Cluck-worthy fried chicken: Bay Bay’s is lip-smacking good

Hold the waffle. Even if just for a minute, hold the waffle.

Yes, it’s a decadent touch and part of the brand at Bay Bay’s Chicken & Waffles, but with its syrup, toppings and breakfast connotations it’s also a potential distraction from the main event.

The main event being the fried chicken. The lip-smacking good fried chicken.

Tender beneath a crispy, spicy, almost sweet crust, the first bite is a juicy and flavorful wallop.

The fried chicken recipe, as the place itself, is the enterprise of Israel Johnson, a businessman and educator who teaches online college classes on restaurant management. Johnson opened Bay Bay’s five months ago in the compact, red, freestanding building where Eggsotic Bistro stood some years ago.

Here you are, bellied up to the counter at the tiny, but busy chicken joint, as the fried chicken chef drops one well-seasoned, buttermilk-marinated piece after another into the fryer, then dresses up a fresh-made waffle. At the sight of that waffle, you may be tempted to plunge into the sweet side of the experience first.

But don’t be seduced by the sweet. Oh, the waffles will tempt with their flavor “upgrades” – for $3, you can swap out a plain waffle for one flavored in lemon cake, red velvet, strawberry, chocolate, pumpkin pie or pecan.

If you’re a fried chicken fan, however, do yourself a favor: dig into the chicken first. Then have your waffle fun.

That chicken is served in a range of ways, in chicken and waffle combos that run from $6.95 (two piece, dark meat), to $12.95 for 8 jumbo wingettes. Family meals run from $26.95 for a 10-piece bucket and two large sides to $49.95 for 20 pieces and four large sides.

The spicy chicken also is served in a fried chicken sub ($8.95), in fried wings and strips (starting at $8.95), a fried chicken sandwich ($7.95) and fried chicken wing fettuccine ($14.95).

Beyond that, there a menu to meander through.

You may want to try the (non-fried) chicken fettuccine ($9.95), in a thick, creamy and peppery Alfredo sauce, or the fried catfish and grits ($9.95), or the Jamaican Curry Stir ($11.95), a sauté of jumbo shrimp with spinach, peppers, onions and tomatoes that’s served with nicely acidic collard greens.

Or you may want to do the breakfast for dinner – or breakfast for dessert – and plunge straight into a peanut butter and grape jelly waffle ($7.95) or a Cuban coffee waffle ($7.95) that’s filled with bits of cream cheese and topped with a guava-orange glaze (and if you do, you’ll hear the sound of the heavens parting).

But whatever you try at this friendly, well attended spot, don’t leave the counter (or table) without digging into a plump, crispy leg or wing.

You’ll cluck about it later.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Food

How to prep and enjoy a mango, the sunniest fruit in the grocery store
How to prep and enjoy a mango, the sunniest fruit in the grocery store

I adore mango in so many forms. Puree as the base of an Indian dal (lentil dish). Chutney to go on a grilled cheese sandwich. Frozen in ice cream. But fresh? I always seemed to walk by those giant crates in the grocery store. In fact, it was not until I bought, oh, a dozen or so for the purposes of this very story that I realized how much I had been...
The scoop on Swedish Candy: It’s more than fish
The scoop on Swedish Candy: It’s more than fish

Candies scooped into shiny pink bags and sold by the pound are a Swedish addition to the Lower East Side. Licorice items, marshmallow-filled chocolates, cola-flavored drops and all sorts of gummies fill the little self-serve bins. It’s the work of Swedish expats and is actually the second Swedish candy store in New York (there’s Sockerbit...
Even the gelato is infused with mezcal at Claro
Even the gelato is infused with mezcal at Claro

It makes sense for a restaurant that specializes in the food of Oaxaca to feature mezcal, the smoky agave-based spirit that dominates the region. At Claro in Brooklyn, T.J. Steele, the chef and an owner of the restaurant, also has a brand of mezcal, El Buho. He has worked with Il Laboratorio del Gelato in Manhattan to create four gelatos flavored with...
Sick of kale Caesars? Toss this together.
Sick of kale Caesars? Toss this together.

I used to like a kale Caesar as much as the next vegetarian. But its ubiquity has ruined it for me. Now, no matter how much I massage those leaves or make sure my dressing is nice and punchy (thank you, garlic), I find myself missing good old lettuce. I often want more from a salad, too. If meat eaters can bastardize their Caesars with chicken or shrimp...
The sweet potato: World colonizer all by itself?
The sweet potato: World colonizer all by itself?

Of all the plants that humanity has turned into crops, none are more puzzling than the sweet potato. Indigenous people of Central and South America grew it on farms for generations, and Europeans discovered it when Christopher Columbus arrived in the Caribbean.   In the 18th century, however, Capt. James Cook stumbled across sweet potatoes...
More Stories