2 addiction treatment center owners indicted after reaping $50 million

Federal prosecutors unsealed indictments on Wednesday charging eight people — sober home and drug treatment owners, employees and a doctor — with health care fraud and money laundering in two of the highest profile investigations in the crackdown on corruption in South Florida’s drug treatment industry.

Kenneth Bailynson, owner of the defunct Good Decisions Sober Living in West Palm Beach, and Eric Snyder, owner of Real Life Recovery and Halfway There, both face more than 20 years in prison and forfeiture of millions of dollars and dozens of condominiums and homes if convicted of bilking insurance companies out of more than $50 million for bogus urine drug tests for addicts.

The FBI raids at Bailynson and Snyder’s businesses in late 2014 grabbed headlines and were the first in an ongoing multi-agency federal crackdown on patient brokering and insurance fraud called Operation Thoroughbred.

Bailynson, known for his explosive temper, psychiatrist Dr. Mark Agresti, Stephanie Curran and Matthew Noel, employees of Good Decisions, bilked more than 80 insurance companies out of $31.3 million in bogus drug tests, according to the indictment.

The charges span four years and detail how Bailynson operated his sober home as a cover for a full-service drug testing empire complete with its own lab, a doctor to write prescriptions for drug screens and condominiums to house addicts with insurance.

According to the indictment, Bailynson bought more than two dozen condos in Green Terrace, a dilapidated complex at 2800 Georgia Ave. in West Palm Beach. He offered insured addicts free rent in exchange for their urine and their commitment to attend drug programs where Bailynson received kickbacks from the operators for each addict he enrolled, the complaint says.

Bailynson, Noel, Curran and four unindicted co-conspirators also paid kickbacks to recruiters to bring insured addicts to Good Decisions for housing. Bailynson hired Dr. Agresti, a West Palm Beach psychiatrist well-known in the drug treatment community, as his medical director.

Agresti, in turn, wrote prescriptions for urine drug screens that were not medically necessary and did not use the results to determine appropriate treatment, according to the indictment.

A Palm Beach Post investigation in 2015 detailed how Bailynson took over the condominium complex and turned it into an armed camp, where guards with guns made sure addicts did not leave and nosy residents minded their own business. By the time the FBI raided Good Decisions in September 2014, Bailynson had converted the pool clubhouse into a urine collection site and banned unit owners from entering.

Urine testing is a staple of drug treatment, a fast way to track relapse and gauge use of prescribed drugs. It’s also cheap. Corner drug stores sell $25 tests that will immediately indicate the presence of a drug. However, unscrupulous treatment operators hire doctors to prescribe more complex — and costly — tests that reveal not only the presence of a drug, but how much is in the addict’s system.

Addiction treatment bonanza: How urine tests rake in millions

The urine of addicts living at Good Decisions was tested at least three times a week. In all, Bailyson’s businesses billed insurance companies for more than $106 million worth of drug tests. The insurance companies paid out $31.3 million.

The other indictment unsealed on Wednesday accuses Eric Snyder, owner of the defunct Halfway There and Real Life Recovery sober home and treatment center in Delray Beach, Paul Materia, Joseph Lubowitz and Christopher Fuller with running a similar operation that raked in $20.1 million from insurance companies for urine drug tests.

Snyder and Fuller were both arrested in July 2017. In a 26-page federal complaint, Fuller was described as a “junkie hunter” hired by Snyder to provide addicts who had insurance for his sober homes and drug treatment center. The document described how Snyder bribed patients with airline tickets, cash, rent and visits to strip clubs. Fuller trolled AA meetings and “crack” motels to find patients, the complaint said.

But prosecutors agreed to hold off on indicting Snyder and Fuller as they tried to negotiate a plea deal with both men. After months of delaying the case, prosecutors went ahead and convened a grand jury, which issued an indictment on June 7.

Musclebound millionaire: How Eric Snyder made his fortune

The indictment describes a multi-state business operation that ensured Snyder’s halfway homes and drug treatment center were full. Lubowitz recruited addicts from his treatment centers in New Jersey and was paid a commission for each addict he admitted to Snyder operations.

Patients’ signatures were forged on sign-in sheets, forms were backdated and fraudulent documents created to make it appear absent patients had attended treatment, according to the indictment. Insured addicts who tested positive were rarely evicted and often urine was collected but not tested. Uninsured addicts were given less costly drug tests, according to the indictment.

Materia ran Snyder’s businesses and was responsible for billing insurance and overseeing lab technicians at the on-site laboratory. In all, Snyder billed insurance companies $58.2 million for urine tests and treatment.


The Palm Beach Post has been investigating corruption in the addiction treatment industry for more than three years. One of the first stories was about Ken Bailynson and Good Decisions. It detailed many of the practices alleged in the indictment. More than 50 people have been arrested by federal and state authorities. To read our investigative coverage, go to www.myPalmBeachPost.com/soberhomes

Palm Beach Post staff researcher Melanie Mena contributed to this report.

Next Up in Local

Cerabino: Torn-jeans dress-code flap hard to bare for school parents
Cerabino: Torn-jeans dress-code flap hard to bare for school parents

I’m foolishly wading into a great controversy gripping our community. That is, whether it was right for Palm Beach County Mayor Melissa McKinlay’s daughter to be hauled out of her high school class for violating the dress code with a pair of jeans that had a wide rip at the right knee. The high-powered mom took to her Facebook page last...
Delray throat cancer survivor to perform concert in Boca on Saturday
Delray throat cancer survivor to perform concert in Boca on Saturday

There was a time when Cecilia St. King wasn’t sure if she’d belt out a ballad again. Singing was how St. King coped with tragedy, including the events of Sept. 11, 2001 — she was blocks from the World Trade Centers when they’d collapsed in a terrorist attack. Six months later, she was diagnosed with throat cancer. “When...
BREAKING: Man found shot to death in Lake Worth
BREAKING: Man found shot to death in Lake Worth

A man was found shot to death Tuesday afternoon in Lake Worth, the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office said. Deputies responded to the shooting around 2 p.m. in the 2600 block of 6th Avenue South and found the man dead. The cause of the shooting is unknown. Anyone with information is asked to call Crime Stoppers of Palm Beach County at (800)...
Treasure Coast teacher sues over shooting at Jacksonville tournament
Treasure Coast teacher sues over shooting at Jacksonville tournament

Treasure Coast history teacher Dalton Kent was competing in one of the final rounds of a gaming tournament in Jacksonville last month when the deafening roar of gunfire pierced his concentration. Diving under the table, the 22-year-old Port St. Lucie man was convinced he was going to die. While two gamers were killed during the Aug. 26 rampage at...
More Stories