POINT OF VIEW: Some Super Bowl TV ads are worth the price

A 30-second ad that airs during today’s Super Bowl, viewed by an estimated 100 million Americans, will cost more than $5 million. Does that amount to overpriced entertainment, or do these ads generate big sales? In many cases, it seems the ads more than pay for themselves.

Many marketing experts say Super Bowl ads are much less cost effective than other advertising, based in part on survey evidence. In one study, researchers interviewed consumers before and after a Super Bowl and found that very few ads led to increased purchases or even boosted viewers’ intention to buy.

However, measuring the effectiveness of advertising is difficult. And it may be especially hard when it comes to Super Bowl ads — as Randall Lewis of Google and Justin Rao of Microsoft have suggested with their “Super Bowl Impossibility Theorem.” Among other problems, surveys may not accurately reflect what consumers actually wind up buying.

But in two recent studies, economists used a clever approach to overcome these challenges, and both found that Super Bowl ads can be more effective than marketing experts assume.

The researchers made use of two facts about the Super Bowl: The ad time is sold well before anyone knows which teams will be playing, and viewership ends up being about 20 percent higher in places with a team in the game than it is elsewhere. This enables a more insightful analysis of ad effectiveness: If sales increase disproportionately in cities with home teams playing, it’s plausible that the ads caused the increase.

The first analysis looked at movie ads. The economists examined the effects of Super Bowl ads from 2004 to 2014 for 70 movies that were released within six months of the games. They assessed opening-weekend revenue as well as Google searches related to the movies — which are a good predictor of actual revenue.

Their stunning result: The average additional opening-weekend revenue generated by a Super Bowl ad amounted to $8.4 million, at a time when the average ad cost about $3 million. The incremental revenue may have been even higher, since the calculation did not include ticket sales after the opening weekend, let alone home purchases or other marketing channels. The researchers also point out, however, that movie studios probably have a limited number of offerings that are commercially promising enough to justify a Super Bowl ad. That may explain why there are usually only about a half dozen movie ads per game.

The second study found that Super Bowl ads for beer and soda also generally pay for themselves. One beer manufacturer earns almost $100 million more because of its ads — far more than what the ads cost. If two beverage competitors advertise, however, the effects cancel out so that neither one gets additional sales.

This new research suggests there’s good reason Super Bowl ads are so expensive. If the prices keep rising, they could presumably reach a point where the marginal ad is no longer profitable. But perhaps the marketing world’s conventional wisdom — that the ads don’t work — pushes back against increases that are too steep, and allows surprisingly strong returns to persist.


Editor’s note: Orszag is a Bloomberg View columnist. He is a vice chairman of investment banking at Lazard.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Gun control about saving lives, not waging culture wars

WASHINGTON — You have perhaps heard the joke about the liberal who is so open-minded that he can’t even take his own side in an argument. What’s less funny is that on gun control, liberals have been told for years that if they do take their own side in the argument, they will only hurt their cause. Supporters of even modest restrictions...
Opinion: Respect first, then gun control.

This has been an emotional week. We greet tragedies like the school shooting in Florida with shock, sadness, mourning and grief that turns into indignation and rage. The anger inevitably gets directed at the NRA, those who support gun rights and the politicians who refuse to do anything while children die. Many of us walked this emotional path. But...
Letters This is the time when heroes emerge

This is the time when heroes emerge Peter didn’t know me. I live far away in a small house with my wife, but the sounds of bravery echoed across the vast expanse. A young boy with a military dream heard the sounds of gunfire and was called to arms with his wit and courage. In the face of danger, he stood his post — the enemy was at the...
Opinion: ‘Daily Me’ undermines ability to understand ‘other side’

We live in two Americas. In one America, a mentally unstable president selected partly by Russia lies daily and stirs up bigotry that tears our social fabric. In another America, a can-do president tries to make America great again as lying journalists stir up hatred that tears our social fabric. The one thing we all agree on: Our social fabric is...
Opinion: Parkland school student rises up to challenge gun carnage

WASHINGTON — It was a profoundly poignant image: Thirty to 40 teens huddled together in a small dark room, their downturned faces illuminated by cellphones as they learned about an active shooter prowling their school. Via news apps, these survivors of Wednesday’s murderous rampage at a Parkland, Florida, high school, where 17 were killed...
More Stories