UPDATE: Melgen’s closing defense: Practice maybe malpractice, not fraud


Acknowledging Dr. Salomon Melgen made some mistakes as he struggled to treat more than 100 patients a day at clinics from Delray Beach to Port St. Lucie, his attorney spent more than three hours Tuesday trying to overcome what federal prosecutors called “staggering” evidence that the ophthalmologist bilked Medicare out of as much as $105 million.

The 62-year-old Harvard-educated retinal specialist should not be found guilty of 76 charges of health care fraud for sloppy record-keeping, attorney Matthew Menchel told a federal jury in closing arguments. Further, he said, the doctor shouldn’t be sent to prison for trying innovative measures to help patients who were told their vision loss was hopeless.

While nationally renowned ophthalmologists testified during the nearly two-month trial that they were appalled by Melgen’s methods, Menchel insisted they had “agendas.” The people the jury should listen to are the patients, he said.

“It’s the patients who are experts in blindness,” Menchel said “It’s the patients, not the doctors, who are experts.”

Patients who testified — both for and against the wealthy physician who faces corruption charges in New Jersey with Democratic U.S. Sen. Robert Menendez — didn’t hold any animosity toward Melgen, he said. “Patients smiled warmly at him for a reason,” he said.

The reason, Assistant U.S. Attorney Roger Stefin countered, was that they that they had no idea he was using them as “props” to rake in millions from the federal insurer.

“He wasn’t just aggressive,” Stefin said, using Menchel’s word for Melgen’s tactics. “He was abusive. He took advantage of patients in many cases — people who were elderly, people who were sick, people who were trusting.”

Melgen subjected patients — some who had prosthetic, blind or shrunken eyes — to dozens of unnecessary and sometimes painful tests to “line his pockets with millions and millions of dollars,” agreed fellow Assistant U.S. Attorney Alexandra Chase.

Jurors, who have endured weeks of complex testimony about medical procedures and Medicare regulations, are to begin their deliberations today.

In a bold request, Menchel told jurors that Melgen doesn’t want them to find him guilty of some of the charges while acquitting him of others in an attempt to appease both sides.

“He’s either guilty of all of it or he’s guilty of none of it,” he said. “It’s all or nothing. Do not compromise this case. That would be a disaster for Dr. Melgen.”

Each of the 42 counts of health care fraud carry a maximum 10-year sentence while the remaining charges of filing false claims and making false statements related to health care each can be punished by maximum five-year terms. The charges stem from his treatment of 30 patients — patients Menchel claimed were “cherry-picked” because they were “the worst of the worst.”

Prosecutors disputed Menchel’s contention. Further, they said, while the medical terminology and regulations may be complex, the case is simple.

“This case is black and white and I mean black and white literally,” Stefin said. He paused while one of scores of images that have formed the basis of the prosecution’s case flashed on jurors’ computer screens.

The image showed photos Melgen used to diagnosis the eyes of one patient. The photos showed clear black and white globes. The reason: the patient was blind in both eyes, Stefin said.

Even though the images showed nothing, Melgen billed Medicare for dozens of them over several years, Stefin said. He also billed Medicare for treating the patient for wet macular degeneration, a sight-robbing retinal disease he didn’t have, he said.

And that patient wasn’t unique, prosecutors said, recounting bills Melgen sent Medicare for tests given to patients who had prosthetic eyes or shrunken eyes.

Medicare records showed Melgen billed Medicare far more than any other retinal specialist in the nation. For instance, while his closest competitor nationwide made $33.6 million over six years for a particular procedure, he made $57.3 million. While the median, or typical, amount a retinal specialist made for a certain test was $3,678, he collected a whopping $16.8 million.

Menchel said the analysis of Medicare billing records was far from scientific. Further, he said, Melgen has already had to repay Medicare $8.9 million and has been asked to return another $32 million. National health regulators and federal judges agreed he wasn’t entitled to the $57.3 million he made by using a single vial of Lucentis, a drug used to curb wet macular degeneration, on multiple patients. The practice is known as multi-dosing.

Menchel insisted Melgen’s legitimate fight over his use of Lucentis prompted the criminal investigation. “He put a target on his back,” he said. “It’s one of the reason we’re in this courtroom today.”

Instead of letting go, he said, prosecutors dug in. Not satisfied to let Medicare recoup its money in civil actions, they filed criminal charges. At best, prosecutors are left with a medical malpractice case, he said.

Melgen, he claimed, could be sued by patients for improper treatment. He could lose his medical license. “But,” he insisted, “it’s not a crime.”

Pointing to the thousands of pieces of evidence they have gathered, prosecutors disagreed. The so-called “mistakes” Melgen made were intentional and fraudulent, Chase said.

“We don’t have mistakes here,” she said. “Over and over you have evidence of Dr. Melgen’s deliberate actions to violate the law, to continue to cheat Medicare. Dr. Melgen did it on purpose and he did it deliberately.”

>>RELATED: AJC Doctors & Sex Abuse Investigation Headlines




Next Up in Local

Police: Girl sexually assaulted riding on school bus in north county

A high school girl was sexually assaulted by the boy sitting next to her on a 30-minute bus ride home from the second day of school in the north end of Palm Beach County, school police report. The boy has been arrested, according to the report, in which the names and ages of both the victim and the accused were blacked out as well as the school they...
Woman in need of kidney transplant helps others with same disease
Woman in need of kidney transplant helps others with same disease

Every morning, Susan Caplan wakes in her Boca Raton home, hoping the wait is over. That this will be the day the matching kidney is found, and her 19-year quest will be at an end. She waits. And as she has done since her 1999 diagnosis of kidney disease, she passes the time by helping others who suffer from the same debilitating ailment. “Being...
Modern remodel creates dramatically geometric family home
Modern remodel creates dramatically geometric family home

BELLEVUE, Wash. — On the crest of one of Bellevue’s highest hills, a mesmerizingly modern form rises above treetops, horizontal lines stretching sideways from an exposed double-height stairway of diagonals and zigzags. Floating, glowing, beckoning, there and in the covered entry court: more than a dozen unexpected, suspended spheres. When...
Tips for tackling the grossest parts of your home
Tips for tackling the grossest parts of your home

Many of us spend our weekends chasing dirt and grime in our homes — vacuuming, mopping, scrubbing and washing. And no matter what we do, we’re suspicious that we didn’t and will never get it all. The truth is: We’re right. Here’s a look at some of the grossest parts of your home and what you can do to address them. FLOOR...
Jupiter Community Center to close for maintenance
Jupiter Community Center to close for maintenance

The Jupiter Community Center will be closed for annual maintenance for one week starting Aug. 29. The center will not hold any activities on Aug. 27. It is one of the polling places for the primary elections on Aug. 28, when it will be open from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. The only other activity that will take place on Aug. 28 is the School’s Out Camp...
More Stories