POINT OF VIEW Boynton ban on group homes is unlawful


The city of Boynton Beach is calling for a total and complete shutdown of new group homes for persons with disabilities entering the city until June 1, 2017 — until their staff can figure out what is going on.

The City Commission voted to have a moratorium on any group homes for persons with disabilities in the city in order to have the ability to study guidance issued by the U.S. Department of Justice and the Department of Housing and Urban Development in November that was designed to help state and local governments better understand how to comply with the Fair Housing Act when making zoning and land use decisions. The guidance is a restatement of existing law in an easy to read format to ensure that persons with disabilities are permitted to be integrated into neighborhood, and not to be subject to discriminatory barriers.

In response to this document, the city did the exact opposite as required by the guidance – it built a regulatory wall around the city to bar persons with disabilities from moving into the city. This ban includes all group homes for persons with disabilities, such as group homes for adults with autism, intellectual or developmental disabilities, children who are medically complex and need 24 hour per day medical care or supervision, and persons overcoming drug or alcohol abuse.

The city may not block a group home in response to residents’ stereotypical fears or prejudices about persons with disabilities or a particular type of disability. For example, as a result of this moratorium, a person with a developmental or intellectual disability who would like to move out of his or her parent’s home Boynton Beach, may be required to move out of the city because of the failure to have adequate housing options. If municipalities were permitted to enact similar moratoriums, then persons with disabilities would be relegated to institutional placements or only go to certain “disability friendly” areas.

The acts of the City of Boynton Beach blatantly violates the Florida and Federal Fair Housing Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act, and should be contrary to the moral values that we hold dear as Americans.

A “moratorium” on group homes for persons with disabilities, whether temporary or permanent, is unlawful because it deprives persons with disabilities with the right to full participation in the community — that would be deprived to no other person or class of persons if they wished to move to the city of Boynton Beach.

MATTHEW W. DIETZ, MIAMI

Editor’s note: Matthew W. Dietz is founder and litigation director of Disability Independence Group, a nonprofit, South Florida Disability Rights Advocacy center.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Commentary: Fight against school vouchers hurts low-income parents
Commentary: Fight against school vouchers hurts low-income parents

Vouchers put educational choices for children in the hands of the people who care most: the parents. The voucher program was developed in the 1980s to give low-income families more choice in where their kids go to school. Rich people already have this choice. Why should this choice be denied to low-income kids who especially need a school environment...
Commentary: On vouchers, the evidence is in, and it’s not good
Commentary: On vouchers, the evidence is in, and it’s not good

The continued push for school vouchers, which transfer scarce taxpayer dollars out of public education and into private schools, is “a triumph of ideology over evidence that should worry anyone who wants to improve results for children.” That’s how one scholar described President Donald Trump’s nomination of Betsy DeVos to lead...
POINT OF VIEW: Today’s GOP needs another William F. Buckley Jr.

After the neo-Nazi demonstration in Charlottesville, Va., William F. Buckley Jr. must have been rolling over in his grave. As the founder of the National Review magazine, Buckley was an important catalyst for the modern conservative movement. Perhaps his greatest service was marginalizing extremists to prevent them from gaining ascendancy within Republican...
Letters: Charities too quick to bail on Mar-a-Lago
Letters: Charities too quick to bail on Mar-a-Lago

Charities too quick to bail on Mar-a-Lago I am so disappointed and upset by all the charities canceling their events at Mar-A-Lago. In past years the events seem to have been very successful in raising money. This may have been due to persons wanting to see this very beautiful and rather historical home in our area. These charities have allowed themselves...
CARTOON
CARTOON

CARTOON VIEW DANA SUMMERS
More Stories