Pain doctor accused of overprescribing opioids pleads guilty


At Dr. Fathalla Mashali's pain management clinics, the waiting rooms were often so packed with patients that people sat on the floor, leaned against walls and spilled into the hallways.

That's because, federal prosecutors say, Mashali was prescribing oxycodone and other powerful opioid painkillers at alarming rates to people making risky use of drugs. At one point, they say, Mashali wrote out more oxycodone prescriptions in one month — over 1,100 — than some of the largest hospitals in Massachusetts.

Mashali pleaded guilty Wednesday to 44 counts of health care fraud, conspiracy to commit mail fraud and money laundering, offering a brief apology during his change-of-plea hearing in U.S. District Court.

"I'm very sorry. I hurt my family. I hurt my patients," Mashali said.

Sentencing is scheduled for June 21. Prosecutors said in a court filing that federal sentencing guidelines call for 12½ to 15½ years in prison.

Prosecutors nationwide have cracked down on so-called pill mills like the pain management clinics run by Mashali, places where prescriptions are often handed out without physical exams or tests to determine whether a legitimate condition requires pain medication.

Prosecutors in Boston said Mashali would often see more than 100 patients in one day. A medical assistant who worked at one of Mashali's offices told investigators that only about 5 percent of his patients had legitimate medical conditions.

Mashali, 62, was born in Egypt and received a medical degree from Cairo University. He moved to the United States more than 30 years ago, became a permanent resident, got married, had four children and served as a captain in the U.S. Army Reserve.

In the early 2000s, Mashali began operating a pain management clinic, eventually opening three offices in Massachusetts and one in Rhode Island. As his practice grew, so did his personal spending. In 2008, Mashali filed for bankruptcy, listing $12 million in debts.

Prosecutors say he used the proceeds from his thriving practice to pay for a lavish lifestyle. In 2011, after emerging from bankruptcy, he and his wife bought a $2.2 million home in Dover, one of the wealthiest towns in Massachusetts, and made approximately $2 million in improvements.

"The evidence will show that Mashali's lust for exuberant wealth and luxury severely compromised the care and safety of his vulnerable patients," prosecutors wrote in a trial brief last month.

Mashali's practice began to fall apart in 2012, when his former employees alleged he was prescribing high doses of drugs to patients with addictions and fraudulently billing for tests he never did.

In 2013, the Rhode Island Board of Medicine revoked his medical license, finding that he had provided "substandard care" to six of seven patients who died. After that, Mashali voluntarily surrendered his Massachusetts license.

He was arrested Feb. 7, 2014, while attempting to board a plane to Egypt on a one-way ticket.

In court filings, Mashali's lawyers have said he has severe bipolar disorder and neurosarcoidosis, a central nervous system disease that can be characterized by confusion or dementia. During Wednesday's hearing, Mashali said he is taking more than 20 medications for those illnesses, as well as anxiety and depression.

"As the sentencing hearing will show, he is a deeply troubled individual whose underlying psychopathology in large part contributed to the offense conduct," Mashali's attorney, Jeffrey Denner, said after the hearing.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Maxim Grinberg asked for Mashali to be taken into custody while awaiting sentencing.

But Judge Rya Zobel said he could remain free so he can continue to receive daily treatment at a psychiatric hospital. She ordered him to wear an electronic monitoring bracelet.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

8-year-old football players kneel during national anthem in protest
8-year-old football players kneel during national anthem in protest

Every player from an 8-and-under football team in Belleville, Illinois, took a knee in protest during the national anthem before their game on Saturday, according to KTVI. “One of the kids asked me if I saw (people) protesting and rioting in St. Louis. I said yes; I said, ‘Do you know why they are doing it?'” said Coach...
Hurricane Maria: Live updates
Hurricane Maria: Live updates

Hurricane Maria is bearing down on the Caribbean and is set to pass over much the same area devastated by Hurricane Irma nearly two weeks ago. >> Read more trending news 
Doctor realizes she's going into labor after delivering patient's baby
Doctor realizes she's going into labor after delivering patient's baby

In the early morning hours of July 28, Dr. Emily Jacobs noticed that her own water had broken just after delivering a third baby during her shift -- taking her from the role of doctor to patient. "I noticed what I thought was amniotic fluid of the patient as the baby was delivering. It wasn't until I left the room when I realized that it was my...
These are the 'Most Dangerous' celebrities on the internet, according to a new survey
These are the 'Most Dangerous' celebrities on the internet, according to a new survey

What do Avril Lavigne, Bruno Mars, Beyonce, Sean “P. Diddy” Combs and Katy Perry have in common? Besides fame, that is? They’re “dangerous” online — at least according to McAfee, the cybersecurity company, who tracks and ranks celebrities based on the search results for their name. Using Google, Bing and Yahoo...
Mother speaks out after her children are barred from school after principal denies their residency
Mother speaks out after her children are barred from school after principal denies their residency

Four children have been barred from a Memphis, Tennessee, school after its principal denies their residency. For nearly two weeks, Erica Smith, the mother of those children, says she has fought to get them re-enrolled in Snowden School since they were barred from attending by Principal Jamie Stallsmith Sept. 8. Over a week later, Smith is facing a...
More Stories