Is Vanity Fair right to trash Mar-a-Lago’s architectural style?

In a recent online Vanity Fair article about the bucolic character of Bedminster, New Jersey, where President Trump is spending his 17-day vacation, the magazine took a swipe at Palm Beach.

Trump, cloistered in his private club in the town, hasn’t changed its quiet, horse-country flavor, said the writer.


“It isn’t faux cosmopolitan, like Trump Tower, or a poor man’s version of the Mediterranean, like Mar-a-Lago.”

Do ‘Mar-A-Lago’ and ‘poor’ belong in the same sentence?

I think I know what the writer meant. Bedminster seems authentic while Palm Beach and Mar-a-Lago, in particular, are concocted pastiches of various Mediterranean architectural styles.


Well, it’s true. After World War I, widely traveled architect Addison Mizner looked around at the resort colony’s New England shingle-style cottages and Newport-appropriate Beaux Arts mansions and created a new style of stucco, red-tile-roofed mansions that would be forever known as “the Palm Beach look.”

One critic famously called Mizner’s work the “Bastard-Spanish-Moorish-Romanesque-Gothic-Renaissance-Bull-Market-Damn-the-Expense Style.”


As for Mar-a-Lago, although it was initially designed by the versatile, conventionally-trained Marion Sims Wyeth, owner Marjorie Merriweather Post wanted a bit more pizzazz.

The richest woman in the country hired Viennese theater architece Joseph Urban, who designed sets for Flo Ziegfeld, to gild her lily with a theatrical river of gold leaf, ancient Portuguese tiles, carved wood doors and fanciful wrought iron.

So, go ahead and call Palm Beach and Mar-a-Lago beautiful fakes.

But using the word “poor” in association with anything in Palm Beach?


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Community

HPV-related cancer rates are rising. Vaccine rates are rising, too

Cancers linked to the human papillomavirus have increased significantly over the last 15 years in the United States, with throat cancer now the most common HPV-related malignancy, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. More than 43,000 people developed HPV-associated cancer in 2015, compared with about 30,000 in 1999, the CDC...
Huge clinical trial collapses, research on alcohol remains befuddling

Research on alcohol consumption is in a pickle. There’s no question that pounding one drink after another is bad for your health. Things get murkier when it comes to “moderate” drinking. What does that mean? What’s the limit? Can a health-conscious person serenely order a second round? The alcohol industry has long embraced...
Eye exam shows promise in predicting Alzheimer’s years before symptoms
Eye exam shows promise in predicting Alzheimer’s years before symptoms

ST. LOUIS — Using an easy eye exam, researchers at Washington University of Medicine in St. Louis were able to detect evidence of Alzheimer’s disease in patients before they had symptoms of the disease. The findings, involving 30 patients, were published today in the journal JAMA Ophthalmology. Scientists estimate that Alzheimer’s-related...
Google’s revamped fitness app tracks ‘Move Minutes’ and ‘Heart Points’

Google’s trying to get you off the couch by simplifying the look of its Fit app to measure just two things: how much you move and how good that is for your heart. The company redesigned the app in partnership with the American Heart Association and the World Health Organization to reflect both the amount that people move every day and the intensity...
CDC approves nasal-spray vaccine for flu season
CDC approves nasal-spray vaccine for flu season

After advising the public to avoid the nasal-spray version of the flu vaccine for the past two years, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is now giving it the green light. A favorite of the needle-averse, the spray did not appear to work as well against H1N1, a strain of the flu, in the past few seasons, the CDC said. But it’s expected...
More Stories