Analysis: Did Trump’s tweet about Flynn’s guilty plea admit something it shouldn’t have?

Some say Trump tweeted an admission to obstruction of justice. One prominent watchdog said it would have been the end of any other president.


Editor's note: The Post is now reporting that the tweet was authored by President Donald Trump's personal lawyer, John Dowd, according to two people familiar with the situation. The fact that Dowd authored the tweet could limit its salience to the investigation, but the White House still hasn't publicly corrected anything.

A little more than 24 hours after Michael Flynn pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI, President Trump finally took to Twitter to offer his thoughts. He may wish he hadn't. 

In his first tweet on the subject since Flynn's plea, Trump argued that Flynn had no reason to lie about his actions because they weren't unlawful. But it's the first part of the tweet that caught plenty of people's attention. 

The entire tweet reads: I had to fire General Flynn because he lied to the Vice President and the FBI. He has pled guilty to those lies. It is a shame because his actions during the transition were lawful. There was nothing to hide! 

"I had to fire General Flynn because he lied to the Vice President and the FBI," Trump began. 

Except when Trump fired Flynn on Feb. 13, he mentioned only Flynn's comments to Vice President Mike Pence — not the FBI. In fact, Flynn's contradictory comments to the FBI on his meeting with the Russian ambassador weren't public knowledge at the time. And the current timeline as we understand it does not suggest the White House had direct knowledge of what Flynn told the FBI at the time. 

Flynn's comments to the FBI didn't come into the public domain until three days after his dismissal, on Feb. 16, when The Washington Post's Sari Horwitz and Adam Entous reported that Flynn had wrongly denied discussing sanctions with the Russian ambassador: 

"Former national security adviser Michael Flynn denied to FBI agents in an interview last month that he had discussed U.S. sanctions against Russia with that country's ambassador to the United States before President Trump took office, contradicting the contents of intercepted communications collected by intelligence agencies, current and former U.S. officials said. 

The Jan. 24 interview potentially puts Flynn in legal jeopardy. Lying to the FBI is a felony offense. But several officials said it is unclear whether prosecutors would attempt to bring a case, in part because Flynn may parse the definition of the word "sanctions." 

Some see a problematic admission in Trump's tweet on Saturday — possibly even something that could be construed as an admission to obstruction of justice. Here's why: 

The day after Trump fired Flynn, on Feb. 14, Trump urged then-FBI Director James Comey to be lenient with Flynn, according to Comey's notes at the time, saying, "I hope you can let this go." If Trump knew at that time that Flynn had lied to the FBI and was under investigation, the argument goes, it may constitute an attempt to obstruct that investigation. 

Walter Shaub, the former head of the U.S. Office of Government Ethics, suggested the tweet could prove a major misstep for the president and even that it might have cost any other president his job. 

...just couldn't resist commenting on Flynn. 

Shaub's tweet: Are you ADMITTING you knew Flynn had lied to the FBI when you asked Comey to back off Flynn??????????????????????????????????????????? 

Shaub followed with another tweet: Before we slipped into an alternate universe of unabashed corruption, this tweet alone might have ended a Presidential administration. 

Others agreed, including Lawfare Executive Editor Susan Hennessey, who said Trump's tweet amounted to a "confession to essential knowledge elements of an obstruction of justice charge." 

She tweeted: This is a pretty substantial confession to essential knowledge elements of an obstruction of justice charge. 

Still, at the time it likely wasn't difficult for Trump and the White House to have surmised that Flynn had been under investigation. Acting Attorney General Sally Yates had told White House counsel Don McGahn on Jan. 26 — two days after Flynn's FBI interview — that Flynn had discussed sanctions on his phone calls with the Russian ambassador. This was contrary to what Flynn had told Pence and opened Flynn up to blackmail, Yates told McGahn. 

Yates has said she told McGahn that Flynn had been interviewed by the FBI, but she says she did characterize for McGahn what Flynn had told the FBI. 

"We also told the White House counsel that General Flynn had been interviewed by the FBI on [January] 24," Yates said in congressional testimony on May 8. "Mr. McGahn asked me how he did, and I declined to give him an answer to that. And we then walked through with Mr. McGahn essentially why we were telling them about this and the first thing we did was to explain to Mr. McGahn that the underlying conduct that General Flynn had engaged in was problematic in and of itself. Secondly, we told him we felt like the vice president and others were entitled to know that the information that they were conveying to the American people wasn't true." 

So Yates didn't clearly state to McGahn that Flynn had misled the FBI or that he was under investigation, but given the content of their conversation — including talking about Flynn's intercepted communications — it wouldn't have been difficult to come to that conclusion. And if McGahn told Trump about the conversation with Yates, it's likely Trump believed Flynn was in legal jeopardy when he spoke to Comey on Feb. 14. 

It's also possible Trump merely misremembered the timeline of what he knew when as he fired off his tweet on Saturday. But either way, it doesn't change the fact that he just tweeted something he may regret. 

Later Saturday, Dowd said, "The tweet just paraphrases what [White House lawyer] Ty Cobb issued yesterday. I refer you to Comey's testimony about Flynn's answers. I have nothing further." 

But Cobb's comments Friday didn't address the timeline like Trump's tweet does. Cobb merely said Friday that the "false statements involved mirror the false statements to White House officials which resulted in his resignation in February of this year."

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

Boynton woman killed in Delray car crash
Boynton woman killed in Delray car crash

A Boynton Beach woman was killed early Saturday in a three-car crash in suburban Delray Beach, the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office said. A car driven by Gerilynn B. Krieg, 69, was in the northbound center lane of Jog Road waiting for a traffic light to cycle green at Champion Boulevard. A car driven by Fay M. Zolin, 72, of Delray Beach was...
March for Our Lives: President’s detour avoids gun control rally and impeachment billboard
March for Our Lives: President’s detour avoids gun control rally and impeachment billboard

Demonstrators are using social media to get out their message. UPDATE 3:02 p.m.: Emma Gonzalez, a senior at Marjory Stoneman Douglas, took the stage in Washington and remained silent for 6 minutes and 20 seconds. Although the president bypassed the March for Our Lives by taking a detour, demonstrators continued their march to a bridge near Mar-a-Lago...
Trump in Palm Beach: Motorcade detour avoids March for Our Lives and impeachment billboard
Trump in Palm Beach: Motorcade detour avoids March for Our Lives and impeachment billboard

UPDATE 3 p.m.: The president has returned to Mar-a-Lago and is not expected to leave again today. UPDATE 2:20 p.m.: The president’s motorcade has taken a detour away from the March for Our Lives. Upon leaving his golf club, the motorcade turned north on Australian Avenue, then east on Okeechobee Boulevard. The motorcade then headed over the middle...
With session done, what is Senate President Negron’s political future?
With session done, what is Senate President Negron’s political future?

If you had asked Senate President Joe Negron what his plans were immediately following the close of the 2018 session of the Florida Legislature on March 11, he would have told you he was leaving that night to go home to Stuart. But if you ask Negron – who served in the Florida House for six years prior to his 2009 election to the Senate &ndash...
For Russia’s Putin, pressure pays off in facing weak, divided West
For Russia’s Putin, pressure pays off in facing weak, divided West

The U.S. and Europe appeared last week to be lining up alongside the U.K. for a new round of pressure against Vladimir Putin over Russia's alleged use of a nerve agent to poison a former spy outside London.  But the West's united front didn't last long. President Donald Trump didn't even bring up the case in a call to congratulate Putin on his...
More Stories