Cerabino: Florida high school girl launches bra rebellion

Does the U.S. Constitution cover a Florida high school girl who shows up for classes without wearing a bra under her shirt?

This is not an idle question. The girl is Lizzy Martinez, a 17-year-old junior who went to her Braden River High School classes one day last month in a loose, dark T-shirt and jeans. She Tweeted about what happened next.

“I decided not to wear a bra today and got pulled out of class (because) one of my teachers complained that it was a ‘distraction to boys in my class.’ ” she wrote. “My school basically told me that boys’ education is far more important than mine and I should be ashamed of my body.”

After being sent to the dean’s office, Martinez was given a T-shirt to wear under her shirt. After putting it on, Martinez was told that wasn’t good enough.

She sent the girl to the nurse’s office to get four adhesive strips, and told her to make an X-pattern on each breast to cover her nipples.

Martinez was upset, and she later Tweeted “stop sexualizing my body” to her high school’s Twitter page. The high school responded by blocking the girl’s Twitter account.

And by that night, the girl’s mother began complaining to the school’s principal, the Manatee County School Board and the district superintendent for the way her daughter was treated.

School district officials would later defend the actions of administrators by saying that although the school dress code doesn’t address girls not wearing bras, it does say that students are not permitted to wear attire that is “indecent” or “disrupts the ordinary learning environment.”

In Palm Beach County’s public schools, distracting or disrupting clothing has been interpreted to include a Confederate flag T-shirt and a beaded necklace of the Cuban flag. And in one case, a teacher was sanctioned for wearing an Obama T-shirt to school after a presidential election.

But as for underwear, it’s usually only mentioned as a violation if it is worn over the student’s clothing. In Martinez’s school district, it just says, “all undergarments must be covered.”

It doesn’t say anything about not wearing them. But that may now change. As a result of what happened to Martinez, Diana Greene, the Manatee County Schools Superintendent, has recommended that the dress code be amended to explicitly require girls to wear bras.

Martinez, who missed days of school over this issue, decided to fight back. And she, like many young people, had become galvanized to action by the February mass shooting of students and staff at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland.

After that school shooting, she posted on Twitter:

“I’m completely sickened that we live in a country that is run by such money-hungry people who would rather watch people get murdered, rather than take action to prevent such horrific tragedies.”

She followed it with the hashtags “NeverAgain,” “Gun Reform Now” and “Kill The NRA.”

And she retweeted former President Barack Obama’s shout-out to the student activism after Parkland, which said in part, “Young people have helped lead all our great movements.”

So I guess you could say Martinez was already primed for protest when the bra episode happened to her.

So she organized a protest at her school, giving it the hashtag “Bracott.”

“Show support for the destigmatization of natural bodies” she posted online in a graphically designed poster.

As part of the Bracott, she urged girls to clip bras on their backpacks, while instructing boys to put adhesive strips on their shirts on top of their nipples.

The school reacted quickly by sending a note home to parents, and putting out the word that students could face out-of-school suspensions and lose their ability to attend the school prom if they participated in the Bracott.

The protest fizzled. But by then Martinez and her beef with the school district had become a national story. She was featured in a story by The New York Times, and lawyers for the American Civil Liberties Union took up her cause.

On Monday, lawyers for the ACLU sent an eight-page letter to the girl’s school district that outlined why “enforcing the dress code selectively against female students, and doing so in a manner that reinforces invidious sex stereotypes” is a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Requiring girls to wear bras “reflects overly broad and archaic generalizations about boys’ inability to control their sexual impulses and girls’ inability to make their own decisions about the clothing that makes them feel safe and comfortable,” the ACLU letter said.

“These stereotypes reinforce a culture of victim blaming in which schools convey the message to female students that they are at fault for experiencing sexual harassment if they make certain clothing choices.”

The letter calls for the school district to remove the prohibition in its dress code for “personal attire or grooming (that) distracts the attention of other students or teachers from their school work.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

NEW: Officers from two city police departments at Riviera Beach home 
NEW: Officers from two city police departments at Riviera Beach home 

Police officers from two agencies have closed off parts of a Riviera Beach neighborhood Thursday evening.  Police cars for Riviera Beach and West Palm Beach officers put up police tape near a home on west 14th Street and Avenue R, just south of Blue Heron Boulevard and east of North Congress Avenue.  West Palm Beach police said...
Morgan Freeman friend defends actor after misconduct allegations, speaks out against accusers
Morgan Freeman friend defends actor after misconduct allegations, speaks out against accusers

At least eight women have accused actor Morgan Freeman of inappropriate behavior, according to a report from CNN. The women said the behavior happened on and off movie sets. >> Read more trending news  Freeman is an Academy Award-winning actor, but he's also a business owner in Clarksdale, Mississippi. Two blocks around the corner...
A year later: What’s going on with Jupiter’s proposed no-wake zone?
A year later: What’s going on with Jupiter’s proposed no-wake zone?

A female leatherback turtle had to be euthanized on May 8 after suffering five propeller cuts, each 24 inches long, that became infected with meningitis. One slice was so deep that it severed the turtle’s spinal cord causing her to become paralyzed, according to the preliminary necropsy. The turtle, that was “loaded with eggs,” was...
Honda Classic charity gets a new president
Honda Classic charity gets a new president

John Domenico has been tapped as president of the Children’s Healthcare Charity, the charitable arm of the Honda Classic.  Domenico has served on the board for eight years and succeeds Joe Steranka, who finished his four-year term. Domenico is a managing director and private client advisor for U.S. Trust, a private bank that serves high...
Veterans ceremony: We’ll always honor their memory, ‘it’s just in a different realm’
Veterans ceremony: We’ll always honor their memory, ‘it’s just in a different realm’

Through teary eyes and cracked voices, family members of fallen veterans walked to the front of the room, placed a white flower in a vase and spoke the name of their loved one. They gathered Thursday at the West Palm Beach VA Medical Center for the Last Roll Call Ceremony of Remembrance, to honor and celebrate veterans who have died over the last year...
More Stories