Getting paid 6 cents an hour? Judge in Chatman case says that’s too low


One of the longest-serving employees at Kenny Chatman’s corrupt drug treatment operation won’t have to pay restitution while she serves her seven-year prison sentence, a federal judge ruled today.

Fransesia “Francine” Davis is currently making a measly 12 cents an hour working in a prison cafeteria, with no help from her family to afford basic commissary items.

At that rate, she has to work 44 hours to afford a box of tampons from the commissary, her court-appointed federal public defender, Neison Marks, argued today.

But under the terms of her plea deal, her earnings are even more pitiful: Half of what she earns in prison is supposed to go toward paying down more than $7 million in restitution.

RELATED: ‘Kenny Chatman kidnapped me:’ Read one woman’s human trafficking story

U.S. District Court Judge Donald Middlebrooks acknowledged that Davis was in a “bad spot” and that 6 cents per hour was “negligible” toward paying back millions.

He agreed that she wouldn’t have to pay anything while she serves her sentence. Once she’s out, 10 percent of whatever she earns has to go toward paying down the $7 million.

Davis was one of the longest-serving employees at Chatman’s Reflections Treatment Center in Broward County. She was also a “house mother” at his various sober homes in Palm Beach County, which were essentially drug dens where drug use was open and tolerated.

At one of his homes, in Mangonia Park, he kept women captive and pimped them out. One woman testified at his sentencing that she was held in chains and escaped through a window.

Davis pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit health care fraud and maintaining a drug-involved house.

Chatman pleaded guilty to money laundering, conspiracy to commit health care fraud and conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, and was sentenced to 27.5 years in prison. He’s appealing the sentence.

Davis and the other defendants, including Chatman, have to pay down the more than $7 million toward insurance companies that were defrauded. They’ll each pitch in 10 percent of their earnings until it’s paid.

EXCLUSIVE: The Palm Beach Post first exposed Chatman. He tried to sue us for it.

Apparently because of her crimes, she’s not eligible for a better Unicor job making various products such as clothing and car parts. The federal inmate work program typically pays between 23 cents and $1.15 an hour, according to its website.

Davis appeared today in handcuffs and a blue jump suit, clutching a worn manila envelope full of documents. She didn’t argue that she shouldn’t pay restitution once she’s released.

“I have no problem paying restitution,” she said. “It’s just that I have no outside help or anything.”

Davis, 44, was homeless until Chatman found her and took her in and gave her a job working in a sober home years ago, Davis’ daughter said earlier this year.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Congressmen want answers after Ryan asks House chaplain to resign
Congressmen want answers after Ryan asks House chaplain to resign

Democratic congressmen are seeking answers after House Speaker Paul Ryan asked the House chaplain to resign earlier this month, CNN reported. Father Pat Conroy resigned April 15, ending nearly seven years of praying to kick off House of Representatives sessions. Democratic Rep. Gerry Connolly said he wasn't sure why Ryan asked for the Jesuit priest&rsquo...
Dog recovers after attack by hawk in backyard
Dog recovers after attack by hawk in backyard

A dog in Massachusetts is on the mend after she was attacked in her backyard by a hawk. It's been a few days for Daisy and her owner Susan Nascimeno after the 10-year-old bichon frise was attacked by a hawk Monday afternoon while fenced in her East Freeport backyard.  "She was just covered in blood -- her chest, back, butt, everything was...
Texas man gets life in prison for beating, stomping girlfriend's baby
Texas man gets life in prison for beating, stomping girlfriend's baby

A Texas man was sentenced to life in prison Wednesday after his conviction for beating and stomping his girlfriend’s baby to death, KDFW reported. Joshua Beard and the child’s mother, Alexis Botello, are accused of burying the girl in Parker County. According to police, in 2014 Beard slammed 18-month old Tylea so hard onto a bed that...
Missing 15-year-old Kentucky girl found safe in Louisville, police say
Missing 15-year-old Kentucky girl found safe in Louisville, police say

A 15-year-old Kentucky girl who left school to leave with an unknown person has been found, WKYT reported Thursday. Amber Renae Wagers was found safe in Louisville, the Berea Police Department said in a Facebook post. Wagers, 15, walked out of Berea Community School around 10 a.m. Wednesday to leave with an unknown person, police said. Investigators...
James Shaw Jr. raises $170,000 for Waffle House shooting victims
James Shaw Jr. raises $170,000 for Waffle House shooting victims

James Shaw Jr., who disarmed a gunman who opened fire at a Waffle House in Tennessee on Sunday, has raised more than $170,000 in a fundraiser to help the victims’ families, CNN reported. Shaw, who wrestled a rifle away from the gunman and tossed it over the counter, launched a GoFundMe campaign that easily topped its $15,000 goal. Four...
More Stories