U.S. Supreme Court takes second Fane Lozman case against Riviera Beach

In what U.S. Supreme Court watchers say may be a first, longtime Riviera Beach critic Fane Lozman on Monday learned he will get the chance to air another grievance against the city before the nation’s highest court.

Justices agreed to decide Lozman’s claims that the city retaliated against him by having him arrested him for exercising his First Amendment rights. Oral arguments are expected in March.

The case is different from the previous one that won Lozman a trip to the hallowed halls of justice in Washington. In 2013, he successfully persuaded justices that the city illegally seized his floating home and had it destroyed.

Chief Justice John Roberts called it his favorite case of the term. Justices agreed that just because a home floats it doesn’t mean it’s a boat. Lozman’s floating home shouldn’t have been seized under centuries-old maritime laws, the court ruled.

In the case that will be heard next year, Lozman, a self-made millionaire and former U.S. Marine, will argue that Riviera officials had him arrested for expressing views they didn’t want to hear. A federal jury in 2014 rejected his allegations that the city retaliated against him.

Claiming the decision would have been different had jurors not been told the arrest nullified his retaliation claims, Lozman appealed. His briefs to the high court were supported by the First Amendment Foundation and the Institute for Justice, both of which called it an issue of great public importance.

The organizations are interested in his case because other governments around the country have taken similar action to silence critics, Lozman said. “You should not be able to retaliate against people by making a bogus arrest,” he said.

The Palm Beach County State Attorney’s Office dropped charges of disorderly conduct and resisting arrest that Riviera Beach police filed against him after dragging him out of a city council meeting in 2006 — one of many he attended to accuse city officials of wrongdoing.

In addition to concerns that he is not alone, the case appears to be of interest to Supreme Court justices because appeals courts across the nation are split on the issue of whether an arrest bars a claim of retaliation. Had his lawsuit played out in a different part of the country where courts don’t believe an arrest bars First Amendment retaliation claims, the decision of the jury in South Florida may have been different, Lozman said. The divergent views among appellate courts paved the way for the high court to intervene.

“At this time in our nation’s history, when there’s been such an assault on the First Amendment, I’m just so grateful that the U.S. Supreme Court has allowed me to defend the First Amendment,” Lozman said. “It’s a special privilege we have as Americans.”

Attorneys representing Riviera Beach didn’t return a phone call for comment.

When a federal jury in Palm Beach County rejected Lozman’s claims, city officials declared the battle over. “It’s a vindication for the city,” then City Attorney Pamala Ryan said in a celebration, which now appears to have been premature. “No matter what happens in the future at least nine members of the community looked at all the facts and looked at everything that’s been done since Mr. Lozman started his reign of terror and said to the city, ‘You’ve done nothing wrong.’”

West Palm Beach attorney Ben Bedard, who represented the city, agreed. “I’m hoping he moves on with his life and leaves the city alone,” he said after the 2014 verdict.

Unlike during that trial, when Lozman represented himself, he will get some high-powered help when he appears before the Supreme Court. He will be represented by the Stanford Law School Supreme Court Litigation Clinic and Kerri Barsh, an attorney with the Miami law firm Greenberg Traurig.

Riviera Beach will also have some legal muscle of its own. In addition to Bedard, it will be represented by Washington attorney Shay Dvoretzky, a former law clerk to the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia who has appeared before the high court regularly in recent years.

While other plaintiffs have made more than one appearance before the Supreme Court, the respected SCOTUS blog said it typically has involved the same legal issue. Lozman may be the first to get invited back to argue a completely different kind of case, it wrote.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

It’s not all about the turkey: 9 things you probably didn't know about Thanksgiving
It’s not all about the turkey: 9 things you probably didn't know about Thanksgiving

Each year, Thanksgiving comes around with with the giddy anticipation of devoruing comfort food and spending some QT with loved ones, which reminds you just what what you are thankful for the most. The rich, deep history of this centuries-old tradition is woven into the United States' cultural fabric, yet, there are still many aspects of the holiday...
Debate settled: This is the right time to put up your Christmas tree
Debate settled: This is the right time to put up your Christmas tree

While it may never reach the level of controversy of how to hang the toilet paper roll or which way to load the dishwasher, the right time to put up the Christmas tree is a heavily-debated household topic. There are answers to this question that depend on everything from Prince Albert to the opinion of tree growers to something called Adelaide...
BREAKING: Man shot to death in Boynton Beach
BREAKING: Man shot to death in Boynton Beach

A man was shot and killed Sunday night at a Boynton Beach park where an estimated 50 people had assembled. The man, who was not identified by Boynton Beach Police, was found shortly after 8 p.m. when police responded to a call of shots fired at Caloosa Park, 1300 S.W. 35th Ave. Officers saw about 50 people quickly dispersing from a basketball court...
NEW: Protesters decry alleged animal abuse at Monkey Jungle
NEW: Protesters decry alleged animal abuse at Monkey Jungle

Closed since Hurricane Irma caused damage in September, Monkey Jungle is still drawing crowds. Unfortunately for the southern Miami-Dade County tourist attraction, the 50 people who showed up Sunday were there to protest what have been called "abysmal" conditions in which hundreds of animals live. A former employee recently accused the 80-year-old...
UPDATE: Toddler dies after being found in suburban Boca pond
UPDATE: Toddler dies after being found in suburban Boca pond

A toddler pulled from a pond in a suburban Boca Raton development Sunday afternoon has died, according to the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office. Teri Barbera, director of public information for the sheriff’s office, said detectives are investigating the events that led to the child ending up in the pond. Palm Beach County Fire Rescue crews...
More Stories