Cerabino: Marco Rubio’s spine to be tested in new tax bill


Uh, oh. Marco Rubio’s talking about his parents again.

Florida’s junior U.S. Senator usually invokes his father the bartender, and his mother the maid, when he’s running for office and delivering a stem-winder on the American Dream.

Rubio’s parents came to the United States in pre-Castro Cuba with little skills, but through hard work, they earned a living, and raised children, one of whom is a U.S. Senator and potential future president.

Rubio’s actual lawmaking sometimes runs in conflict with his heartwarming origin story. For example, he cravenly fell in line with his party’s call for “merit-based immigration,” which would have surely deemed Rubio’s fourth-grade-educated father unworthy for entry.

But I’m hoping that Rubio’s new references to his parents will turn into real action, and not just some pretty words that ultimately take a back seat to his own political ambition.

Last week, Rubio gave an impassioned speech on the floor of the Senate in support of a more generous child tax credit in the massive tax bill that his Republican colleagues in the House were writing. He said it was imperative that the mix of big tax cuts didn’t leave out the families that might not make enough to pay federal income tax, but pay plenty in payroll taxes.

“Let’s just take a family like the one I grew up in: a bartender and maid,” he said.

Uh, oh. Here we go again.

“The median income of the bartender and a maid is about $42,000, $43,000 a year,” Rubio said.

“They have three children. Without anything in the child tax credit — we just leave it like it is and do the framework — they are going to pay $1,276 more in taxes,” Rubio said. “Can you imagine a tax reform plan that raises taxes on a bartender and a maid, with three children, making $42,000, $43,000 a year, and it raises their taxes by almost $1,300 a year?”

Rubio was making a pitch for something he’s been talking about for a couple of years. That the real way to give more buying power to the vast majority of American families in the middle and lower classes is to reduce their tax rate through child tax credits.

The Republican plan being worked on at the time of Rubio’s speech tentatively called for raising the $1,000 child tax credit by an additional $500. But Rubio was arguing, using his bartender and maid example, that this was just window dressing.

“So let’s just do the symbolic thing, raise it $500 but make it nonrefundable,” he said. “They will get a tax cut of about the same — $233. You might as well keep it because they’re not going to make a difference.”

The word “refundable” is significant here, and something his party hadn’t embraced. Nearly half of all taxpayers pay no federal income tax or very little federal income tax.

But if they work, they do pay significant payroll taxes for Social Security, Medicare and unemployment benefits. And even for those who do pay federal income tax, payroll taxes make up the majority of taxes paid by all but the top 10 percent of wage earners.

So Rubio’s middle-class tax reform idea is to give a significant boost to the child-tax credit — he argued two years ago for raising it to $2,500, but has knocked it back to $2,000 now — and making it refundable against not just the federal income taxes paid, but more significantly, the payroll taxes paid.

If it’s not refundable against payroll taxes, giving a federal income tax credit alone is useless to the bottom 47 percent of earners.

“For people that work and get a paycheck every week or every two weeks, when they get that paycheck it shows that money came out of their paycheck,” Rubio argued last week. “It doesn’t matter if that money went into income or payroll tax, that’s the money they earned that you took away using the power of government.

“They are paying taxes, whether they are paying income tax or payroll tax, they are paying taxes. If you want to help people who are working but don’t make enough, then the only way — and they are trying to raise a family — the child tax credit is the best way to do it,” Rubio said.

So what happened? When Republicans in the House unveiled their tax bill two days after Rubio’s speech, it had the symbolic, but ineffective, increase in the child tax credit to $1,600, and it was not refundable through payroll taxes, thereby making it useless to his bartender-maid example family.

Now what, Marco?

“We appreciate the hard work and countless hours our colleagues in the House have put into crafting this legislation,” Rubio’s office said in a prepared statement after his child-tax credit push was ignored.

Then he gently mentioned that he hadn’t given up on it yet.

“We wish the House draft had done more on this front—preferably doubling the credit to $2,000 per child and expanding its applicability to payroll taxes. We look forward to working with our colleagues to make sure working families are moved to the front of the line in the Senate bill.”

I’m rooting for Rubio. I know somewhere in that ball of ambition is a backbone capable of stiffening. This could be the time.

Maybe there will be a day soon when Rubio will stand up on the floor of the Senate and not just talk, but provide a meaningful vote against a bill that provides a windfall in tax relief to the wealthiest estates in America while giving nothing to the sainted bartender-maid households that inhabit his speeches.

Maybe. I wouldn’t bet the mortgage on it.

But it would be a show-don’t-tell moment for Rubio worth waiting for.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Trump’s first year: JFK comparisons, golf, missiles, the 561 Cabinet, other Palm Beach highlights
Trump’s first year: JFK comparisons, golf, missiles, the 561 Cabinet, other Palm Beach highlights

Presidents in Palm Beach: JFK and Jackie with kids on Easter in 1963; Donald and Melania Trump at Easter last year. (Kennedy photo from JFK Library; Trump photo by Melanie Bell/Palm Beach Daily News) PALM BEACH — John F. Kennedy was America’s first Palm Beach president, but Donald...
Shutdown: Some Senate Dems from Trump states vote with GOP; Florida’s Bill Nelson does not
Shutdown: Some Senate Dems from Trump states vote with GOP; Florida’s Bill Nelson does not

Republican Sen. Marco Rubio (left) supported a short-term spending measure to avert a federal government shutdown; Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson was opposed. (George Bennett/The Palm Beach Post) Five Democratic senators from states that President Donald Trump carried in 2016 broke with party leadership late Friday and voted...
Here's what has happened during previous government shutdowns
Here's what has happened during previous government shutdowns

It’s fairly certain the government will shut down. If the Senate doesn’t pass the short-term spending bill —passed earlier by the House — by midnight Friday, it will happen. Under a shutdown, thousands of federal employees would go without pay and national parks would close, among other things.  Here's a look at the key...
House Speaker: Florida lawmakers to weigh oversight of high-speed rail
House Speaker: Florida lawmakers to weigh oversight of high-speed rail

House Speaker Richard Corcoran said a push by some lawmakers for state oversight of high-speed passenger rail will get consideration during this year’s legislative session. But he offered little detail, as opponents want to put the brakes on a controversial new rail service in South Florida following a second recent death on the tracks. »...
Former PBC Fire Rescue chief Collins says he wants his job back
Former PBC Fire Rescue chief Collins says he wants his job back

Former Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Chief Jeffrey Collins, who resigned in the aftermath of sexual harassment and retaliation complaints that have rocked the department, said Friday he wants his job back. During a 22-minute press conference at the law offices of his attorneys in Boca Raton, Collins, a 21-year veteran of the department, said County...
More Stories