West Palm claims ex-cop lied in court about PTSD


In what labor lawyer Sid Garcia calls the most vicious act he’s ever seen by an employer, the city of West Palm Beach is suing a former city police officer, claiming the Iraqi vet lied to convince a jury to award him $880,000 in a discrimination case.

The complex, multi-pronged litigation involves Matthew Ladd, who was fired by West Palm Beach in 2010 while he was still on probation. His termination came days after a psychiatrist hired by the city rejected police claims that Ladd, who served two years in Iraq and Afghanistan, suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder. Dr. Norman Silversmith found that Ladd was fit to return to duty.

Silversmith’s opinion and other evidence presented during a 2013 trial persuaded a jury that the city had used PTSD as a ruse to fire Ladd and ordered it to pay him nearly $900,000 in damages.

However, city officials say in a lawsuit filed this month in Palm Beach County Circuit Court that Ladd lied to police brass and Silversmith about his condition. Medical records they obtained as part of a related federal lawsuit show Ladd was diagnosed with PTSD as early as 2007 and that he was taking experimental drugs to deal with it during the three months he worked as a city cop, city attorneys claim.

Garcia counters that city officials are misinterpreting Ladd’s medical records to trump up their claims that his client committed a fraud upon the court. Further, Garcia says in records in the federal lawsuit that the claim is “a vexatious, bad faith attempt to punish Mr. Ladd for the resounding victory he had against the (city)” in the 2013 state court trial.

Ladd wasn’t diagnosed with PTSD until September 2012, nearly two years after he was fired by the city, Garcia says. Subsequently, in May 2013, Ladd scored a zero for PTSD on questionnaires administered by the Veteran’s Administration, the attorney said. Ladd remained in the Army reserves until 2012.

Garcia also blasted city attorneys for putting most of Ladd’s medical records in federal court files, where the records can be accessed by the public. “I’ve never seen such vindictiveness on the part of an employer,” he said.

City spokesman Elliot Cohen on Monday declined to comment about the lawsuit, saying he didn’t want his comments to influence Tuesday’s municipal elections for mayor and city commission.

In a statement on Tuesday, he said: “This entire case centers around Mr. Ladd’s medical background, and it would be impossible to defend ourselves in court without referring to his medical records.”

The two sides have argued bitterly in court since the jury returned its verdict. City attorneys persuaded Palm Beach County Circuit Judge David Crow not to order the city to reinstate Ladd.

Instead, the judge said Ladd was entitled to pay he would have received had he not been fired. The amount — which could push Ladd’s award to more than $1 million — has not been determined while the city appeals the verdict.

In the meantime, Ladd sued the city in federal court, claiming that the city violated his rights under the Uniformed Services Employment and Re-employment Rights Act of 1994 and the Americans with Disabilities Act when it fired him for having PTSD. A federal judge has rejected the city efforts to have the case thrown out.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Congress can easily avoid shutdowns. Here’s why it doesn’t.
Congress can easily avoid shutdowns. Here’s why it doesn’t.

A government shutdown is like the weather. Everyone talks about it but nobody does anything about it.  There's one big difference between the weather and shutdown, however. Nobody can do anything about the weather while members of Congress can easily avoid shutdowns. Indeed, they usually do, with only four "true" shutdowns in modern...
With a porn star on stage, a strip club and a presidency meet
With a porn star on stage, a strip club and a presidency meet

One by one, the patrons lurched to the stage’s edge, summoned by the siren song of stale arena rock and toplessness — a sea of large men with small bills and slight smiles, plainly convinced that America has been plenty great for some time now.  It was a special kind of Saturday, and the cover charge showed: $20 at the door, double...
A president not sure of what he wants complicates the shutdown impasse
A president not sure of what he wants complicates the shutdown impasse

When President Donald Trump mused last year about protecting immigrants brought to the United States illegally as children, calling them “these incredible kids,” aides implored him privately to stop talking about them so sympathetically.  When he batted around the idea of granting them citizenship over a Chinese dinner at the White...
Vacation rentals become focal point of state vs. local power struggle
Vacation rentals become focal point of state vs. local power struggle

Six years ago, Aline was on the verge of losing her Boca Raton home. The single mother was employed but a divorce had left her bad off financially. Additionally, she struggled to care for her aging parents. Anxious to turn things around, she spotted an Airbnb newspaper ad. A former hotel owner, Aline jumped at the chance to make some extra money renting...
Eric Trump says dad would be ‘hugely impeded’ if Dems take Congress
Eric Trump says dad would be ‘hugely impeded’ if Dems take Congress

Eric Trump and wife Lara speaking to Republican activists at the West Palm Beach Marriott today. (Damon Higgins/The Palm Beach Post) WEST PALM BEACH — Eric Trump thanked local Republican activists for their grass-roots efforts today and warned that his father’s agenda would be “hugely, hugely...
More Stories