A wide-ranging bill that would rein in local governments’ ability to increase taxes narrowly passed the Florida House Ways & Means Committee on Wednesday.
The committee approved the measure (PCB WMC 17-02) on a nearly party-line vote, 9-7, with Rep. Kathleen Peters, R-Treasure Island, joining all the committee Democrats in opposing the measure.
The bill would require local governments, except for school boards, to spend down money saved in some special funds before approving increases in property taxes.
“When you’re sitting down to do your budget for the next year and deciding what tax rate you need to levy, if your cash position as a local government is such that you could make the choice to spend the money you have in the bank instead of raising taxes, that is the choice we would like to see you do as a result of this bill,” said Rep. Matt Caldwell, a North Fort Myers Republican handling the legislation.
The proposal would also restrict cities and counties from passing local option taxes if they have approved property tax increases within the past three years. An increase in sales taxes for school construction would have to pass a school board with a four-fifths supermajority.
And the measure would require any local referendums raising taxes to gain 60 percent of the vote to pass. Such questions also would have to go before voters during general elections. Voters would also have to approve any moves by local governments to take on debt longer than five years.
Palm Beach County officials who met with legislators in Tallahassee this week urged them not to pass legislation that limits their authority.
“I haven’t had a chance to read the bill,” County Commissioner Mack Bernard, a Democrat who previously served in the House, said of PCB WMC 17-02. “But we don’t want any more unfunded mandates. We don’t want these types of bills in Tallahassee. Let the local municipalities make decisions for the constituents in their communities.”
Palm Beach County Mayor Paulette Burdick, also a Democrat, said, “I’ve been the one clamoring for some sort of benchmark for when we will reduce our (property tax rate). Most of the time when we see these sort of funky bills out of Tallahassee, they have one local government in mind and then they want to take local control away. Clearly, we have said over and over again, ‘Don’t pre-empt us from local decision-making. Who knows what the future holds?’”
West Palm Beach Mayor Jeri Muoio said that, while she was not familiar with the bill, “Anything that’s going to preempt a local government’s ability to do what it needs to do is not a good thing.”
“There’s a general direction in Tallahassee to try and preempt what happens at the local level,” she added. “I’m a strong home-rule person and believe that’s what the people of West Palm Beach want.”
Other critics of the bill contended the legislation was confusing and too restrictive on local governments.
Amber Hughes, a lobbyist for the Florida League of Cities, said different accounting methods among local governments might make it difficult to figure out the meaning of certain terms in the bill — like the excess fund balances that the legislation targets.
“When I send (a message) out to my finance officers and say, ‘Do you meet these thresholds?’ and they say, ‘We have no idea; we don’t even know how to calculate it’ — that’s concerning to me,” Hughes said.
Others zeroed in on the bill’s mandate that a supermajority of voters approve tax referendums.
“To start imposing 60 percent requirements to get anything done, I just think is anti-democratic,” said Rep. Joseph Geller, D-Aventura.
The bill comes amid a debate at the Capitol about the proper role of local governments. A measure that would severely restrict the authority of local governments to pass business regulations (HB 17) has already been approved by one of its two House committees.
Palm Beach Post staff writers Wayne Washington and Tony Doris contributed to this story.
Get The Post’s complete coverage of the 2017 session of the Florida Legislature, PalmBeachPost.com/legislature
031017 fla leg death penalty, B2
031017 flaleg higher ed, B2
031017 fla lawmaker indicted, B2