Dalia Dippolito a U.S. Supreme Court case? Justices to decide


The U.S. Supreme Court met Friday to decide whether to consider a number of cases from around the nation. Among them, a case that could challenge Arizona’s death penalty, whether criminal defendants can claim double jeopardy after overturned convictions — and Dalia Dippolito?

True, according to court records and attorneys for the former Boynton Beach newlywed, now serving a 16-year prison sentence for trying to have a hitman kill her then-husband in a 2009 Boynton Beach case that sparked three trials, a reality TV show, a book and millions of YouTube clicks on a video of her crying fake tears at a staged crime scene.

RELATED: Complete Dippolito case coverage

Though issues in Dippolito’s storied case included allegations of antifreeze-spiked Starbucks drinks, a fake hitman who offered a cash-back guarantee and a strategy during her first trial later dubbed “the balloon boy defense,” her attorneys believe a part of how her case unfolded challenged a much more sacred pillar of American law: the First Amendment.

In a petition filed with the country’s highest court before Thanksgiving, attorneys Greg Rosenfeld and Andrew Greenlee asked the justices to consider taking on their challenge of Palm Beach County Circuit Judge Glenn Kelley’s decision to issue a gag order between Dippolito’s second and third trials last year.

“Does the issuance of a pretrial gag order prohibiting criminal defense attorneys from disseminating political speech violate the First Amendment, where the extrajudicial comments giving rise to the gag order occurred more than four months prior to trial, and where the State presented no evidence of an imminent or substantial threat to the fairness of the trial?” reads the question Rosenfeld and Greenlee have asked the Supreme Court to consider.

According to court records, the nearly 70-page petition was distributed to the nine U.S. Supreme Court justices on Dec. 14 and added to the list of several hundred cases that they discussed Friday at one of their regularly scheduled conferences to review which cases they will take up. As of late Friday, it was unclear whether or not the high court had decided to hear Dippolito’s case.

On Dec. 7, John M. Klawikofsky, an attorney for the state of Florida, sent the court a waiver declining to respond to the claims.

Florida Department of Corrections records show that Dippolito is now being housed at the annex of the Lowell Correctional Institution in Ocala.

Her case began in 2009, when Boynton Beach Police arrested her at the end of an undercover investigation sparked by her lover, who warned police she was shopping for a hitman to kill her now ex-husband, Michael Dippolito. Two years later, a jury convicted her of solicitation to commit first-degree murder after her failed defense that she and Michael Dippolito contrived the murder-for-hire plot as a hoax to score their own reality television show.

But Greenlee was able to get that conviction and accompanying 20-year prison sentence overturned on appeal, making way for a second trial that ended with a hung jury in December 2016 after Dippolito’s defense team heaped heavy criticism on the Boynton Beach Police Department and accused it of manufacturing the case to impress a camera crew from the reality television show “COPS.”

Prosecutors afterwards claimed defense attorneys’ comments to the media could taint a subsequent jury pool, and Kelley issued a ruling limiting both prosecutors and defense attorneys to making public comment only on procedural matters in the case until the start of the third trial in June.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Supermarket ‘renewal’: Winn-Dixie remake adapts to Lantana changes
Supermarket ‘renewal’: Winn-Dixie remake adapts to Lantana changes

Winn-Dixie unveiled its remodeled Lantana store on May 17 with fanfare — a high school marching band, gift cards, specials and a cake. The 59-year-old Winn-Dixie location now boasts, among other features, a smokehouse serving slow-cooked chicken, ribs and brisket as well as a broader selection of wines, sustainably-sourced seafood and more space...
Suit: District denied overtime pay to school bus drivers for years
Suit: District denied overtime pay to school bus drivers for years

Five Palm Beach County school bus drivers say that the school district systematically denied them overtime pay for at least two years as they worked long hours transporting children. In a federal lawsuit filed last week, the drivers allege that they routinely worked 50 hours a week and were legally entitled to higher overtime wages for the last 10...
Philip Roth dead at 85: Writers, public figures remember Pulitzer Prize-winning author
Philip Roth dead at 85: Writers, public figures remember Pulitzer Prize-winning author

Philip Roth – the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of "American Pastoral" and other highly acclaimed works such as "Portnoy's Complaint," "The Human Stain" and "The Plot Against America" – has died of congestive heart failure, The Associated Press reported late Tuesday. He was 85. Fellow writers...
Milkweed feasting more than you realize
Milkweed feasting more than you realize

As we all strive to get our hands on every native milkweed for our states and to the ultimate benefit of the Monarch butterfly I thought I might plug its use for the other guys. Your first thought might be I’m talking about the Queen or Soldier butterflies that are related to the Monarch and also must have milkweeds as larval host plants. That&rsquo...
Sons and Daughters of Italy award scholarships to high school seniors
Sons and Daughters of Italy award scholarships to high school seniors

PALM BEACH COUNTY SCHOOLS FAITH LUTHERAN SCHOOL A fundraiser, Dog Days of Summer, takes place 9 a.m.-1 p.m. June 2 at the school, 555 U.S. 1, North Palm Beach. Activities include a dog wash, bounce house, a midway for kids, fitness demonstrations for people and dogs, free blood pressure screenings, auctions and raffles and refreshments. ALLAMANDA ELEMENTARY...
More Stories