When the president says it, does that mean it’s printable?


Lester Holt opened the “NBC Nightly News” on Thursday with a parental warning: “This may not be appropriate for some of our younger viewers.”

His counterpart at “ABC World News Tonight,” David Muir, described President Donald Trump “using a profanity we won’t repeat.”

And Jim Acosta, CNN’s chief White House correspondent, stammered as he delivered a report from Washington. “I noticed, Wolf, you hesitated to use that word,” he told the network’s anchor, Wolf Blitzer. “I hesitate to use it myself.”

Media outlets Thursday took the unusual step of allowing the word “shithole” to be used in print and on air, after a report that Trump had used the term to describe African nations and Haiti during a White House meeting with lawmakers on immigration.

The unexpurgated expletive appeared, in capital letters, on the graphics known as chyrons that dominate the lower portion of the screen on CNN and MSNBC. (Fox News spelled the word with asterisks.) It showed up on smartphone push alerts sent by the Washington Post, which broke the story, and the Associated Press.

Acosta, on CNN, the first network to broadcast the term without asterisks, said the word several times on-air, even as Blitzer opted for the more chaste “S-hole.”

MORE: Sen. Durbin: Trump ‘said things which were hate-filled, vile and racist’

MORE: Countries, UN respond to Trump’s vulgar comments

MORE: 5 other times President Trump’s remarks sparked controversy over race

It is exceedingly rare for the country’s biggest news organizations to publish a quote that includes an expletive; usually, they employ a censored or blanked-out version. On Thursday’s network evening newscasts, NBC News was the only organization that quoted Trump in full. Anchors at ABC and CBS used the word “blank” instead.

But several media executives said Thursday that the news value of Trump’s remarks, which the White House did not dispute, was undeniable.

“It would be futile to mask the word when the language itself, in reference to Haiti and African countries, was so extraordinary,” the AP’s vice president for standards, John Daniszewski, said.

Phil Corbett, the associate managing editor for standards at the New York Times, said in an email: “It seemed pretty clear to all of us that we should quote the language directly, not paraphrase it. We wanted to be sure readers would fully understand what the story was about.”

The Times, unlike some papers, omitted the obscenity from its headline and push alert, using the term “vulgar language” instead. “We are still inclined to be somewhat restrained — for instance, by avoiding the actual vulgarities in headlines,” Corbett said.

But Trump’s remarks — and the speed with which they have entered the public domain — are a new test for media outlets, especially when the comments appear to reveal privately held beliefs of the commander-in-chief. In this case, Trump’s comment, in the context of a discussion on immigration, was widely seen as evidence of prejudice.

“Times and levels of White House discourse, and what the public will tolerate, have flipped,” Frank Sesno, a former CNN Washington bureau chief, said Thursday.

He added, “Right along with the rest of our culture.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Fun and free things to do with kids in Palm Beach County this weekend
Fun and free things to do with kids in Palm Beach County this weekend

There are so many amazing and COMPLETELY FREE things to do with your kids in Palm Beach County this weekend. Here are our picks for the best events. We’ve also included a few for next weekend so you can get a head start on planning. To get this weekly listing delivered straight to your inbox, sign up for our Palm Beach Parenting Newsletter...
NEW: West Palm man, 18, charged with attempted murder
NEW: West Palm man, 18, charged with attempted murder

An 18-year-old man was arrested Friday for his alleged role in an October Palm Springs shooting during a drug deal that went bad. Remy Ra St. Felix, of West Palm Beach, was taken into custody Friday on charges that include attempted first-degree murder, aggravated assault with a firearm and armed robbery. He remained in custody at the Palm Beach...
Jacksonville RB Leonard Fournette involved in multicar crash
Jacksonville RB Leonard Fournette involved in multicar crash

The Florida Highway Patrol confirmed that Jaguars running back Leonard Fournette was involved in a three-car crash Tuesday on I-295 in Jacksonville.  Sgt. Dylan Bryan said Fournette was inside a vehicle involved in the collision. Fournette was able to drive home, a Jaguars spokesman said.  There were no injuries and Fournette was not at fault...
4 drinks that could be sabotaging your weight loss efforts
4 drinks that could be sabotaging your weight loss efforts

When you're trying to lose weight, you may not give much thought to what you drink, but those calories definitely add up! These "liquid calories" can sabotage your weight-loss efforts, and you may not feel as full as if you'd eaten the same number of calories. Many drinks also provide little to no nutrients and are often loaded with...
Women targeted in Jacksonville Walmart purse snatchings
Women targeted in Jacksonville Walmart purse snatchings

Women in a Florida city are being targeted at Walmart parking lots as they unload groceries, police said. Two women said Monday that a car pulled up beside them and the driver tried to snatch their purses at a Walmart parking lot near the Avenues Mall in Jacksonville.  “I grabbed my purse, put it on my shoulder and grabbed her purse and...
More Stories