Opponents: ‘Pastor protection’ bill grows from same-sex marriage fears


Church and state collided Wednesday in a Capitol hearing room crowded with dozens of clergy members, as a House panel advanced a controversial “pastor protection act” prompted by the U.S. Supreme Court decision which legalized same-sex marriage.

Rep. Scott Plakon, R-Longwood, said his proposal (HB 43) is an “extra layer of protection” intended to assure that clergy do not have to perform same-sex marriages if they violate their religious beliefs or moral convictions.

Plakon acknowledged the U.S. Constitution already shields clergy and religious organizations from being forced to conduct such ceremonies. But since the justices’ ruling in June, many ministers and social conservatives have grown increasingly alarmed, he said.

“There have been numerous changes in the law and culture,” Plakon said. “This just makes it clear” that Florida clergy can decline to conduct such ceremonies.

But clergy attending the House Civil Justice subcommittee were divided over the bill. Critics blasted it as little more than pushback from those who oppose same-sex marriage.

“Look at the true intent of this bill,” said Rev. Harold Thompson, with United Church of Christ in Miami Beach. “It’s not to protect the pastors or protect the churches, it’s to protect an agenda.”

Rev. Brant Copeland, of Tallahassee’s First Presbyterian Church, also said he was offended by what he called the legislation’s message to lesbian, gay, bi-sexual and transgender Floridians.

“It’s that somehow an LGBT person who is looking to get married is a threat to other people of faith,” Copeland said. “I urge you not to adopt this unnecessary and, I think, basically homophobic bill.”

Carlos Guillermo Smith, representing Equality Florida, which advocates for LGBT issues, said his organization would defend any church sued.

“But we know that is not going to be necessary,” he said. “We know that the existing and clearly defined constitutional protections mean such an imaginary lawsuit would not have any legal basis.”

Supporters, however, said that a state law would assist in discouraging lawsuits against a clergy member or religious institution that declined to perform marriages or provide services and facilities for a wedding.

Following heated testimony from both sides, the Republican-dominated panel approved the legislation in a 9-4, party-line vote.

The bill also is portrayed by backers as thwarting any possible backlash against a church’s tax-exempt status, right to apply for grants and participate in government programs, if it refuses to sanction same-sex marriages.

Plakon’s bill is modeled after legislation signed into law in Texas just days after the high court ruling. He called the approach, “proactive, rather than reactive.”

“In an ideal world, the (constitutional protections) would apply,” said Anthony Verdugo, executive director of the Miami-based Christian Family Coalition. “But we live in the real world, and we need your help.”

Citing a Colorado court ruling against a bakery which refused to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, Rep. Greg Squires of Kissimmee’s Freedom Life Church, said ministers are uneasy.

“Why could (lawsuits) not come to us?” Squires told the subcommittee. “Even though we say it’s in our constitution, that just depends upon the person who is ruling at the moment and how they see it. And you know how that goes, you’re in politics.”

The Colorado decision stemmed from the bakery violating a state law barring businesses from refusing service because of sexual orientation.

Squires and lawmakers failed to point out that although Palm Beach County and more than two dozen governments, mostly across Central and South Florida, bar discrimination against LGBT residents at work, in housing, restaurants and public accommodations, there is no statewide prohibition.

Legislation to expand the state’s civil rights laws to include LGBT Floridians has been filed, but has failed, for several years.

In Wednesday’s hearing, Democratic and Republican lawmakers also squared off over Plakon’s approach.

Rep. Lori Berman, D-Lantana, labeled the proposal, “legislation in search of a problem that doesn’t exist.”

But Rep. Larry Metz, R-Yalaha, said a changing legal landscape warranted such action.

“If the Legislature doesn’t provide direction, the judiciary will be happy to fill the vacuum,” Metz said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Tax increases would need two-thirds vote of Legislature under proposal
Tax increases would need two-thirds vote of Legislature under proposal

A measure that would require future tax or fee increases to be approved by two-thirds votes of the Legislature is ready for consideration by the state Constitution Revision Commission. The commission’s Finance and Taxation Committee on Tuesday voted unanimously to advance a proposed constitutional amendment (Proposal 72), sponsored by Commissioner...
Lawmakers call for investigation into Trump sexual misconduct allegations
Lawmakers call for investigation into Trump sexual misconduct allegations

More than 100 Democratic lawmakers are calling on the House Oversight Committee to investigate allegations of sexual misconduct levied against President Donald Trump, a group of female U.S. representatives said at a news conference Tuesday. More than a dozen women have accused the president of forced kissing, unwanted groping and making inappropriate...
‘I am not a liar,’ local Trump accuser tells national talk show
‘I am not a liar,’ local Trump accuser tells national talk show

A Palm Springs woman who last year accused President Donald Trump of sexual misconduct in 2003 shared her story again today on a national television show and called for an ethics investigation into similar allegations against Trump by 15 other women. “He can’t get away with this,” Melinda McGillivray said on NBC’s Megyn...
Trump vows Americans will return to the moon. The question is how?
Trump vows Americans will return to the moon. The question is how?

Once again, the Trump administration has pledged to restore America’s leadership in space by teaming with the private sector and returning to the moon. Speaking at a White House ceremony Monday, President Donald Trump offered high ambitions, but few specifics in signing a new space policy directive that had no timeline and promised no funding...
Alabama dad criticizes Roy Moore in memory of his gay daughter
Alabama dad criticizes Roy Moore in memory of his gay daughter

An Alabama father who said that his daughter took her life because “she didn’t want to be gay anymore” stood outside Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore’s rally in Midland City on Monday to urge people not to vote for the former judge. Photos from the rally showed peanut farmer and Midland City native Nathan Mathis holding a...
More Stories