Too many lawyers spur road trip for Gardens building flaw trial


When the more than 1,000 residents of a sprawling Palm Beach Gardens condominium community sued home-building giant Kolter Homes for a whopping $36 million, there was no doubt it would be a big case.

So how big is it?

It’s so big there’s not a courtroom in Palm Beach County that can accommodate the roughly 40 lawyers who will represent Kolter and 17 subcontractors against claims by San Matera The Gardens Condominium Association that shoddy workmanship turned their promised luxury homes into water-soaked nightmares.

It’s so big there was talk of holding the trial at the Palm Beach County Convention Center. Instead, crews ripped out benches in a courtroom at the South County Courthouse to handle the phalanx of attorneys along with jurors and court personnel who are needed for the estimated month-long trial. It will mark the second time a jury trial has ever been held at the Delray Beach courthouse.

It’s so big, some 300 county residents — far more than are summoned for a typical trial — are being called in this week to assure the lawyers can find six jurors and four alternates who can decide the complex case.

It’s so big, those who want to watch the trial will have to do so from two small glass-walled rooms in the back of the courtroom because all the seats in what would have been the gallery will be filled with folding tables lined with lawyers. If more than 20 people show up, court officials said audio from the trial may have to be pumped into a nearby atrium.

“It’s one big logistics issue,” said attorney David Haber, who is representing the 676-unit development near The Gardens mall.

He credited court personnel for devising a way for his clients to have their day — or, as it turns out, days — in court after waiting six years for the lawsuit to be brought to trial.

It wasn’t easy. And finding a room big enough was only half of the problem.

Legally, jury trials can’t be held in Delray Beach. While a civil trial was held there in 1995, future ones were blocked in 2003 after a study found the demographic mix in the southern part of the county was too white to comply with court rulings that dictate that the racial makeup of jury pools must reflect the racial profile of the entire county. Based on the 2000 Census, 92 percent of the residents in the Delray Beach-Boca Raton area were white compared with 79 percent in the rest of the county.

That added yet another wrinkle to the trial. While prospective jurors will gather in a courtroom in the main Palm Beach County Courthouse in West Palm Beach for jury selection this week, those selected will be told to drive to Delray Beach for the trial when it begins Tuesday and then head back to West Palm Beach for deliberations.

Debra Oats, court operations consultant, said a variety of options were considered to find a place for the unwieldy trial. The convention center was rejected because parking is limited while a garage is under construction. It also would have cost about $35,000 to rent a room in the facility, but Oats said the lack of parking was the deal-breaker.

The cost of re-configuring the courtroom was minimal, she said. While an unusual situation, she expects the trial to go off without a hitch.

Haber said his clients are just happy their grievances over leaky windows, roofs and walls and other construction defects will finally be aired. “I don’t care if we try it on the courthouse steps,” he said.

An earlier version of this story said no jury trials have been held in the South County Courthouse in Delray Beach. A jury trial was held in a civil case in 1995.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Lake Worth firm sues over worker’s death in FIU bridge collapse
Lake Worth firm sues over worker’s death in FIU bridge collapse

A Lake Worth law firm on Wednesday filed suit on behalf of the widow of a 37-year-old Sunrise construction worker who died when a $14.2 million pedestrian walkway at Florida International University collapsed in March. Navaro Brown, who was working for a company that provides products to strengthen bridges, was among six who died when the 950-ton bridge...
NEW: Delray man, 27, killed in Boca Raton vehicle crash
NEW: Delray man, 27, killed in Boca Raton vehicle crash

A 27-year-old Delray Beach man has been identified as the victim of a fatal crash Monday night in Boca Raton.  City police said Jay Jonas died after his motor scooter was struck by another vehicle in the 7500 block of North Dixie Highway. Jonas died at Delray Medical Center. According to a police statement, Jonas was driving south on North...
La Mancha traffic calming plans in Royal Palm Beach: How to learn more

A busy residential thoroughfare in Royal Palm Beach could receive some relief from speeding vehicles looking to avoid the busy intersection of Royal Palm Beach and Okeechobee boulevards. La Mancha Avenue is eligible for traffic-calming measures, according to a survey completed for the village by consultant Simmons and White. The survey also reviewed...
PHOTOS: From 35th Special Olympics Torch Run in Palm Beach County
PHOTOS: From 35th Special Olympics Torch Run in Palm Beach County

As Bob Mooney stood in a parking lot Wednesday morning amid a sea of law enforcement vehicles and running enthusiasts clad in workout gear, he recalled the origins of the Law Enforcement Torch Run for Special Olympics. “I can tell you that the first year, I ran the torch by myself,” said Mooney, who has coordinated the event for all 35...
Fired FAU professor, who denies Sandy Hook, blasts federal judge
Fired FAU professor, who denies Sandy Hook, blasts federal judge

Fired Florida Atlantic University professor James Tracy blasted a federal judge on Wednesday, a day after she rejected his request for a new trial on his claims that the school robbed him of his First Amendment rights by dismissing him for expressing his beliefs that the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre and other national tragedies never happened...
More Stories