistance from some board members, who questioned the attorney’s legal reasoning and the proposal’s last-minute timing. Led by board member Frank Barbieri, they decided to postpone a decision until July 18.

Since then, the school district has obtained another legal opinion from a different lawyer, and this one gives the school board the go-ahead to leave charters out.

Armed with the new opinion, Fennoy now proposes that the school board carry on with its long-standing policy of excluding charter schools from its requests for voter-approved tax increases.

At stake is about $20 million a year that charter schools would be slated to receive if board members included them in the referendum to increase a special property tax and voters approved it in November.

The special tax, which property owners would pay in addition to regular school property taxes, has been in place for decades but has to be reapproved by voters this year.

Hoping for an influx of money, the district is proposing to quadruple the tax rate, from $25 per $100,000 of taxable property value to $100 per $100,000 of taxable property value.

The hike would raise the amount collected countywide from roughly $50 million this year to an estimated $200 million next year.

But if voters reject it, the school district will lose the $50 million it depends on today to pay for more than 650 teaching positions.

On a school board meeting agenda posted online Monday, Fennoy’s administration asks board members next week to approve placing a referendum on the November ballot that raises the special property tax on behalf only of “non-charter district schools.”

The reversal is sure to be cheered by the school district’s teachers and several board members, who have a strained relationship with the district’s charter schools and expressed frustration last month at being asked to share more tax proceeds with them.

Justin Katz, president of the county teachers union, said Monday that the school district “is making the right decision in moving forward with the language originally proposed.”

But cutting out the charter schools may prompt legal challenges and the potential for dedicated opposition to the proposal from charter school supporters.

Last year, a judge required Indian River County’s school board to give the county’s charter schools a proportional share of money from a special property tax referendum. That decision has emboldened charter schools locally.

But an attorney for the Greenberg Traurig law firm who reviewed state law at the school district’s request concluded that the school board “does not have an obligation to share with district charter schools any proceeds from such a millage levy.”

The chairman of Palm Beach Maritime Academy, a Lantana charter school, vowed Monday to fight the school board in court if it excludes them, saying that doing so wrongfully discriminates against charter school students by providing their schools with less money to support their educations.

“We’re not gonna lay down for that,” said Andy Binns, the school’s chairman. “How can you say we’re gonna discriminate against this group of kids?”

Ralph Arza, director of government relations for the Florida Charter School Alliance, called the reversal “disappointing.”

“Charter schools are public schools, and they are filled with public school students and also teachers who are trying to teach public school students,” he said.

Fennoy declined through a spokeswoman to comment Monday. In an interview in June, he said that sharing money with charter schools was not just a legal strategy but the right thing to do in the wake of the Parkland school shooting, given that some of the money is intended for school safety.

“The entire community is impacted by what happened in Parkland and this new reality,” he said. “And I can’t stand here as a father and say only the kids that go to my traditional schools should be protected.”

Even if charter schools aren’t included in the referendum, school district leaders have discussed providing them with extra money specifically for campus security.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

At least 13 dead in duck boat accident on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, officials say
At least 13 dead in duck boat accident on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, officials say

At least 13 people were killed and several others injured after a duck boat carrying tourists capsized Thursday night on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, according to authorities. >> Read more trending news  Update 10:25 a.m. EDT July 20: Stone County Sheriff Doug Rader said divers are going back in the water Friday in search of...
NEW: Florida woman whose monkey bit Home Depot worker in custody after fleeing state
NEW: Florida woman whose monkey bit Home Depot worker in custody after fleeing state

After failing to appear in court, the woman whose pet spider monkey bit an employee at a Home Depot store in Okeechobee was taken into custody by deputies early Friday.  In early June, Tina Ballard, 56, of Palatka, left her pet spider monkey in her car while she went into the store. The monkey escaped, made its way through the parking lot...
NEW: Arrest made in year-old Jupiter Farms arson case
NEW: Arrest made in year-old Jupiter Farms arson case

A 28-year-old Lake Park man is facing a charge of arson after a Jupiter Farms house sustained nearly $100,000 in damages during an August 2017 fire, according to the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office. Justin Cantrell was arrested July 11. He was denied bond and is being held at the Palm Beach County Jail. Debris from the fire, on 154th...
NEW: Massage therapist at day spa faces sexual battery charge
NEW: Massage therapist at day spa faces sexual battery charge

A massage therapist at a Jensen Beach spa is facing a criminal charge after a woman alleged that he touched her inappropriately during a session.  The Martin County Sheriff’s Office said Thursday it had arrested Joseph Paul Correia III, 50, of Port St. Lucie on a charge of sexual battery. His arrest came after a 62-year-old woman told sheriff&rsquo...
NEW: International arms trafficking gets Florida man 12-year prison sentence
NEW: International arms trafficking gets Florida man 12-year prison sentence

Using hollowed-out water heaters and air-conditioning units, Frederik Barbieri shipped hundreds of firearms — including AR-15 and AK-47 rifles — from South Florida to Brazil over five years, according to federal authorities.  On Thursday, the 47-year-old Port St. Lucie man was sentenced to more than 12 years in federal prison...
More Stories