Suit: YSI whistleblowers blackballed from Florida teen-detention jobs


When County Commissioner Shelly Vana last year began gathering evidence of abuse and mismanagement at the Palm Beach County Juvenile Correctional Facility, she wasn’t acting alone.

Employees, concerned about the welfare of 118 teenage boys housed in the detention center, provided information that she credited with spurring Youth Services International to walk away from its multi-million-contract with the state to operate the facility. The company later bailed out on its lucrative contracts to operate seven other juvenile lockups around the state.

But two employees now say they paid a hefty price for helping Vana, according to a lawsuit filed Friday in U.S. District Court.

Once the Sarasota-based Youth Services International learned Fredrick Robinson, of Belle Glade, and Jean Roc, of West Palm Beach, were reporting problems at the detention center, near the South Florida Fairgrounds, it suspended them without pay, trumped up allegations against them and ultimately fired them, according to the whistleblowers lawsuit filed by Jupiter attorney Christopher Copeland.

Further, the suit says, by putting false and damaging information in their personnel files, the company effectively “blackballed” Robinson and Roc from getting jobs at any detention center in the state. When a prospective employer runs their names through a state database, the false allegations appear, destroying their chances of getting hired, the suit says.

While both are trained officers, “neither is working in their profession,” Copeland said. “They’re going from job to job and trying to survive.”

They are seeking an unspecified amount in back pay from the company as well as substantial damages for punishing them for exercising their First Amendment rights.

In a statement, the company disputed the claims. “The allegations contained in the litigation have been investigated by several state agencies in the past and all have been found to be without merit, ” it wrote. “YSI vigorously denies all the allegations in the complaint and looks forward to seeing these claims dismissed in court.”

Vana, who was county mayor when she began pushing the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice to cancel YSI’s contract, praised Robinson and Roc for speaking up when it would have been easy to remain silent. Robinson, she said, was key to helping her uncover information that the facility was understaffed, violence was rampant and youths’ basic needs — food, clothing and working toilets — weren’t being met.

“If it wasn’t for Fred, we would have never gotten YSI out of there,” she said. “He is the bravest person I have ever met.”

While she didn’t know Roc as well, she said he also provided important information at great personal risk.

“It’s awful,” she said of their predicaments. “For someone like Fred, who stands up and says this is wrong, he should be able to find a job. He just wanted the kids to be OK.”

Vana’s discoveries and other evidence, including records of fights that sent youths to the hospital for treatment, were mounting when the company in August announced it would bow out of its contract. Faced with criticism about the company’s operations elsewhere in Florida, state and federal lawmakers also began pressuring juvenile justice officials to cancel its seven other contracts.

In March, DJJ announced the company was walking away. Insisting they had done nothing wrong, YSI officials said the action was taken to settle a long-running Leon County lawsuit filed by a former YSI worker, who claimed it faked documents to keep its multi-million-dollar contracts and failed to provide services to juveniles in its care.

The detention center YSI operated in Palm Beach County has been renamed the Palm Beach Youth Academy. It is operated by Sequel TSI of Florida , a Huntsville, Ala., company co-founded by John “Jay” Ripley. He was a founder of YSI and served as its president, chief operating officer and chief financial officer, according to the company website.

On a recent visit, Vana said she was pleasantly surprised. “It’s totally different. It’s so much better,” she said. “They actually care about the kids.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

JUST IN: ‘The care they gave’: How EMS saved 77-year-old man after car struck bike
JUST IN: ‘The care they gave’: How EMS saved 77-year-old man after car struck bike

Roy McCarty calls it a blessing not that he was hit by a car, but where. The crash occurred in front of Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Station No. 42. The 77-year-old was out for a bike ride at 5 a.m. March 6 when he was struck by a driver who had fallen asleep. Crews at Station 42 were able to stabilize McCarty before another truck returned to take...
Dramatic Miami-Dade police video shows shootout at Trump Doral resort
Dramatic Miami-Dade police video shows shootout at Trump Doral resort

The Miami-Dade Police Department has released dramatic body-cam video from an officer who rushed into the lobby of the Trump Doral resort during a shootout with an armed man at 1:39 a.m. on May 18. Police identified the shooter as Jonathan Oddi, 42. Four days later, a motive for the bizarre incident has not been revealed. The video begins with...
WATCH: Florida man puts ex-girlfriend in trunk, leads deputies on 120 mph chase
WATCH: Florida man puts ex-girlfriend in trunk, leads deputies on 120 mph chase

A man was arrested after deputies said he punched his ex-girlfriend, put her in the trunk of a car, and then lead authorities on a 120 mph chase. The incident began Monday night in DeLand when Darrian Miller, 42, demanded his ex-girlfriend to drive him somewhere, WKMG reports. She complied, but after arriving at a food market Miller told her to...
West Palm green-lights all-options-open plan for transportation future
West Palm green-lights all-options-open plan for transportation future

The city has adopted an outline for a transportation future that puts trolley and bus riders, bicyclists and walkers on a more even footing with cars. In unanimously approving the mobility plan Monday night, the City Commission overstepped criticism the consultant-driven plan was an unrealistic and expensive road map for congestion. The mayor of Palm...
NEW: ‘No-swim’ advisory lifted for Lake Worth Beach
NEW: ‘No-swim’ advisory lifted for Lake Worth Beach

Health officials have lifted a ‘no-swim’ advisory that was issued last week for Lake Worth Beach.  Recent test results showed moderate levels of bacteria, making the water quality satisfactory, the Palm Beach County health department said Tuesday.  Swimmers are still encouraged to rinse off with fresh water after swimming...
More Stories