POINT OF VIEW: Managed repair programs by Florida insurers a bad idea


A recent op-ed piece written by a lobbyist for the Florida Property & Casualty Association endorsed the increased use of managed repair programs by insurers in Florida. The op-ed promotes an anti-consumer cost-saving strategy being implemented by insurers and maligned the public-adjusting industry for expressing concern with these managed repair programs.

Public Insurance Adjusters are licensed insurance professionals who use their skills and expertise to help policyholders. The author of the opinion piece wants us to believe these insurance professionals are a bunch of crooks who deliver “empty promises.” Rather than take shots at public adjusters, it’s more important to stick to the facts when trying to address a problem.

The author fails to mention the documented evidence that public-adjuster participation generally results in full, fair and increased compensation to policyholders. The Florida Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability (OPPAGA) conducted a study of public-adjuster representation in Citizens Property Insurance Corp. claims. They found that Citizens policyholders who used public adjusters received higher compensation on their claims than those that don’t. In other words, it is the public adjuster who is holding the insurance company’s feet to the fire and making sure that they pay their policyholders what they are rightfully owed.

The op-ed also asserts that public adjusters are “vehemently opposed” to insurers offering their policyholders the option to manage their repair process. This is simply not true. If insurers want to offer voluntary managed repair programs where policyholders have the choice of who and what will be repaired in their homes there would no objection. But that is not what is happening. In fact, what Citizens is proposing is much worse. Citizens is asking the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) to approve language that will penalize policyholders who don’t select to use their repair vendors. Translation: If you do not choose to have strangers selected by Citizens come into your home to make repairs, you will be penalized with an arbitrary $10,000 limit of coverage, regardless of the amount of coverage you bought and paid for.

As consumer advocates, we are compelled to speak out and bring awareness to this issue. Everyone’s focus should always remain on whether policyholders are treated fairly and compensated fully. Managed repair is an insurer cost-saving measure that should not be forced on policyholders with the threat of a penalty that would cause financial hardship.

DON PHILLIPS, TALLAHASSEE

Editor’s note: Don Phillips is president of the Florida Association of Public Insurance Adjusters.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Is the party of Lincoln now the party of Lee?

This year will mark my 30th anniversary as a syndicated columnist. During these years, I have written more words than I would have preferred about race. But race is America’s great moral stain and unending challenge. I’ve tackled school choice, affirmative action, transracial adoption, crime, police conduct, family structure, poverty, free-enterprise...
Letters Criminal justice system is failing addicts in crisis

System is failing addicts in crisis I gave a 19-year-old girl released from jail a ride to a Shell gas station and let her use my phone. Twenty-four hours later I got a call from her 77-year-old grandmother trying to find her. The girl was arrested wearing only a white T-shirt with blisters on her feet. Grandma got a call from police saying she was...
POINT OF VIEW: Need resources to spark interest, save performing arts

With the return of the school year upon us, it is important to remember the arts and its importance to the youth of our community. There has been a demise of cultural arts around the world — especially from generation to generation. We can see the impact in our own community. The Boca Pops is gone. The Florida Philharmonic Orchestra is gone....
CARTOON
CARTOON

CARTOON VIEW SIGNE WILKINSON
Editorial: UF made the right call denying ‘alt-right’ leader’s rally
Editorial: UF made the right call denying ‘alt-right’ leader’s rally

University of Florida President Kent Fuchs, citing serious concerns about the safety and security of students, last week denied a white nationalist leader’s request to rent space for a speech on the campus. Fuchs’ decision, which was a surprise reversal from just days prior, was understandable. It was also right. We don’t come to...
More Stories