PBC school board blasts legal team for blaming girls in sex-abuse suit


Palm Beach County School Board members harshly criticized their own legal team Wednesday for suggesting in court filings that four young girls were partly to blame for their injuries after being sexually molested 12 years ago by their third-grade teacher.

As they approved a $3.5 million legal settlement with the four former students, board members said they were stunned by newspaper reports this past week that revealed that a private attorney representing the school district in the case had argued that the young girls share blame for any trauma they experienced.

“I cried,” School Board member Karen Brill said. “We trust our outside counsel and inside counsel to represent us in a manner that aligns with our values.”

Board member Marcia Andrews said that she was “shocked and dismayed and heartbroken to learn recently that we were using this (legal strategy).”

The case stems from a lawsuit filed by four girls, all about 9 at the time, who had alleged they were molested during the 2004-05 school year by third-grade teacher Blake Sinrod, who they said touched them in private areas and instructed them to touch him.

School district police had investigated their claims and arrested Sinrod, who pleaded guilty to child-abuse charges and surrendered his teaching license.

In a court filing in February, the Conroy Simberg law firm of Broward County argued for the school board that the four girls, all students at Coral Sunset Elementary in Boca Raton, “were old enough to appreciate the consequences of their own actions and to be held accountable for them.”

“Through their actions and/or omissions, [the girls] conducted themselves in a careless and negligent manner, and such negligence was a contributing and/or sole proximate cause of their injuries and damages,” attorney Dale Friedman wrote in a court filing.

Friedman’s firm had been hired by the school board to defend the case, in which the four girls sued claiming emotional and psychological damages.

In an interview this past week, Friedman told The Palm Beach Post that the legal tactic, called “comparative negligence,” reserves the school board’s right to explore the children’s potential culpability in the case. But she said it was never her intention to blame the children.

She made the same argument in a tearful explanation to board members Wednesday.

“The focus has been on one sentence in a pleading known as an affirmative defense,” she said. “We absolutely understand the concern and the perception that came from the use and language of this defense.”

It was not the only time the school board has used the tactic in sexual molestation cases. The Sun Sentinel uncovered four other cases in recent years in which the school board raised questions about the children’s culpability in sexual-abuse lawsuits.

School Board General Counsel JulieAnn Rico declined to comment Wednesday.

Board members took no formal action to bar similar legal tactics in future cases, but board member Barbara McQuinn said that Rico had been instructed to keep the board more closely informed of the legal strategies that attorneys use in defending abuse lawsuits.

“They have to bring the cases to us,” she said.

Brill said that board members “had never discussed a defense strategy blaming (children)” but that they all would work to ensure it was never used again.

“I can personally assure you that I will ask deeper questions when cases are reviewed, and I believe we are all on the same page when we say never again,” she said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Delray Beach residents homeless after fire
Delray Beach residents homeless after fire

Residents of a Delray Beach duplex are without a place to live after a fire swept through one side of their building in the 200 block of Southwest Fourth Avenue Sunday afternoon. “Heavy flames” were shooting from one of the units when firefighters arrived shortly before 3 p.m., according to Capt. Kevin Saxton of Delray Beach Fire Rescue...
One person hurt in Acreage helicopter crash
One person hurt in Acreage helicopter crash

One person was injured after a small helicopter crashed in the Acreage, Palm Beach County Fire Rescue said Sunday. The crash happened near Royal Ascot Estates, Fire Rescue officials said shortly before 4 p.m. The pilot was taken to a hospital for treatment. He was flying a “small experimental helicopter that had crashed while taking off from...
Boy with 10-pound tumor on face dies after surgery in Florida
Boy with 10-pound tumor on face dies after surgery in Florida

A 14-year-old boy who recently underwent surgery to remove a 10-pound tumor from his face has died, according to news reports. Emanuel Zayas developed the benign tumor while suffering from polyostotic fibrous dysplasia, a genetic disorder in which fibrous tissue begins to replace bone in the body. “Our condolences and prayers for Emanuel's family...
Jupiter Island sees rare armed robbery
Jupiter Island sees rare armed robbery

Jupiter Island, that tony strip of mansions that counts Tiger Woods and billionaire John Malone among its homeowners, experienced a rare violent crime this weekend. The Jupiter Island Public Safety Department said two young men wearing masks and “armed with an undetermined type handgun” robbed a Jupiter Island residence early Saturday....
Florida man dead after diving in underwater caves
Florida man dead after diving in underwater caves

A 50-year-old Florida man is dead after cave diving in Weeki Wachee Springs State Park this weekend, officials said. Davin Brannon, 53, of Dover, was diving in the Eagle’s Nest cave around noon Saturday when Hernando County Sheriff officials were called about a diver in distress. By the time crews arrived at the Chassahowitzka Wildlife Management...
More Stories