Local pro-Trump rally put spotlight on tax reform, Trump’s returns


Two dozen Donald Trump backers rallied in support of him here Tuesday, offering an enthusiastic if small-scale counterpoint to the Easter weekend protest in West Palm Beach, where several hundred opponents demanded that the president release his tax returns.

RELATED: The Post’s complete coverage of President Trump

Both sides — the anti-Trump protesters and the backers of the president — sought to draw attention to their cause by linking their rallies to the day when Americans must file their own returns. April 15 is the traditional tax day, but it was bumped to April 18 this year because of the weekend and a Washington, D.C., holiday on Monday.

The Palm Beach County Tea Party organized Tuesday’s rally in Palm Beach Gardens, where flag- and sign-waving Trump backers at the corner of PGA Boulevard and Military Trail drew many honks of support and more than a few middle finger salutes and jeers of derision.

» Trump steers clear of Tax March as hundreds protest near Mar-a-Lago

Officially, the reason for Tuesday’s rally was to generate support for the president’s tax reform plan, whose details are still unknown.

Supporters of the president took the opportunity to offer up a reminder that, despite the weekend protests and recent polling showing Trump to be at historic lows at this point in a presidency, they still have his back.

“The 87 days that he’s been in office, I think he’s done a terrific job,” said Willy Guardiola of Palm Beach Gardens.

“We’re here to save America from what’s been going on the past number of years, from socialism, from communism,” said Mel Grossman, a Palm Beach Gardens resident who is president of the Palm Beach County Tea Party.

Not long ago, tea party rallies drew hundreds.

In 2009, a Tax Day rally at the Palm Beach County Governmental Center drew a crowd estimated to be between 600 to 1,000 people. A year later at the same site, crowd estimates for the tea party rally approached 1,000.

Back then, Marco Rubio was a potential candidate for office, not a twice-elected U.S. senator. And Barack Obama was the newly-elected president reviled by tea partiers across the country.

» Palm Beach County tax return protest organizer: No one paid us

Obama is gone from office now, and while the tea party revulsion of him remains in technicolor, it does not appear to be strong enough to generate the mass rallies of yore.

As evidenced by this past weekend’s protests across the nation, that anger and passion is with Trump’s opponents, who view him as a habitually dishonest and unprepared president who might bluster the country into a nuclear war.

Their protests appeared to annoy the president, who tweeted out a suggestion Sunday that the protesters were paid and a reminder that he won the November election.

“I did what was an almost an impossible thing to do for a Republican-easily won the Electoral College!” the president tweeted. “Now Tax Returns are brought up again?”

Democrats in Congress have said the president’s unwillingness to release his tax returns will complicate any efforts to pass a tax reform plan. Without those returns, offered by every president since Richard Nixon, Americans can’t know whether a reform plan would benefit the president personally, Democrats argue.

» PHOTOS: Tax March in West Palm Beach 

Tax experts say reforms could benefit the president in any number of ways, though they might not shed light on an issue Democrats have pounded away on — the question of whether Trump owes money to or is paid by Russian interests. That question took on added urgency after U.S. intelligence agencies issued a report concluding that the Russian government interfered with last year’s election to help Trump.

Even with an increasing number of fellow Republicans calling on the president to release his tax returns, there is no indication Trump plans to accede to their wishes. Karen Burke, a tax law professor at the University of Florida, said the returns might not bring any clarity on the Russia issue.

“I doubt the returns would shed light on Russian contacts,” she wrote in an email to The Palm Beach Post.

But there are other areas where they could show how much the president would benefit from changes to the alternative minimum tax, a feature of the tax code designed to make sure upper middle class and wealthy individuals are not successful in completely avoiding taxes.

Trump’s returns, Burke said, “would certainly shed light on what Trump would gain personally from repeal of the AMT,” something Republicans have long supported.

“Depending on the years in question, they would also shed light on how Trump has benefited from the loophole for real estate developers who have cancellation of indebtedness income but are allowed to preserve their net operating losses,” she said.

Martin McMahon, director of the Graduate Tax Program at the University of Florida’s law school, said Trump’s returns could give Americans other bits of information about their president — what his effective tax rate is, how much he gives to charity and whether he has benefited from conservation easements on his golf courses.

Such easements are now controversial, McMahon said, because some argue that their benefits to nature — the reason such easement holders are eligible for assistance through the tax code in the first place — are negligible.

McMahon, who has viewed some of Trump’s financial and tax documents at the request of various media outlets, said the returns aren’t likely to show whether Trump personally owes money to Russian interests, which, in the mind of some opponents, is one explanation for the president’s inexplicable initial embrace of Russian President Vladimir Putin.

“Trump probably has no direct borrowing as a person,” McMahon said. “Everything that I saw was through partnerships.”

The issue of Trump’s tax returns was of little interest to his supporters in Palm Beach Gardens Tuesday.

“Who cares?” said Madi Page of Greenacres.

The bigger issue, Page said, is media treatment of the president. And, on that score, she had a directive for The Palm Beach Post and other newspapers.

“Start putting some more ‘love Trump’ stuff on the cover of your newspaper,” she said. “Start finding more right instead of finding things wrong. We want to see some more positive stuff.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Florida governor, GOP lawmakers weigh options after mass shooting
Florida governor, GOP lawmakers weigh options after mass shooting

A second gun-related bill has been postponed in the Florida Senate in the wake of last week’s mass shooting at a Parkland high school, as legislative leaders craft a multi-pronged response to the massacre and Gov. Rick Scott plans a series of workshops about school safety and ways to keep guns away from people struggling with mental illnesses...
Gun control could become key issue in Florida in November
Gun control could become key issue in Florida in November

An aversion to gun-rights restrictions has been a bedrock of Republican campaigns in Florida — a testing ground for model NRA-backed legislation — for years. But a 19-year-old killer, armed with a semi-automatic rifle he purchased legally and used to fatally gun down 14 students and three faculty members at a Broward County high school...
Education issues key to end of session for Florida Legislature
Education issues key to end of session for Florida Legislature

Florida lawmakers will use the last three weeks of the 2018 session to decide the fate of a number of major education bills that address everything from school bullying to teachers to university tuition. The decisions will begin unfolding Tuesday when the Senate Education Committee takes up a nearly 200-page bill (HB 7055) that is important to House...
Trump fumes about Russia investigation as nation mourns
Trump fumes about Russia investigation as nation mourns

As the nation mourned, President Donald Trump kept largely silent about the Florida school shooting victims and the escalating gun control debate, instead raging at the FBI for what he perceived to be a fixation on the Russia investigation at the cost of failing to deter the attack. From the privacy of Mar-a-Lago, Trump vented about the investigation...
Why Parkland students have emerged as a powerful political voice
Why Parkland students have emerged as a powerful political voice

The boldest voices to emerge in the wake of last week's mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. have been unexpected ones. Surviving students at the school quickly spoke out on social media and to news cameras both about the incident and, more broadly, about political leadership which they saw as having let them...
More Stories