The other face of Napa Cabernet

There is little question that cabernet sauvignon is the Napa Valley's money grape. As a stand-alone grape, it produces some of the most expensive and sought-after red wines in America. And, as a blending agent, it is the backbone of most of the Napa Valley's most coveted and traditional Bordeaux-style red blends.

This is Napa's strength. 

But there is another side of the Cabernet story, one told eloquently by Paraduxx, a sister winery to the renowned Duckhorn (where merlot is king). 

Paraduxx was founded on the premise of blending zinfandel with other red grapes from the Napa Valley. The results were often spectacular. In recent years, Paraduxx has expanded its repertoire of blends, and those are spectacular as well. 

That point was driven home to me recently when I sampled two new Paraduxx blends from the 2014 vintage. Both are modestly labeled "Red Wine" with the appellation being the determining identifier. 

The "Atlas Peak" ($80) is a blend of cabernet sauvignon and sangiovese, the latter being the "money" grape of Tuscany. Long ago, the great Italian winemaker Piero Antinori suggested the Atlas Peak region off the Silverado Trail in southern Napa would be an excellent place to grow sangiovese. 

The "Howell Mountain" ($80) borrows a familiar theme from Australia and blends cabernet sauvignon with syrah. Both varieties do well on Howell Mountain, situated in the eastern hills of the Napa Valley above the fog line, which is important. The southwest sun exposure guarantees optimum ripeness for these two world-class grapes. 

Both wines exhibit exceptional depth and richness, with classic tannin structure that suggests they will age beautifully. I assigned a score of 96 to the Atlas Peak and a 95 to the Howell Mountain. Though pricey, they are still less expensive than many Napa Valley blends of comparable quality. 

What's more, they are not what you've come to expect from Napa. They are different in a very good way. They demonstrate the versatility of the Napa Valley. They are a triumph in every respect. 

Best Value 

Wines are rated on a 100-point scale. Wines are chosen for review because they represent outstanding quality or value, and the scores are simply a measure of this reviewer's enthusiasm for the recommended wine. 

Cycles Gladiator 2016 Pinot Noir, Central Coas ($12) -- Cycles Gladiator started at Monterey's Hahn Estates winery during the reign of winemaker Adam LaZarre. The brand moved on, and so has LaZarre, though they are still together under the Wine Hooligans umbrella. LaZarre is at his very best when the task is getting the very best into a modestly priced bottle of wine. The 2016 Cycles Gladiator shows good flavor intensity and body, with notes of dark cherry and earth. It's a perfect budget wine for the backyard barbecue this summer. Rating: 86. 

Tasting Notes 

Cuvaison 2015 'Adda' Chardonnay, Carneros ($50) -- Chardonnay has been Cuvaison's strength over the past three decades, and this single-block "Adda" chardonnay from the winery's estate in Carneros lays down a marker that bodes well for the future, too. Beautifully balanced and admirably restrained, the Adda nevertheless shows ample richness and depth without the heaviness that often comes with those two characteristics. Notes of pear, lemon creme and spice dazzle without sacrificing the elegance innate in this bottling. Rating: 94. 

Dutton-Goldfield 2016 Chardonnay, Dutton Ranch, Russian River Valley ($38) -- The beat goes on for winemaker Dan Goldfield, whose chardonnays consistently rank among the finest in California. The Dutton Ranch is another beauty from the master, showing exquisite balance, a core of ripe pear and delicious golden apple, a touch of baking spice as background and a gentle note of lemon oil. Rating: 94. 

Trefethen 2016 Chardonnay, Estate, Oak Knoll District ($36) -- Over the half century Trefethen has been in business, its chardonnay has stood out among the Napa Valley's finest. Always well-balanced and age-worthy, Trefethen resisted the temptation to follow the trend of the 1990s toward more lavish oak and uber-ripe grapes. The 2016 is in keeping with past vintages, exhibiting a note of pineapple/tropical fruit, pear and green apple with a mere hint of wood spice. This wine will age nicely, unlike many other Napa Valley chardonnays, and retain its freshness for several years to come. Rating: 94. 

Cortonesi 2013 'La Mannella' Brunello di Montalcino DOCG, Italy ($72) -- Cortonesi's "La Manella" Brunello from the 2013 is still a baby, showing powerful tannins that, to some extent, mask an impressive flavor profile of black cherries and dried herbs. Even at five years of age, it easily needs another two to three years to show what's behind the wall of tannin. This is a collector's wine that will hold together a good 15 to 20 years. If you must serve it now, think osso bucco or strong cheeses. Rating: 93. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Food

Easter endeavor: How to stuff an artichoke like a kitchen boss
Easter endeavor: How to stuff an artichoke like a kitchen boss

Admit it, you find raw artichokes a little intimidating. They’re pointy and prickly – all that drama for a few bites? No sweat. We’ve got this.  We’ve got a trusty tutorial by Tequesta personal chef Lenore Pinello, a great cook who has a gift for making even complicated dishes seem like a cinch.  Snip the pointed top...
Easter Sunday eats: nine brunches worth a hop 
Easter Sunday eats: nine brunches worth a hop 

Whether or not we scavenge for colorful, candy-filled eggs on Easter Sunday, chances are our day will involve some sort of egg hunt. It’s called brunch.  Here are some spots where the Easter brunches are worth pursuing.  This restaurant bustles at brunch time on the PGA Boulevard corridor. If you haven’t been there...
The sublime joy of cooking with peanut butter
The sublime joy of cooking with peanut butter

Peanut butter is my religion. George Washington Carver is my prophet. I think we can all agree that peanut butter is the most perfect food ever invented. It is the ultimate expression of man’s genius, a spreadable utopia that covers our sins, brings happiness to all and goes as well with jam as it does with jelly. Though peanut butter is the...
This fragrant, tasty chicken dinner comes with a bonus: No cleanup
This fragrant, tasty chicken dinner comes with a bonus: No cleanup

If the cleanup end of a weeknight meal is your least favorite part, this recipe's for you. It uses a time-honored technique employed by professional chefs and camping enthusiasts with equal aplomb: packet cooking, a.k.a. en papillote, al cartoccio, hobo packets and foil-packet dinners. Foods enclosed in a parchment paper or foil pouch essentially steam...
Bubbles, with joy: Pétillant Naturel’s triumphant return
Bubbles, with joy: Pétillant Naturel’s triumphant return

Don’t call pétillant naturel the new bubbly in town. Don’t call it “the new rosé,” as did in 2016 in an effort to encapsulate its trendiness. In fact, don’t call it the new anything. This genre of sparkling wine, now known as pétillant naturel, or pét-nat, is made by a method so old...
More Stories