GOP senators work behind closed doors to repeal health care law


Senate Republicans are facing increasing criticism for ducking public scrutiny as they craft legislation to roll back the Affordable Care Act with little input from outside experts, patients, physicians and others most affected by health care legislation.

The GOP's secretive process marks a sharp departure from the traditional way the Senate has developed large, complex bills, which are often debated for years with multiple committee hearings to ensure broad input and careful analysis.

The closed-door approach, which is even more opaque than the process used earlier this year in the House, is all the more remarkable given the bill's likely effect on tens of millions of Americans, many of whom could see their health insurance protections substantially scaled back or eliminated altogether.

"It is deeply disturbing," said Erika Sward, assistant vice president of the American Lung Association. "Patients groups like ours need to make sure that our patients' needs for health care will be met. ... We can't do that if we can't see what is being proposed."

The lung association is among 120 patient groups that this week sent a letter to senior Republican senators expressing deep concerns about GOP proposals to fundamentally restructure Medicaid, which provides health coverage to more than 70 million poor Americans.

Although Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., has indicated he wants to vote on a bill in the next two weeks, Senate Republicans thus far haven't disclosed details of their Medicaid plans, or any other part of their health care legislation.

The Affordable Care Act repeal bill passed by the House in May, which has helped guide the Senate discussions, would slash federal health care assistance to low- and moderate-income Americans by nearly $1 trillion and increase the number of uninsured by 23 million over the next decade, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office.

Speaking to reporters at the Capitol this week, McConnell_who had previously vowed a much more open legislative process for the health care bill_denied there was any effort to conceal the Senate legislation.

"We'll let you see the bill when we finally release it," he said. "Nobody's hiding the ball here. You're free to ask anybody anything."

But even some GOP senators have voiced increasing frustration about the lack of public debate about the specifics of how Republicans plan to replace the health care law.

Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, lamented in an interview with online news site Vox this week that she couldn't even answer basic questions about the bill.

"None of us have actually seen language," she said. "My constituents expect me to know, and if we had utilized the process that goes through a committee, I would be able to answer ... my constituents' questions."

It remains unclear if any GOP lawmakers will try to hold up the health care legislation, however, as no Republican senator has yet demanded publicly that McConnell slow down or hold hearings on the legislation.

Before voting, the Senate, unlike the House, will have to wait for an independent analysis from the CBO.

The lack of public debate appears to be a deliberate strategy by McConnell and his lieutenants to minimize opportunities for critical evaluation of their bill, which is likely to be highly controversial.

Senate Finance Committee chairman Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, said holding public hearings about the legislation would only give Democrats more opportunity to attack the bill.

"We have zero cooperation from the Democrats," he said. "So getting it in public gives them a chance to get up and scream."

But interest in the GOP health care legislation extends far beyond Democratic politicians on Capitol Hill.

Major physician groups, hospitals, consumer advocates and organizations representing millions of patients with cancer, diabetes, heart disease and other serious illnesses have been pleading with Republican leaders for months to open up the process and listen to their concerns.

This week, a group of more than 15 patients groups_including the American Heart Association, the March of Dimes, the American Lung Association and the American Diabetes Association_asked McConnell's office to meet with them next week, proposing any time between Friday and June 22.

A representative from McConnell's office told them staff schedules were too busy, according to representatives of several of the organizations.

Dick Woodruff, vice president of the American Cancer Society's advocacy arm, said even when he and others have sat down with Republican congressional aides, it is often fruitless.

"The Senate staff generally don't know anything," Woodruff said. "There are so few people who understand what is going on that having meetings isn't particularly productive. ... This is such a closed process."

Another representative of a leading patient group compared the experience to "talking to a wall."

The concerns about the health care legislation extend to the broader public as well, polls suggest.

The House bill is extremely unpopular, with voters disapproving of the legislation by nearly 4 to 1.

Just 17 percent of registered voters backed the House bill in a recent nationwide poll, compared with 62 percent who disapprove of the legislation. This week, Trump reportedly called that legislation, which he celebrated six weeks ago in a Rose Garden ceremony, "mean."

Rutgers University professor Ross Baker, who has spent decades studying Congress, said lawmakers have traditionally used committee hearings and public debate over legislation to help educate voters and build support for complex and controversial legislation such as the civil rights bills of the 1960s.

That is what makes the current GOP effort so remarkable, he said. "I can't think of another piece of legislation of this scope and magnitude that affects so many people that has been drawn up behind such a dense veil of secrecy."


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Officials: Targeting welfare programs will help spur economic growth
Officials: Targeting welfare programs will help spur economic growth

Some House Republicans believe that Congress should cut Americans off government anti-poverty programs in part to help grow the national economy. “For us to achieve 3 percent GDP growth over the next 10 years from tax reform, we have to have welfare reform. We need people who are mentally and physically able to work to get into the workforce...
Trump to pitch tax plan; Treasury offers rosy estimate
Trump to pitch tax plan; Treasury offers rosy estimate

President Donald Trump on Wednesday will try to sell the American people on an unpopular Republican tax overhaul that his administration claims will generate a large part of $1.8 trillion in new revenue — a figure that a top Democratic lawmaker dismissed as “fake math.” The White House said Monday that Trump’s pitch will focus...
Trump accusers call for congressional investigation into alleged sexual misconduct
Trump accusers call for congressional investigation into alleged sexual misconduct

Update 3:15 p.m. Dec. 11: White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders denied the allegations levied against President Donald Trump in a news briefing Monday, telling reporters that the president has “addressed these accusations directly and denied all of these allegations.” "The American people knew this and voted...
The rise, striking fall of a Trump adviser
The rise, striking fall of a Trump adviser

A brass band played, fighter jets streaked the clear blue sky and a red carpet adorned the airport tarmac on the day in May 2016 when Vladimir Putin came to Athens for a visit.  "Mr. President, welcome to Greece," the Greek defense minister, Panos Kammenos, said in Russian as he smiled broadly and greeted a stone-faced Putin at the base...
8.8 million Americans face big tax hike if Republicans scrap the medical deduction
8.8 million Americans face big tax hike if Republicans scrap the medical deduction

Anne Hammer is one of millions of elderly Americans who could face a substantial tax hike in 2018 depending on the final negotiations over the Republican tax bill.  In her retirement community in Chestertown, Maryland, it's the big topic of conversation.  Hammer is 71. Like many seniors, her medical bills are piling up. There are doctor visits...
More Stories