Lawsuit over Trump golf club contract so complex even judge confused

Like many who have been stunned by the meteoric rise of GOP front-runner Donald Trump, a federal judge on Thursday voiced the same sentiment — confusion — about a lawsuit pitting the part-time Palm Beach millionaire against members of Trump National Golf Club in Jupiter.

“I’m trying to understand what we’re really fighting about,” U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra told warring attorneys during the roughly two-hour hearing.

While they didn’t mention the amount Thursday, attorneys representing roughly 60 members of the club in the long-running class-action lawsuit have said at least $6 million is at stake.

That is the minimum they claim Trump owes their clients for changing the membership rules after he plunked down $5 million for the ailing club, knowing it had $41 million in liabilities because of money it owed members in what were supposed to be refundable deposits. Attorney Mark Fistos said his clients — upset by the rule changes and blocked from using the club — want their hefty deposits back now.

“Clearly Trump has changed the whole policy and plan,” Fistos said of what is fueling the breach of contract litigation.

Attorneys representing Trump, who asked Marra to throw out the lawsuit, countered that the members will get their money in due time. They simply have to wait until new members join before getting back deposits, which range from $35,000 to $210,000. The rules forcing members to play a waiting game were in place when Trump bought the club in December 2012 from the Ritz-Carlton Golf Club & Spa, which had been losing as much as $4.2 million annually trying to keep it afloat.

“They don’t want to wait any longer, so they filed this lawsuit,” said Miami attorney Herman Russomanno III, who represents the club. The lawsuit is simply a way to jump to the front of what has always been a very long line, he said.

The club, in a gated community off Donald Ross Road near Alternate A1A, was catapulted into the national spotlight this month when Trump showcased it by staging one of his political press conferences there. Standing in the ballroom of the club’s ornate clubhouse, he displayed Trump Steaks, Trump magazine, Trump water and other Trump products in an effort to bolster his claim of business savvy against his Republican opponents’ attacks that many of his ventures were failures.

After the press conference, Michelle Fields, a reporter for the conservative Breitbart News, claimed she was manhandled by Trump campaign manager Corey Lewandowski at the event, an accusation he denied. Jupiter police are investigating the claim.

The hearing on the lawsuit featured a stunning array of legal terms and contradictory interpretations of them. Attorneys disagreed, for instance, about a “legacy addendum,” what constitutes a “breach,” and “terminability.”

Even the plain language of Trump was disputed. In a throwback to his famous “You’re fired!” catchphrase of his TV show, “The Apprentice,” he said in a 2012 letter to members that if they didn’t like his new rules, “you’re out.”

Fistos said his clients believed what they read. They were further convinced when they were denied entry to the club. Trump’s behavior means he breached their membership contracts, which makes them entitled to refunds immediately, Fistos said.

Russomanno attempted to walk back Trump’s “you’re out” comment. Instead of cancelling memberships, Trump’s son, Eric, who oversees the club, has negotiated with other members, he said.

Further, he said, Fistos’ clients were preventing from using the club because they hadn’t paid their dues. In court papers, he said some owed as much as $81,000. It has long been a rule that if you don’t pay, you can’t play, he said.

But, again, disagreement erupted. Fistos said his clients stopped paying their dues because they couldn’t use the club.

Marra, who quizzed both sides rigorously, promised a ruling soon.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Trump touts ‘America first,’ until he needs cheap labor at Mar-a-Lago
Trump touts ‘America first,’ until he needs cheap labor at Mar-a-Lago

In case you haven’t noticed, our governor, Rick Scott, is obsessed with jobs. He loves talking about his devotion to putting people to work in Florida. “I travel the state every day and I can say the most important thing we can do is give people a job,” Scott said earlier this year in South Florida while on one of his “job tours&rdquo...
NEW: 3 children, 2 adults displaced after fire in Belle Glade
NEW: 3 children, 2 adults displaced after fire in Belle Glade

Three children and two adults were displaced after a fire in Belle Glade Friday evening, according the American Red Cross of Greater Palm Beach and Martin counties. Palm Beach County Fire Rescue crews were called to an apartment fire on the 500 block of 8th Street, just west of South Main Street and south of Doctor M.L.K Boulevard. When they arrived...
16-year sentence follows emotional, grueling Dalia Dippolito hearing
16-year sentence follows emotional, grueling Dalia Dippolito hearing

Unless a second round of appeals in her case proves as fruitful as the first, Dalia Dippolito’s infant son could be well into his teens by the time his mother gets out of prison for the 2009 plot to kill her now ex-husband, Michael. Palm Beach County Circuit Judge Glenn Kelley sentenced the 34-year-old former Boynton Beach newlywed to 16 years...
NEW: West Palm detective featured on ‘Cold Justice’ TV show Saturday
NEW: West Palm detective featured on ‘Cold Justice’ TV show Saturday

Over his nearly two decades with the West Palm Beach Police Department, Detective Aaron Sam has investigated more than 200 deaths and homicides, with his share of unsolved ones. He remembers one he and others feared wouldn’t be solved: It took nearly four years, local, state and federal agencies and patience for an arrest. Two fatal shootings...
BREAKING: West Palm man gets life in prison for sex trafficking
BREAKING: West Palm man gets life in prison for sex trafficking

A former government contractor with ties to West Palm Beach was sentenced to life in prison Friday on a convictions for sex trafficking and child exploitation while he worked at a U.S. military base in Honduras. Christopher Rennie Glenn was sentenced during an appearance before U.S. District Judge Robert N. Scola Jr. He was convicted in March following...
More Stories