NEW: Brightline foes’ new twist in fight against loan — President Trump

Brightline’s most vocal foes have found a new argument: President Donald J. Trump.

Treasure Coast leaders opposed to All Aboard Florida’s passenger rail project launched a new attack this week, arguing that a federal loan to help pay for the private rail venture could create both a financial benefit and a safety risk for Trump because of train line’s proximity to his Mar-a-Lago club in Palm Beach.

In a 6-page letter sent to federal transportation officials on Monday, attorneys for Martin and Indian River counties and the anti-rail group CARE FL argue a loan from the Federal Railroad Administration to help pay for the Brightline project would create “unique financial concerns” for the Trump administration.

One of Brightline’s three South Florida stations will be located in downtown West Palm Beach, roughly 5 miles from the sprawling Mar-a-Lago property. Some have argued that properties around those stations will see a benefit from Brightline’s trains, the attorneys wrote in the letter.

RELATED: Brightline’s Orlando leg delayed to 2020; focus now on local commuters

“This include’s the President’s Mar-a-Lago resort, which is located near the West Palm Beach station,” the letter said. “Therefore, granting the loan arguably impacts the president’s property. Critics may argue the loan creates an important benefit to a private business of the president’s.”

The attorneys also argue that the location of the Florida East Cost Railway tracks, where Brightline will operate its passenger trains alongside other freight traffic, could create a safety hazard for the president. The tracks are located about 1.5 miles west of the Mar-a-Lago club.

“An alternative argument that we believe is more accurate is that the AAF project creates safety risks to President Trump and reduces the value of nearby properties such as Mar-a-Lago,” the letter said.

Brightline CEO Dave Howard told federal transporation officials in April the company intended to “submit promptly” an application for a Railroad Rehabilitation and Improvement Financing loan, adding that it planned to use the proceeds to complete its service between Miami and Orlando.

As of July 20, the U.S. Department of Transportation had not received a formal application for the loan.

The push came after All Aboard Florida unsuccessfully tried to sell tax-exempt private activity bonds to help pay for the construction of its second phase between West Palm Beach and Orlando. Officials have said it will be at least three years before that leg is operational.

Brightline officials on Wednesday declined to comment on the attorneys’ letter.

In their letter, Indian River County Attorney Dylan Reingold, Ruth Holmes, Martin County’s senior assistant county attorney, and Stephen Ryan, a Washington, D.C.-based attorney representing the citizen’s group CARE FL, urge federal transportation officials to “carefully consider” the project before deciding whether to grant a loan. The attorneys argue that the loan is “unlikely to be payable and creates a very high risk of default.”

They pointed to the recent split in ownership between All Aboard’s parent company, Florida East Coast Industries, and Florida East Coast Railway, which owns the train tracks.

“These two ownership changes have significant implications for the AAF project — both from a financial and environmental perspective,” the attorneys wrote in their letter.

RELATED: Grupo México to buy Florida East Coast Railway

In February, Japanese Internet and telecommunication giant SoftBank announced it planned to buy Fortress Investment Group in a $3.3 billion deal. Florida East Coast Industries, All Aboard’s parent company, is a commercial real estate, transportation and infrastructure firm owned by private equity funds managed Fortress Investment Group.

In a sepreate deal, Grupo México, a mining and transportation company based in Mexico City, announced in March that it planned to buy Florida East Coast Railway from Fortress Investment Group.

At the time of the announcement, All Aboard, Brightline’s developer, said the sale would not impact the passenger rail project, which plans to start offering service in South Florida this summer.

“The sale of the Florida East Coast Railway does not impact Brightline,” the company said in March. “Brightline is a separate company that has dual ownership of the corridor and the right to operate passenger service. We have all shared operations-related agreements in place with the Florida East Coast Railway for us to fully build out and implement our passenger rail system.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in

Wellington Green mall museum pokes saber-toothed hole in expectations
Wellington Green mall museum pokes saber-toothed hole in expectations

Look out for that time warp near the Nordstrom store at the Mall at Wellington Green. It could throw off your whole shopping schedule by, like, a million years. One minute you’re browsing the latest gadgets or clothes. The next you’re in a world of mammoths and saber-toothed cats. Some come straight out of prehistoric versions of Palm Beach...
Brightline buys private rail line connecting Los Angeles and Las Vegas
Brightline buys private rail line connecting Los Angeles and Las Vegas

Brightline’s newly launched rail service in South Florida is losing money and struggling to lure passengers, but its owners are optimistic enough about the concept that they just bought the private train route from Los Angeles to Las Vegas. Brightline said Tuesday that it paid an undisclosed sum for XpressWest, a high-speed passenger rail project...
Intech leaving CityPlace for location in One Clearlake Centre
Intech leaving CityPlace for location in One Clearlake Centre

Intech, the longtime anchor tenant of the luxury CityPlace Tower office building, confirmed it plans to move to One Clearlake Centre, west of downtown West Palm Beach. The deal, in the works for some time and first reported last November, would free up 50,000 square feet of arguably the best office space downtown. READ ALSO: Pricey new townhomes in...
Dress for Success Director Mary Hart on empowering women
Dress for Success Director Mary Hart on empowering women

Meet Mary Hart, executive director of Dress for Success Palm Beaches. In addition to providing women professional attire to assist in seeking employment, Dress for Success offers an impressive 10-week job preparation and mentoring program called New Directions. The mentees have diverse paths, many seeking new opportunities after significant accomplishments...
Wellington FPL lineman ‘scared to death’ for family riding out Florence
Wellington FPL lineman ‘scared to death’ for family riding out Florence

A storm that has claimed at least nine lives and knocked out power to about 1 million people in the Carolinas took on special significance for Wellington’s Gerald Nixon. The Florida Power & Light Co. line worker, one of 930 workers from his utility dispatched to help restore power in Florence’s wake, anxiously awaited word family members...
More Stories