Panel rejects plan to narrow right to privacy in Florida constitution


A state panel Thursday defeated a proposal that sought to narrow the right to privacy in the state Constitution and allow increased regulation of abortions.

In a 4-2 vote, the Judicial Committee of the state Constitution Revision Commission rejected a measure (Proposal 22) from Commissioner John Stemberger of Orlando that would have changed the Constitution to say people have a right to be free from governmental intrusion “with respect to privacy of information and the disclosure thereof.”

»RELATED: The latest in Florida political news

Stemberger has objected to state courts using the privacy clause to overturn a law requiring parental consent for minors seeking abortions and to negate another law requiring a 24-hour waiting period for women seeking abortions.

He said his proposal was aimed at “restraining the Florida Supreme Court’s gross overreach by ignoring the original intent of the amendment and producing, what I believe, is very bad public policy as a result.”

After researching a privacy proposal drafted by the 1977-1978 Constitution Revision Commission and legislation in 1980 that led to the amendment, which was adopted by 61 percent of the voters that year, Stemberger said he could find no record that drafters had intended it to apply to abortion and other personal issues outside of informational privacy.

“You can look for days and find nothing on the record relating to abortion or any other area of privacy, except for informational privacy, surveillance, the encroachment of government when it comes to technological advances,” he said.

But Jon Mills, a former Democratic lawmaker from Gainesville and former University of Florida law school dean who helped write the 1980 measure, said other applications of the privacy amendment were discussed, although it may not necessarily be part of the official record.

“There was an understanding that this was not just information. That’s my recollection,” he said.

Mills also said the amendment established a broader right to privacy in Florida than in the federal Constitution, and it should be retained due to the “undefinable future” of federal regulations and decisions.

“We have a state right that accords additional rights to our citizens,” Mills said. “There’s no question that if we limit that only to informational privacy that that would reduce existing rights under the Florida Constitution.”

The proposal split the Judicial Committee members.

Sen. Tom Lee, a Thonotosassa Republican who voted for the proposal, said he believed voters should be given another chance to consider the issue.

“Questions surrounding the rights of parents in our state have been impaired somewhat by this amendment, arguably tangentially,” Lee said. “We ought to give the voters an opportunity to reconsider this.”

But Commissioner Arthenia Joyner, a former state senator from Tampa, who voted against the measure, said it would be a mistake to scale back Florida’s privacy right.

“This proposal has one purpose and one purpose only: to strip a woman’s right to choose,” Joyner said. “It does so by cutting our state’s personal privacy protections, the ones that stand in the way of government overreach and intrusion.”

Commissioner Tim Cerio of Tallahassee voted for the proposal, although he said he was somewhat skeptical of the argument that the original intent of the amendment was limited to informational privacy.

But he also said the language of the existing amendment is so broad that it puts judges in the position of having to act like lawmakers in trying to apply the measure.

Commissioner Roberto Martinez of Coral Gables opposed the measure, saying he is staunch supporter of personal privacy rights.

“I believe the right to privacy in Florida is an extra protection that the public should have and does have and it extends beyond informational privacy,” Martinez said.

He said altering the existing privacy clause would subject Floridians “to a higher possibility of governmental intrusion into their private lives and that includes medical decisions and the right to receive an abortion.”

Although the committee defeated the proposal, Stemberger has the option of trying to revive the measure once the full 37-member Constitution Revision Commission meets. Under the commission’s rules, a majority vote by the commission would keep the proposal under consideration.

Stemberger said Thursday he would consider that option.

The commission, which meets every 20 years, has the power to place constitutional amendments on the 2018 general election ballot. At least 22 members of the commission must support a proposal before it can reach the ballot.

Ballot measures must be approved by at least 60 percent of the voters to be enacted.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

EXCLUSIVE: Parents of teen killed by Conniston classmate again try claims bill
EXCLUSIVE: Parents of teen killed by Conniston classmate again try claims bill

For years, Ashraf Kamel and his ex-wife, Marguerite Dimitri, tried to persuade Florida lawmakers to award them more of the $1.6 million verdict they won in 2002 for the 1997 shooting death of their 13-year-old son, Jean Pierre, at Conniston Middle School in West Palm Beach. They received the $200,000 statutory limit from the Palm Beach County...
Transcript, photos: Trump, Melania, Rubio, Scott meet cops after Parkland school shooting
Transcript, photos: Trump, Melania, Rubio, Scott meet cops after Parkland school shooting

Sen. Marco Rubio (near American flag at left), first lady Melania Trump, Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel, President Donald Trump, Gov. Rick Scott and Attorney General Pam Bondi with first responders in Fort Lauderdale on Friday night. (George Bennett/The Palm Beach Post) FORT LAUDERDALE — President ...
With McCain’s retreat, some look to Romney to carry traditional GOP torch
With McCain’s retreat, some look to Romney to carry traditional GOP torch

In more ways than one, followers of traditional Republican orthodoxy are facing an emotional inflection point this week.  Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., at home battling an aggressive form of brain cancer, will not attend this weekend's Munich Security Conference, an annual gathering of foreign policy leaders from NATO nations that has become a central...
Mike Pence bought a Valentine’s Day gift for his wife at . . . CVS Pharmacy
Mike Pence bought a Valentine’s Day gift for his wife at . . . CVS Pharmacy

Hey, isn't that . . . Vice President Mike Pence, on Wednesday night dropping by a retail spot known for its selection of gifts every woman loves? The Veep was spotted on Valentine's Day making his way out of the CVS at Pennsylvania Avenue and 19th Street NW. And it seemed he hadn't just made the drugstore run for a pack of gum.  CBS White House...
Mnuchin calls on Congress to look into gun violence, breaking with rest of White House
Mnuchin calls on Congress to look into gun violence, breaking with rest of White House

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin on Thursday called on Congress to look into issues related to gun violence less than 24 hours after 17 people were killed in a school shooting in Florida.  "I will say, personally, I think the gun violence — it's a tragedy what we've seen yesterday, and I urge Congress to look at these issues,"...
More Stories