NEW: Congress committee questions Brightline financing strategy


Members of a congressional oversight committee Thursday took aim at Brightline’s plan to use tax-exempt bonds to pay for its West Palm Beach-to-Orlando extension, questioning whether the project qualifies for the tax-free financing.

Brightline in December won federal approval to sell $1.15 billion in private activity bonds to help pay for the second phase its passenger rail project, which will connect the company’s West Palm Beach station to the Orlando airport and ultimately allow its fleet of trains to shuttle passengers between Miami and Central Florida.

Rep. Brian Mast, R-Palm City, a longtime Brightline critic, called for the oversight hearing in February.

The U.S. House of Representative’s Subcommittee on Government Operations took no formal action in Washington, D.C. on Thursday, but some members questioned whether Brightline’s passenger service meets federal requirements to qualify for the tax-exempt bonds.

RELATED: Three people killed by Brightline trains had drugs in system

The bonds are designed to help private developers finance projects by giving them access to tax-exempt interest rates — lowering their costs.

An amendment to internal revenue code set aside $15 billion at the federal level for private activity bonds to pay for highway projects and freight transfer facilities. The U.S. Department of Transportation had issued $8.2 billion for 23 projects, including $600 million for Brightline’s West Palm Beach-to-Miami leg. Another $2 billion has been allocated for four projects, including Brightline’s northern extension to Orlando.

RELATED: Quiet zone to stop Brightline horns delayed in 5 PBC cities

Rep. Mark Meadows (R-NC) questioned the U.S. Department of Transportation’s decision to classify Brightline as a highway project, saying he had a “real concern that the intent of Congress is being overridden.”

Martin and Indian River counties filed a federal lawsuit in February in an effort to block the bond sale, arguing that the Brightline does not qualify for the bonds. The suit also alleges federal officials either ignored or failed to consider the impacts the company’s trains could have on the environment, public safety and maritime traffic.

Brightline’s President and Chief Operating Officer Patrick Goddard told the committee that the company continues to seek a $1.75 billion federal loan.

During the two-hour hearing, the committee also questioned whether Treasure Coast counties should have to pay for ongoing maintenance of safety upgrades Brightline plans to install at railroad crossings in order to run its fast-moving trains through the region.

Dylan Reingold, Indian River County Attorney, said the maintenance is expected to cost the county $8.2 million through 2030. He argued that local governments have no control over the costs.

“We do not want the bills for these safety and maintenance costs to come from the pockets of our constituents,” Reingold told the committee.

Goddard pointed to decades-old agreements between the railroad and local governments that require cities and counties to pay for the maintenance at rail crossings.

“We have improved all of the crossings up and down the corridor, but yes, they do need to continue to pay the maintenance that they have agreed to pay,” Goddard said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in

Palm Beach County home prices stall in August

Home buyers took a breather in August, a month when the typical price of a Palm Beach County house slipped to the lowest level since January. The median price of single-family homes sold by Realtors was $340,000 last month, the Realtors of the Palm Beaches and Greater Fort Lauderdale said Thursday. That was down from July’s median price of $350...
Palm Beach County home prices pull back in August
Palm Beach County home prices pull back in August

Home buyers took a breather in August, a month when the typical price of a Palm Beach County house slipped to the lowest level since January. The median price of single-family homes sold by Realtors was $340,000 last month, the Realtors of the Palm Beaches and Greater Fort Lauderdale said Thursday. That was down from July’s median price...
Back to the drawing board: NPB seeks new restaurant for clubhouse
Back to the drawing board: NPB seeks new restaurant for clubhouse

Always a bridesmaid, never a bride. “That’s what it feels like,” said Andrew Lukasik, the village of North Palm Beach’s manager, after two unsuccessful years of trying to find the right restaurant for a new country club under construction. MORE: Golf course, done. Clubhouse under way. What’s next at Banyan Cay? Lukasik...
‘Magic: The Gathering Arena’ may finally get game right for video games
‘Magic: The Gathering Arena’ may finally get game right for video games

Despite pioneering the trading card game on paper, Wizards of the Coast has had a rough go of it in the digital space. “Magic: The Gathering Online” hasn’t had wild success mainly because of stability issues and accessibility. “Magic Duels” was better but it didn’t seem to take full advantage of the medium or capture...
These Android phones have security defects out of the box
These Android phones have security defects out of the box

At least 25 Android smartphone models — 11 of which are sold by major U.S. carriers — carry vulnerabilities out of the box, making them easy prey for hackers, according to a new study from security researchers. Researchers from the firm Kryptowire found 38 vulnerabilities in 25 Android phones, according to Wired. They range from being able...
More Stories