Editorial: FPL’s 2013 pipeline looks better than FPL’s 2009 pipeline

In 2009, the Florida Public Service Commission rejected Florida Power & Light’s proposed $1.5 billion natural gas pipeline. This year, FPL is requesting a $3.5 billion pipeline project. Why does FPL think that this time will be different?

For starters, an FPL spokesman says, this actually is a cheaper pipeline from a customer standpoint. The commission rejected the 2009 project because it was deemed not to be the most cost-effective method of delivering gas. According to FPL, transportation costs of the new project are lower. Customers would pay those transportation costs, not for construction.

This project is different in other ways. FPL would have owned the pipeline proposed four years ago, running from northern Florida to FPL’s Martin County plant in Indiantown. Most of the new pipeline would be a joint venture between Spectra Energy of Houston and NextEra Energy, FPL’s Juno Beach-based parent company. They would spend $3 billion on the section between a pipeline hub in Alabama and Osceola County, south of Orlando. A NextEra subsidiary would build the $550 million link from there to the Indiantown plant, from which FPL would distribute the gas.

Finally, FPL and all Florida utilities have become even more dependent on natural gas than they were four years ago. By 2016, FPL will have converted three major generating plants — in Brevard County, Riviera Beach and Broward County — from oil to natural gas. The company projects that roughly two-thirds of its power then will come from natural gas.

Such a change requires more capacity to import the gas, since Florida produces almost none of it. FPL argues that Florida’s two existing natural gas pipelines are at capacity or will be there soon. At the start, FPL would use about half of the longer pipeline’s capacity. Only Texas uses more natural gas to generate electricity than Florida.

Still another reason, one that FPL doesn’t acknowledge, is that the current Public Service Commission has been friendly to the company. In December the PSC agreed to settle a rate case on terms that the company had drawn up, which was an unprecedented move and drew a legal challenge from the Office of Public Counsel, which represents consumers. FPL wants an answer on the pipeline by the end of 2013. Two seats on the five-member commission come open this year, but no new commissioners would take over until 2014.

Florida’s switch to natural gas has brought many benefits. The boom in production, due in large part to the controversial practice of fracking, has driven down prices. Natural gas also burns cleaner than oil and much cleaner than coal, thus reducing emissions of greenhouses gases that cause global warming. The Public Service Commission has been steering FPL and other utilities toward this switch for nearly a decade. Barring a persuasive argument that the pipeline would be a burden to consumers, FPL’s case is stronger than it was four years ago.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Huts burn, children die and Suu Kyi shrugs

A beloved Nobel Peace Prize winner is presiding over an ethnic cleansing in which villages are burned, women raped and children butchered. For the last three weeks, Buddhist-majority Myanmar has systematically slaughtered civilians belonging to the Rohingya Muslim minority, forcing 270,000 to flee to neighboring Bangladesh — with Myanmar soldiers...

Letters: Thanks to eatery for act of kindness
Letters: Thanks to eatery for act of kindness

Thanks to eatery for act of kindness I saw a lot of kind acts before and after Hurricane Irma. One that was much appreciated was after hours spent searching in vain for a store that had ice. On my way home, I went into a restaurant on Atlantic Avenue in Delray. It wasn’t open yet, still on generators, I think; and their crew was very busy trying...
Commentary: Liberal bias has reached disturbing new heights
Commentary: Liberal bias has reached disturbing new heights

A truly objective press has never existed in the United States, but the news media’s current commitment to destroy the Trump administration has revealed the sad reality that much of the American press is hardly engaging in journalism at all. Instead, the media have manipulated the public with falsehoods, trafficked in fear, and mastered hypocrisy...
POINT OF VIEW: PBC schools charter challenge a matter of local control

When the Palm Beach County School Board rejected a charter school application in December 2014, it brought a flurry of headlines – and gave the school district and School Board a reputation that it is opposed to charter schools. As a former charter school principal and longtime educator, I can tell you that nothing could be further from the truth...
More Stories