‘Eyeball wars’ flare again over bill to let optometrists do surgery


Four years ago, Florida House and Senate leaders thought they had finally settled a decade-old turf battle between the state’s optometrists and ophthalmologists.

After heavy lobbying, heated arguing and much finger-pointing, the two sides signed off on a compromise allowing optometrists to prescribe oral medications — but not perform surgery.

Then-Senate President Don Gaetz, R-Niceville, even declared, “So the eyeball wars have ended.”

RELATED: More Florida Legislature coverage

But the eyeball wars have once more descended on the Capitol with a vengeance, as optometrists seek to expand their scope of practice to perform some surgical procedures. Optometrists maintain the proposal is an access-to-care issue, while ophthalmologists argue it would endanger patient safety.

The House Health Quality Subcommittee narrowly approved the proposal Wednesday by a one-vote margin, after two hours of testimony.

But the bill’s chances of success in the Senate are anything but certain.

The measure (HB 1037) would allow optometrists who receive special training to perform certain kinds of surgery in which “human tissue is injected, cut, burned, frozen, sutured, vaporized, coagulated, or photodisrupted by the use of surgical instrumentation,” including lasers and scalpels, according to a House staff analysis of the bill.

Kenneth Lawson, a Manatee County optometrist who is legislative chairman of the Florida Optometric Association, acknowledged that the proposal, sponsored by Rep. Manny Diaz Jr., R-Hialeah, is a “contentious” bill.

But supporters said it would address a dearth of care available to some patients, including in rural communities.

Lawson said many ophthalmologists will not treat patients who are on Medicaid, while optometrists care for patients who are on Medicaid or who are indigent.

If the bill passes, he said optometrists would only be able to perform a fraction of the surgical procedures that ophthalmologists can do.

“We are not trying to elevate ourselves by any means to the level of ophthalmologists,” Lawson said.

But ophthalmologists argued that the amount of training the legislation would require for optometrists to perform the procedures is inadequate, especially compared to the years of preparation ophthalmologists must undergo.

Bruce May, general counsel of the Florida Society of Ophthalmology, gave the House panel a mini-history lesson.

“Less than four years ago … the (House) speaker and president made it clear that they were going to put an end to what they called the eyeball wars,” May said.

Under the terms of the 2013 deal, optometrists could prescribe 14 types of medications and also agreed that “surgery of any kind is expressly prohibited,” according to May.

“I don’t know why the optometrists are walking back from the agreement they made just four years ago,” he said.

Powerful Senate budget chief Jack Latvala, R-Clearwater, is sponsoring the Senate version of the bill (SB 1168), but that does not guarantee a victory for optometrists in the upper chamber.

Senate President Joe Negron, R-Stuart, told The News Service of Florida on Wednesday that he has left it up to the heads of committees to decide how to handle bills, such as the optometrist-backed measure, that aren’t a priority of his.

Senate Health Policy Chairwoman Dana Young, R-Tampa, has not put the measure on an agenda for her committee.

“I haven’t made any determinations on what we’re hearing beyond the next two weeks,” Young said Wednesday. “I think anytime you have an industry food fight like this it is difficult at best, and, this year, there’s a lot of uncertainty about what we’re going to do after the next two weeks.”

Young noted that some other lawmakers “seem to be very upset that this has come back.”

While it’s too early to write off the Senate’s handling of the bill, scope-of-practice measures that involve industry battles often take years to pass after first being introduced.

“I wouldn’t say it’s DOA in the Senate. There are those of us who think it goes too far, but I think there’s always room for compromise, like the last go-round,” Sen. Bill Galvano, a Bradenton Republican who is in line to become Senate president after the 2018 elections, said in an interview Wednesday.

Galvano laughed when asked if lawmakers felt cheated after signing off on what was sold as an end to a perennial battle between the optometrists and the ophthalmologists.

“No. Every session is a new session. And these issues never go away,” he said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

What John McCain learned from Ted Kennedy on challenging his own party
What John McCain learned from Ted Kennedy on challenging his own party

WASHINGTON — Ted Kennedy liked to tell a favorite story about Sen. John McCain. The Massachusetts Democrat and the Arizona Republican were on the floor of the Senate and became distracted by a heated debate between two freshmen senators. Just for the fun of it, Kennedy and McCain launched into the fray. As one spoke, the other circled...
Trump shake-up: Sean Spicer, Anthony Scaramucci both have Palm Beach County ties
Trump shake-up: Sean Spicer, Anthony Scaramucci both have Palm Beach County ties

Sean Spicer, left, and Anthony Scaramucci Sean Spicer resigned as President Donald Trump‘s communications director, reportedly because he disagreed with Trump  naming Anthony Scaramucci as communications director. Like part-time Palm Beacher Trump, both Spicer and Scaramucci have Palm Beach...
Your A-to-Z guide to the media mayhem during President Trump’s first six months in office
Your A-to-Z guide to the media mayhem during President Trump’s first six months in office

The media has been the message for President Donald Trump almost every day of his presidency. And the message hasn't been warm and encouraging.   Trump's demonization of reporters and news organizations - fake news! failing media! failing fake news media! - has become as routine as a morning coffee. His supporters expect it, delight in it...
Conservative guerilla videographer James O’Keefe heading to Palm Beach County
Conservative guerilla videographer James O’Keefe heading to Palm Beach County

Guerilla videographer James O’Keefe will headline the Palm Beach County GOP’s annual Lobsterfest next month. Conservative activist James O’Keefe — whose Project Veritas Action has released controversial undercover videos targeting CNN, the  Hillary Clinton campaign and the...
Negron: Need- and merit-based aid boosted for Florida college students
Negron: Need- and merit-based aid boosted for Florida college students

Despite the governor’s veto of a wide-ranging higher-education policy bill, Senate President Joe Negron said Wednesday that many of the initiatives embedded in the legislation, including an expansion of Bright Futures scholarships, will still benefit state university and college students as fall terms begin next month. In a memo to senators,...
More Stories