Editorial: Extreme partisanship blocks judges, cripples federal courts


The federal courts are where citizens go to protect important constitutional rights on voting access, the environment and discrimination.

Think it’s bad that we have an empty seat on the U.S. Supreme Court?

Well, that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Senate Republicans have been so successful in their strategy of obstructing any nominees by President Barack Obama that there are now 89 vacancies in the federal courts system.

Waiting to fill those spots are 58 nominees, the limbo for some going back almost a year and a half. That includes South Florida attorney Mary Barzee Flores, whose nomination 16 months ago has been blocked by her own senator, Marco Rubio. The seat she would fill on the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida? It’s been empty two years.

The foot-dragging of the Senate is at new levels, and it is having a dispiriting impact on the judiciary. More accused criminals are having their charges dismissed or taking pleas because the pressure is on in the courthouses to slash criminal dockets.

More important, the federal courts are where citizens go to protect important constitutional rights on voting access, the environment and discrimination. It’s where consumers and workers go to hold corporations accountable. With those courts crippled, essential liberties may be eroded.

There is no mystery why this is occurring. Just hours after conservative Justice Antonin Scalia died on Feb. 13, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said, “This vacancy should not be filled until we have a new president”— even though the U.S. Constitution clearly defines the Senate’s duty to “advise and consent” when presidents nominate a justice.

Sure enough, Obama’s pick, Judge Merrick Garland, has been all but forgotten, no confirmation hearing in sight, while the Supreme Court makes do with a shorthanded bench, divided 4-4 between liberals and conservatives. Last month, the court punted on an important case that challenged Obamacare contraception coverage on religious grounds, sending it back to a lower court with the lame request that everybody try to work things out. Thus is the highest court in the land diminished.

Stalling and voting no have been the consistent approach of congressional Republicans all through the Obama administration. In Obama’s first term, he saw fewer total circuit court and district court nominees confirmed than in the first term of the past three presidents: just 173, compared with 205 for George W. Bush, 200 for Bill Clinton and 192 for George H.W. Bush.

Most of Obama’s picks had to wait 200 days or more from nomination to confirmation; back in the administration of Ronald Reagan, 82 percent of judgeships were confirmed inside 100 days — with a Democratic Senate.

To be sure, both Democrats and Republicans have been escalating this kind of fighting over the past 30 years. But it really spiked after Obama took office and McConnell vowed that his “No. 1 priority” was to engineer Obama’s failure. This isn’t patriotism. It’s the very definition of putting party above country.

It all adds immeasurably to the cynicism that people feel about government. Our system is supposed to be one of checks and balances, not a system of perpetual stalemate.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

COMMENTARY: Reformers: Be ready when your time comes

Reformers are by nature impatient. But historically their victories have come from long, sustained efforts that began in periods when conservatives were dominant. Many aspects of Franklin Roosevelt’s program were first advanced during the administrations of Calvin Coolidge and Herbert Hoover. They reached fruition when the political atmosphere...
Opinion: Is war with Iran now inevitable?

With his declaration Friday that the Iran nuclear deal is not in the national interest, President Donald Trump may have put us on the road to war with Iran. Indeed, it is easier to see the collisions that are coming than to see how we get off this road before the shooting starts. After “de-certifying” the nuclear agreement, signed by all...
Letters South Flagler Drive a traffic tragedy waiting to happen
Letters South Flagler Drive a traffic tragedy waiting to happen

South Flagler Drive a tragedy in waiting A very dangerous situation both for pedestrians and motor vehicles has thoughtlessly been created on South Flagler Drive. The passageway by the water is underutilized. The traffic lights are useless and there is little room for error when driving a car. The complexity of turning is dangerous in two small traffic...
POINT OF VIEW: Time for Florida to take a closer look at charters

Florida’s charter school movement had humble beginnings in the 1990s, as pioneers promised tailored programs. Along the way, the lucrative for-profit industry convinced Florida’s Legislature and governor, through House Bill 7069, that their privately owned facilities should be funded at equal levels to Florida’s 4,200 public schools...
Editorial: Scott must stand firm on getting generators into facilities
Editorial: Scott must stand firm on getting generators into facilities

Florida’s nursing home industry, which has been whining ever since Gov. Rick Scott ordered facilities to install enough generator power to keep elderly people from dying of heat after the next hurricane, is now asking for permission to be excused from Scott’s emergency deadline. As of Monday, 54 providers of nursing homes or assisted-living...
More Stories